DCNU Superman vs AvX Thor

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
So you're asking me, if Emma/Cyclops, who have been shown to be above Thor (by beating him), if they continued beating him when he was beaten....would they beat him into beaten submission with a beating?

Yes, lol.

Originally posted by Damborgson
If Namor and Colossus had kept pounding on Gladiator he'd have lived through it?

Thor wasn't ko'd. He had his head up, his helmet on, and a very tightly grasped Mjolnir in his hands. Namor was just yanking him by the cape.

Which is my point. Emma koed Thor with some well place blows while smiling. Namor and Colossus POUNDED on Gladiator and he still wasn't out. Can't believe you don't see the difference in this, so freaking obvious.

Scarlet Witch should have just increased the odds so that The PF commits suicide. It would have fit perfectly with the writing in this arc imo....

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
I won't say 10/10 with ease....but I think he'd beat him, yes.

10/10?

Originally posted by carver9
Which is my point. Emma koed Thor with some well place blows while smiling. Namor and Colossus POUNDED on Gladiator and he still wasn't out. Can't believe you don't see the difference in this, so freaking obvious.

It is fairly obvious, to me anyway.

Emma is a *****.

Originally posted by carver9
10/10?

Nah. 6/10, maaaayyyybe even 7/10?

I guess I AM power sharing a bit between pre and post DCnU, so whilst DCnU Superman does NOT have the feats to suggest he can hang with pre, I think (and this is a feeling) that given time, based on the history of these reboots, that DCnU Supes will soon be up there.

Originally posted by carver9
Which is my point. Emma koed Thor with some well place blows while smiling. Namor and Colossus POUNDED on Gladiator and he still wasn't out. Can't believe you don't see the difference in this, so freaking obvious.

......what? That wasn't your point. You're making this up as you go lol.

She ko'd him after a rain of Phoenix shards tore through him. Then a brutal beat down. Thor was out, and was up again soon. Gladiator was put in a coma Carver. That's the difference.

At what point did Cyclops give up trying to talk to Gladiator?

Thor's skirmish with the Force incarnate > Gladiator's encounter with the hosts.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Nah. 6/10, maaaayyyybe even 7/10?

I guess I AM power sharing a bit between pre and post DCnU, so whilst DCnU Superman does NOT have the feats to suggest he can hang with pre, I think (and this is a feeling) that given time, based on the history of these reboots, that DCnU Supes will soon be up there.

So you changed your mind about DCNU beating Thor?

Originally posted by carver9
So you changed your mind about DCNU beating Thor?

Nope. Its still a split. He COULD beat Thor, and Thor COULD beat him. Either outcome is likely.

Pre-reboot Superman could also beat Thor, but its more likely that Superman beats him, but not by a huge amount.

Originally posted by Damborgson
......what? That wasn't your point. You're making this up as you go lol.

She ko'd him after a rain of Phoenix shards tore through him. Then a brutal beat down. Thor was out, and was up again soon. Gladiator was put in a coma Carver. That's the difference.

Gladiator was also pounded on by a Phoenix user that is amped off of Cytorrak powers and Namor as well. You clinging on to Emma, making her seem similar to two Phoenix users (and one of them is more powerful than her) is making you look foolish. You can't compare what Glads went through to what Thor went though...completely different. Thor got dropped and again, if she kept pounding (one user) he probably would have died.

Lulz at this thread. Thor wins. Now if it was Avengers Assemble Thor..........................

Thor already experienced worse than Gladiator did in this arc and recovered faster.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Nope. Its still a split. He COULD beat Thor, and Thor COULD beat him. Either outcome is likely.

Pre-reboot Superman could also beat Thor, but its more likely that Superman beats him, but not by a huge amount.

So how many wins would you give reboot Supes over pre reboot Superman.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Thor already experienced worse than Gladiator did in this arc and recovered faster.

Are you referring to the Phoenix blasting Thor.?

Originally posted by carver9
Are you referring to the Phoenix blasting Thor.?

Thor dealt with the full force three times and managed to clip its wing and harm the entity itself.

That blows Gladiator's encounter out of the water.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Thor dealt with the full force three times and managed to clip its wing and harm the entity itself.

That blows Gladiator's encounter out of the water.

Didn't Ms. Marvel and some other Avengers also withstood attacks from a full powered Phoenix? Are you putting everyone that withstood attacks from this Phoenix above Glads?

I haven't read the comics.

But yes and yes.

Originally posted by carver9
Didn't Ms. Marvel and some other Avengers also withstood attacks from a full powered Phoenix? Are you putting everyone that withstood attacks from this Phoenix above Glads?

Ms. Marvel and other Avengers didn't take an attack from the Phoenix and then recover enough to actually muster an attack against the Phoenix and damage them on their own. Pretty obvious Thor fared the best against the Force itself out of his teammates.