Hulks hardest punch/hit vs Supermans hardest punch/hit

Who's is greater?

1.highest feat

2. On average

One of a weaker version of Hulk's strongest punches obliterated an asteroid twice as big as Earth.

I don't read Superman, but I don't know if he's surpassed that.

I think SM best punch shattered both time and space.

Come again? What did he do?

In that Hulk feat he was aided by the force of being propelled into orbit

I know, but he still punched an asteroid twice as large as Earth and killed it. Superman's punches have been aided by his flight. Same concept. Like when he flew into that Dark Matter Moon.

Flight is part of supermans power so its not a outside aid.

No, but it's still aid. As many of the big punches, the moon for example wouldn't have been possible to pull off without his flight.

So its still part of his power set. Taking his flight away hampers a lot of his punching feats,

Just once I'd like to see someone post the full version of that Hulk asteroid breaking scene from start to finish. Only seen and have the most hyper abridged panels of the ep, the scientist detecting it, then the scene of hulk in the midst of shattering it. No lead-up or explanation of how Hulk got outfitted, or warned of what the scientist saw, or got to launching point or anything.

Carver, perhaps you would be willing to supply that?

In the meantime, the following are perennial favorites that should be shared in a thread like this:

cliff shaker
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=13786236

cardboard punch
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cl_5UwS57X8

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Source 1: DC Comics Presents #29, Volume 1 (scan)
Writer: Len Wein
Penciller: Jim Starlin
Date: January 1981
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://dc.wikia.com/wiki/DC_Comics_Presents_Vol_1_29

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Source 2: Justice League Unlimited (YouTube clip)
Episode: "Destroyer"
Writer: Dwayne McDuffie
Director: Joaquim dos Santos
U.S. AirDate: May 13, 2006
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Justice_League_episodes

Originally posted by Nihilist
So its still part of his power set. Taking his flight away hampers a lot of his punching feats,

That's the point I'm making. Taking away Clark's flight takes away a lot of his feats. Taking that feat from Hulk by saying he had help in the form of propulsion means you do the same for Superman, as he has help in the form of propulsion. Self propulsion or not, he wouldn't have been able to pull a lot of that off without being able to fly.

Argue all you want, this thread is about they've done under their own powers without any outside aid whatsoever.

No it's not. You didn't specify that. You just said highest feats and on average. So the asteroid buster counts.

There's also the one where Hulk punched a hole through time or through dimensions, I can't remember which.

Originally posted by KingD19
That's the point I'm making. Taking away Clark's flight takes away a lot of his feats. Taking that feat from Hulk by saying he had help in the form of propulsion means you do the same for Superman, as he has help in the form of propulsion. Self propulsion or not, he wouldn't have been able to pull a lot of that off without being able to fly.

On a related note, this is why, no matter how powerful he gets, you've never seen Hulk move a planet, and likely never will.

Note, as a counterpoint, without what we consider "true" comic book flight, how hokey you need to make a scene for a non-flier to perform a feat involving the truly "big" stuff:

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/attachment.php?s=&postid=13842190

That "invisible" jet is horribly drawn, and yeah. Can't move a planet while you're standing on it.

Originally posted by KingD19
No it's not. You didn't specify that. You just said highest feats and on average. So the asteroid buster counts.

There's also the one where Hulk punched a hole through time or through dimensions, I can't remember which.

Fact is He needed to be shot in air like that otherwise he would of just jumped.

you guys really think hulk can destroy the asteroid without his strength?

Originally posted by dynamix
you guys really think hulk can destroy the asteroid without his strength?

How much did it aid him? To what extent we don't know, but it certain I did aid him in some way

Originally posted by KingD19
I know, but he still punched an asteroid twice as large as Earth and killed it. Superman's punches have been aided by his flight. Same concept. Like when he flew into that Dark Matter Moon.

It isn't the same thing. First, you would have to prove that Superman's flight gives him any more assistance than say his shoulder, his back or his leg when he throws a punch.

Hulk had outside help; Superman throws those punches under his own power.

@Blue

Don't have time to post all of it, at work but Hulk said he had a LITTLE help from the springs that wad created to help him spring out of Earth orbit. A LITTLE bit of help and he destroyed an object twice the size of Earth. So basically, without the help, since he only received just a LITTLE bit of help, with the propellers, he would have laid waste to Earth under his own power.

http://i30.photobucket.com/albums/c324/Hulk3389/MCP-52-30.jpg

The propellers were used to get him out of orbit, his strength destroyed the asteroid.