Orion Vs DCnU Helspont

Started by Philosophía3 pages

Originally posted by ODG
Not really.
Not really what? Helspont backhanded Superman into unconsciousness. This Superman is [at least strength and endurance/durability] superior to pre-Flashpoint Superman.

None of that is debatable.

Originally posted by ODG
Not surprising since he was being assaulted by her Blue Flame, which would render using that fight unreliable (at best) for measuring respective power levels.
I hope you're not implying a weakness explotation here just because it's called "Blue Flame", because that would be borderline idiotic.

Originally posted by ODG
Not really. Orion's got better feats.
Orion's got better feats than casually backhanding a [superior] Superman into unconsciousness

Originally posted by Philosophía
Not really what? Helspont backhanded Superman into unconsciousness. This Superman is [at least strength and endurance/durability] superior to pre-Flashpoint Superman.

None of that is debatable.

I hope you're not implying a weakness explotation here just because it's called "Blue Flame", because that would be borderline idiotic.

Orion's got better feats than casually backhanding a [superior] Superman into unconsciousness

I'm not interested in discussing the implications of an unreleased comic, particularly when what we've seen makes evident that DCnU Superman is pushing himself past the levels he previously operated on... which included the Helspont fight.

You're right, it really isn't.

Don't be so obscenely obtuse.

Orion's got better feats than someone who backhanded DCnU Superman (who apparently hasn't been pushing himself to his heights) and was challenged/embarassed by Grifter.

Originally posted by ODG
I'm not interested in discussing the implications of an unreleased comic, particularly when what we've seen makes evident that DCnU Superman is pushing himself past the levels he previously operated on... which included the Helspont fight.
Where in the preview did you see Superman pushing himself? He lifted the Earth for 5 days, out of the sun and he barely worked a sweat. That's not pushing himself, that's just showing what he can casually do right now [which include the Helspont fight]. It is clearly visible that he pushed himself against Helspont much more than he did in order to perform this feat. [under the same writer - which is good to remember]

Thus the "is that it?" part, and needing to get extradimensional mass to start and actually challenge him - which Superman didn't want to do, so as not to endanger the Earth.

This is Superman's base level - his casual level, sort to speak. Barely working a sweat. Pushing himself will come later.

Originally posted by ODG
Don't be so obscenely obtuse.
Right back at you. Just because its name is "blue flame" doesn't mean that it's a weakness impediment. It wasn't an impediment when J'onn attacked her physically, eventough she is glowing with that energy. It wasn't stated as a weakness at any point - in fact, it was explicitly put an emphasis on how this was just a fraction of Helspont's power which took down J'onn, which clearly points out that it's the potency of the attack which downed him, and not some imaginary weakness exploitation.

You don't have a leg to stand on, be serious here.

Originally posted by ODG
Orion's got better feats than someone who backhanded DCnU Superman (who apparently hasn't been pushing himself to his heights)
See above.

Originally posted by Philosophía
Where in the preview did you see Superman pushing himself? He lifted the Earth for 5 days, out of the sun and he barely worked a sweat. That's not pushing himself, that's just showing what he can casually do right now [which include the Helspont fight]. It is clearly visible that he pushed himself against Helspont much more than he did in order to perform this feat.

Thus the "is that it?" part, and needing to get extradimensional mass to start and actually challenge him - which Superman didn't want to do, so as not to endanger the Earth.

This is Superman's base level - his casual level, sort to speak. Barely working a sweat. Pushing himself will come later.

My flat statement that I am not interested in discussing an unpublished comic was a flat statement. Moreover, I don't need to be yelled at by any mods over it. Moreover, it is apparent that DCnU Superman is accessing new levels of power previously not accessed before. Specifically because of Helspont.
Originally posted by Philosophía
Right back at you. Just because it's name is "blue flame" doesn't mean that it's a weakness impediment. It wasn't an impediment when J'onn attacked her physically, eventough she is glowing with that energy. It wasn's stated as a weakness at any point - in fact, it was explicitly put an emphasis on how this was just a fraction of Helspont's power which took down J'onn, which clearly points out that it's the potency of the attack which downed him, and not some imaginary weakness exploitation.
Your embellishment is wholly wasted. And I'll freely dismiss the ignorance of your reading of that fight. J'onn punching someone in the face and being capable of drawing blood is not dispositive of his fire weakness being in play. Especially not when that enemy's face isn't even covered in fire or being meaningfully projected outwards from her body (until it actually was in a focused blast). And him being engulfed in blue flames was not imaginary.
Originally posted by Philosophía
You don't have a leg to stand on, be serious here.

See above.

Right back at you.

This discussion can end here. If the level of willful ignorance you're approaching DCnU J'onn is only a hint at what I'd have to deal with when it comes to Helspont, I'll pass. I'm not interested in the blatant reverse projection you're utilizing no matter how intriguing the notion of a planetary+++ Grifter might be.

Originally posted by ODG
Moreover, it is apparent that DCnU Superman is accessing new levels of power previously not accessed before. Specifically because of Helspont. Your embellishment is wholly wasted.
Repeating the same thing doesn't make it true. Superman wasn't pushing himself, this was explicitly shown ("the sole drop of sweat after 5 days of bench-pressing Earth out of the sun"😉 and stated ("is that it?"😉 and implied to need more in order to do so ("Going forward, the only way to aproximate the tonnage you need to test the upper limits of your strength, would necessitate tapping directly into a pan-dimensional wormhole" [as if we would need any more statements that they haven't reached his baseline limit].

You're wrong, based on the evidence we have until now.

You're also baseless about J'onn, and deflect my arguments "but his fists didn't go through the 'blue fire' she was glowing with! I'll ignore everything else you said!". It is not regular fire - it is energy with diffrent applications. Just because it's called "blue fire" doesn't mean it's fire in the common sense, nor that it would affect J'onn the same way. It wasn't even hinted at - and it affecting him was directly correlated to its potency [ie just a fraction of Helspont's power]. You're baseless. You're wrong about his one, too.

Nothing more needs to be said. And unless something different is said on Wednesday, you'll continue to be wrong.

Originally posted by Philosophía
Repeating the same thing doesn't make it true. Superman wasn't pushing himself, this was explicitly shown ("the sole drop of sweat after 5 days of bench-pressing Earth out of the sun"😉 and stated ("is that it?"😉 and implied to need more in order to do so ("Going forward, the only way to aproximate the tonnage you need to test the upper limits of your strength, would necessitate tapping directly into a pan-dimensional wormhole" [as if we would need any more statements that they haven't reached his baseline limit].

You're wrong, based on the evidence we have until now.

Just because you use the phrase, "push yourself," as only suggesting significant exertion accompanied by visible fatigue and loads of sweat, doesn't mean I do or did. Superman is pushing himself to access new levels of power he's not accessed previously.

And that is readily apparent, based on the evidence we have until now.

Originally posted by Philosophía
You're also baseless about J'onn, and deflect my arguments "but his fists didn't go through the 'blue fire' she was glowing with! I'll ignore everything else you said!". It is not regular fire - it is energy with diffrent applications. Just because it's called "blue fire" doesn't mean it's fire in the common sense, nor that it would affect J'onn the same way. It wasn't even hinted at - and it affecting him was directly correlated to its potency [ie just a fraction of Helspont's power]. You're baseless. You're wrong about his one, too.

Nothing more needs to be said. And unless something different is said on Wednesday, you'll continue to be wrong.

I'm sorry you felt the need to defend your inaccurate description, "wasn't an impediment when J'onn attacked her physically, eventough she is glowing with that energy." But you bungled that yourself. When you have proof that the Blue Flame displays no similarities to fire and is meaningless to those who are weak to fire, let us know. I'm not here to make your argument though. And I don't need an author pandering to us with a narrative or character statement reminding us of J'onn's weakness to fire in the same instance where he gets blasted by Blue Flame to be reminded of same. You do.

Nothing more needs to be said, true. And everything I've stated takes into account what we've seen in previews. If Grifter is revealed to have planetary+++ telekinesis on Wednesday, I will concede you were right all along though. That much is true.

Originally posted by ODG
Just because you use the phrase, "push yourself," as only suggesting significant exertion accompanied by visible fatigue and loads of sweat, doesn't mean I do or did. Superman is pushing himself to access new levels of power he's not accessed previously.
😂

ODG, ladies and gentlemen, giving new meanings to the term "push oneself". How is Superman pushing himself to access new levels of power -- by not pushing himself, and barely working a sweat after 5 days of doing something that by his own words is shit "is that it?", by his physical state being with "barely a drop of sweat" and by the scientist's own words,not testing his limits "the only way to aproximate the tonnage you need to test the upper limits of your strength, would necessitate tapping directly into a pan-dimensional wormhole". OneDumb logic at work. 👆

As I was writing this post, I picked up a pencil from the desk. Started bench-pressing it. I'll do this for a couple of hours, and when I work up a sweat, I know I've done it - I've finally reached levels of power I've not accessed before.

Same old ODG.

Superman was never shown accesing new levels of power - he hadn't even reached his current, baseline limits. The comic literally spells it out for you.

Originally posted by ODG
And that is readily apparent, based on the evidence we have until now. I'm sorry you felt the need to defend your inaccurate description, "wasn't an impediment when J'onn attacked her physically, eventough she is glowing with that energy." But you bungled that yourself. When you have proof that the Blue Flame displays no similarities to fire and is meaningless to those who are weak to fire, let us know. I'm not here to make your argument though. And I don't need an author pandering to us with a narrative or character statement reminding us of J'onn's weakness to fire in the same instance where he gets blasted by Blue Flame to be reminded of same. You do.
You need to prove that an alien, blue energy source activated J'onn's weakness, when literally nothing in the issue even hints that's the case. Just because an alien energy source with various capabilities is called "blue flame" isn't an argument. Just in case people don't think I'm omitting facts, here is the entire scene:

Now prove that the energy blast had anything to do with exploiting J'onn's weakness, and not the potecy of the blast itself. What's next? J'onn is weak to Kyle's energy because he is the "Torch bearer"?

Why do you think constantly mentioning Grifter means anything? Do you think the name "Grifter" means that he can't give Helspont problems [which he has]?

Originally posted by Philosophía
😂

ODG, ladies and gentlemen, giving new meanings to the term "push oneself". How is Superman pushing himself to access new levels of power -- by not pushing himself, and barely working a sweat after 5 days of doing something that by his own words is shit "is that it?", by his physical state being with "barely a drop of sweat" and by the scientist's own words,not testing his limits "the only way to aproximate the tonnage you need to test the upper limits of your strength, would necessitate tapping directly into a pan-dimensional wormhole". OneDumb logic at work. 👆

As I was writing this post, I picked up a pencil from the desk. Started bench-pressing it. I'll do this for a couple of hours, and when I work up a sweat, I know I've done it - I've finally reached levels of power I've not accessed before.

Same old ODG.

Your flippancy is wholly wasted. It's apparent that you refuse to even address what I've plainly stated. And I understand that, because it provides you no egress for your narrow-minded argument. But insulting my grasp of the English language to manufacture excuses for pretending Superman wasn't pushing himself to previously unseen levels of power is a rather comical and pitiable ploy.
Originally posted by Philosophía
Superman was never shown accesing new levels of power - he hadn't even reached his current, baseline limits. The comic literally spells it out for you.
From what I've seen of an unreleased comic, that's exactly what was spelled out. But we both should accept that statements such as, "-- made me realize I need to push myself further than I have before" and "This whole exhaustion thing feels kind of... liberating" should be read in their fullest context, i.e., when the comic comes out.
Originally posted by Philosophía
You need to prove that an alien, blue energy source activated J'onn's weakness, when literally nothing in the issue even hints that's the case. Just because an alien energy source with various capabilities is called "blue flame" isn't an argument. Just in case people don't think I'm omitting facts, here is the entire scene:

Now prove that the energy blast had anything to do with exploiting J'onn's weakness, and not the potecy of the blast itself. What's next? J'onn is weak to Kyle's energy because he is the "Torch bearer"?

Nobody accused you of omitting facts. You just blundered when you mentioned that J'onn was just fine attacking her "eventhough she was glowing with that energy" when she actually wasn't. Your attempt to shift the burden of proof on to me only demonstrates that you've utterly eschewed common sense deduction.

Mentioning GLs does provide a rather fortuitous opportunity for elaboration though. I can, in fact, prove that Green Lantern energy can have nothing to do with fire and flame effects. Can you do the same with the Blue Flame? No. I can, in fact, use simple common sense and perceive that when GLs wield their energy to simulate fire and flame, it will actually be devastatingly hot and cause burns. Can you do the same with the Blue Flame? Apparently, not. Common sense fails you in this regard (or is it the other way around?).

It looks like fire. It's called the "Blue Flame." And J'onn becomes a little fetal b1tch when he's engulfed in special fire, much less normal fire. I'm not entertaining your attempts to gloss over that just so you can make unflattering comparisons between characters.

Originally posted by Philosophía
Why do you think constantly mentioning Grifter means anything? Do you think the name "Grifter" means that he can't give Helspont problems [which he has]?
We both know exactly why I repeat it. However far you end up carrying this irresponsible reverse projection is on you though. If it turns out Grifter's got power levels rivaling/exceeding Superman's with the way he challenged/toppled Helspont, I will concede that all your arguments are correct.

And since we're doing little else but repeating ourselves, this conversation has run thin.

Guys, for the time being, please refrain from discussing previews of comics.

Wait til the issue comes out, then have at it.

taking helspont