Sadako of Girth
Extreme Mode
Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Yeah but if you didn't like his later work, you would just say that. End of. A lot of people hated Star Trek TNG, and only loved the Original.Did Rodenberry get anywhere near the hate that Lucas gets? Nope.
But people continually trash Lucas for the PT, the CW Series, giving money to charity even! He just can't move without someone trashing him nowadays. And a lot of it comes from supposed "beloved fans" of the OT!
Well in fairness Roddenberry left his original work alone.
Look how many ST fans hated the last one because of a little parallel universe continuity.
Oh I do. Well I think the CW series was infantile and was a big disappointment because it seemed to pander unneccessarily to trends in mass marketed generic trendism and it messed with virtually every unwritten law that made SW good originally. No sense of danger or character depth (On the 1st season alone, I base this: Granted) or grit/character. Even visually: Why is it assumed that people wouldn't like animated SW unless they have oversized pie eyes and a de-gritted/'filtered for cuddly' design?
(Is the sterility and cutesiness really neccesary? In ANH we saw burned skeletons and planetary genocide.. ROTS saw the murdering of Jedi Kids. And we grew up fine.)
I still will always love the OT, and feel disappointed when its messed with unneccesarily.
The totally extraneous NOOOOOO in ROTJ that ruined the tension in one of the sagas most climactic, most beautiful moment...the Jabba-hiring-a-Yazzum-fronted-chicago-blues band for the redone more generic-to-earth version of a song that sounded alien enough in the 1st place..! But recorrected Lightsabres, blinking Ewoks, Recorrected Yoda in TPM....im all for it.
That "Noooooo" and the redone Jabba's hideout bit pissed me off having those as the only HD versions avaliable on Bluray. (I do sympathise with the frustration other fans feel in that regard and they shouldn't be demonised for failing to blindly accept whatever is put in front of them.) Many of them will fight to the death to defend SW against real hateful naysayers online..give em a break. They're fans.