Marek vs. Luke

Nephthys
For the record, I'm deliberating if I consider the novels account of his atmospheric re-entry canon or not. It does contradict the game directly. And I consider the game as the original source of TFU since thats what it was originally conceived as. Everything else simply expands upon the original games.

Yeah, the same stuff happened with TFU and its game, book, and graphic novel. They're all equal level canon, so I personally pull from all the above.

But I give you points for your devious squirming. You make me proud. 👆

Yeah, so did I. But, I mean all those things contradict the **** out of each other. So i have no idea what whats canonically, but if I had to choose authoritatively, I would go with the games.

Well of course you would.

I can see an argument for the novels (I guess), but imo its similar to the rule about the movies. The games are the original source, so they should be the defining canon.

Originally posted by Nephthys
I can see an argument for the novels (I guess), but imo its similar to the rule about the movies. The games are the original source, so they should be the defining canon.

It's nowhere near as clear cut. The supremacy of the films over all other canon is written explicitly into the canon hierarchy; here, the game, book, and graphic novel are all equally canon with no hierarchy established between them.

I said similar.

I said gay (as in you are). :3
For what it's worth, he disintegrates the Salvation in the Wii!TFU2.

But the wii sucks and isn't a real console so it doesn't count.

Plus he... blows it up or something. Theres an explosion.

Originally posted by Nephthys
But the wii sucks and isn't a real console so it doesn't count.

Plus he... blows it up or something. Theres an explosion.

Yep, a giant Force repulse.