Emperor Palpatine -vs- Emperor Vitiate

Indeed, but before it has been conclusively determined I must consult and confirm or interpret the source for this:

Nai
When we assume, that the Force did shift towards the Dark Side, than Plagueis delivers the basic idea himself:

"But had Sith like Naga Sadow and Exar Kun genuinely been more powerful, or had they benefited from the fact that the dark side had been more prominent in those bygone eras?" - Darth Plagueis, iBook, Chapter 5, p.65

And after the shift occured, the first thing Plagueis does is demonstrating his - apparently new - ability to bring beings back from the other side of the wall of death unaided.

Sidious is far too frail as of ROTJ to wield a lightsaber any better than Vitiate. So this comes down to Force Abilities, where I believe Vitiate would get the edge.

However, Sidious as of Dark Empire could probably take Vitiate down a few notches.

I can't decide.

Any form of Sidious will defeat Vitshit.

The original will always be superior to the rehash every time.

Palpatine > Vitiate.

Originally posted by AncientPower
The original will always be superior to the rehash every time.

Palpatine > Vitiate.

Palpatine often win V.S vitiate through light saber meaning... And here... He don't have a light saber it change everythings !!!! RotJ sidious is less polyvalent than RotS one....

Both Are at the quasi same level of insame power exept thna Vitiate is clearkly the more powerfull but his power are unaturals compared to sidious, and sidous have also a natural use of his power...

Originally posted by AncientPower
The original will always be superior to the rehash every time.

Palpatine > Vitiate.

Character quality wise no one can deny this fact.

However, power wise I agree with this(though I'm not sure if Newguy is being sincere):

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Sidious is far too frail as of ROTJ to wield a lightsaber any better than Vitiate. So this comes down to Force Abilities, where I believe Vitiate would get the edge.

I doubt that as I don't think Vitiate can pull out anything that will either work or he can do better than Sidious.

Originally posted by Lord Stark
Any form of Sidious will defeat Vitshit.

Dying Sidious from DE.

Originally posted by Sinious
Character quality wise no one can deny this fact.

However, power wise I agree with this(though I'm not sure if Newguy is being sincere):

It's not insincerity, it's simply two years outdated.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
It's not insincerity, it's simply two years outdated.

And for a second I thought we could be friends. 🙁

Originally posted by AncientPower
I doubt that as I don't think Vitiate can pull out anything that will either work or he can do better than Sidious.

And I doubt that I don't think than Plaptine have some shit really effectiv against Vitiate if that's the case...

Vitiate have this problem of energy, he need ernegy to destroy the entire universe and he don't want to waste it in just a combat... He is gathering a lot and a lot of energy/power.

But he don't use it, If he were able to use this power and then regaining immediatly (as sidious does because his power are naturals...)
Then DE sidious force storm will look so tiny !!!

He is ten time more pwoerfull than DE sidious !!!!!!!! But he can't regain his power fater a missv use of it !!! That's the difference.. In anyway... If he use all his power against sidious he just destroy the star system (lol)
And sidious Using his full power destroy the entire continent (lol)

They satelmate each other !!!! Each one have the potential to just over power the ennemy defenses !!!!

Originally posted by Sinious
And for a second I thought we could be friends. 🙁

Do you really think RotJ Sidious can't use his lightsaber?

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Do you really think RotJ Sidious can't use his lightsaber?

Of course I don't. He most likely isnt as good as he was in ROTS but it shouldn't matter.

A Sith Lord ten times more powerful than the most powerful Sith Lord of all time as confirmed on every possible level from a trading card to Lucas himself.

Seems legit.

@Post below me:

No one knows.

I'm not following you. What exactly is the debate here?

Originally posted by NewGuy01

What are you talking about?

I think he means Plagueis > all sith and Sidious = Plagueis x 10

According to Chiste that is logical.

Hm.