Silver Surfer vs Superman Power Competition

Started by Rage.Of.Olympus10 pages
Originally posted by abhilegend
Yeah, thor was also burned by sun. Marvel heralds are so fragile!!!

Apparently. When did the Sun burn Thor?

Originally posted by Newjak
I quote my post again to give you one last chance to really look at it and look at the scan again.

After doing that instead of trying to play the political comic book heroes game actually take a second to figure out at no point does Surfer say anything about fighting through the solar plasma being a challenge for him, it only says and I repeat.

If the Surfer had wanted to he could have gone through it but decided not to.

That's all your scan really says.


That's what I said in my post too. Not sure what is being argued here. Surfer said "I could fight my way through solar plasma" and that's it. Nowhere did I argue that surfer would be hurt or struggle to "fight" through plasma. You know like how rookie lanterns "fight" through solar plasma

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v58/Desaad/Hal%20Jordan/TalesofGLCorpsAnnual01-13.jpg

Oops........

Seriously using suns and shit to prove surfer is immune to HV is lolworthy. Surfer was knocked out by smashing into a speeding ship once and in the next issue he was fighting inside a black hole. He is inconsistent like that like every other character.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Apparently. When did the Sun burn Thor?

Do you really want me to answer that rage? It was in one of bendis' avengers book around Osborn being Super adaptoid and all that shit. Pretty stupid but hey, quasar was unable to stand the heat of the photosphere of the sun.

Originally posted by abhilegend
That's what I said in my post too. Not sure what is being argued here. Surfer said "I could fight my way through solar plasma" and that's it. Nowhere did I argue that surfer would be hurt or struggle to "fight" through plasma. You know like how rookie lanterns "fight" through solar plasma

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v58/Desaad/Hal%20Jordan/TalesofGLCorpsAnnual01-13.jpg

Oops........

Seriously using suns and shit to prove surfer is immune to HV is lolworthy. Surfer was knocked out by smashing into a speeding ship once and in the next issue he was fighting inside a black hole. He is inconsistent like that like every other character.

The angle you're trying to play with this is lolwourthy.

You're obviously trying to make a strenuous connection with the scan you're posting and to a rookie GL.

But once again it's a useless comparison cause you don't know how much energy Surfer would have had to exert to actually overcome the effect.

All the scan says and I repeat Surfer could have over come it but instead chose not to.

You really can't form the argument you are trying to make with that scan.

The only things you can confer from that scan is that Solar Palsma doesn't hurt Surfer and that he can over come it should he choose to. That's it.

Oh and he can breath in space and survive in it.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Do you really want me to answer that rage? It was in one of bendis' avengers book around Osborn being Super adaptoid and all that shit. Pretty stupid but hey, quasar was unable to stand the heat of the photosphere of the sun.

Why wouldn't I? If it happened, it happened, me not liking it won't change anything. Was this in New Avenger's or something? I really can't recall the instance you're talking about.

Yeah, will shit happens. Under Bendis, Sentry couldn't endure the center of the Sun for long. Under some writers, even Cosmic's are around more or less planet busting. Not everyone has heralds surviving Stars, just the nature of the beast.

Silver Surfer should be able to to duplicate anything power wise that Superman can do but the same can't be said about Superman with SS powers.

Originally posted by abhilegend
That's what I said in my post too. Not sure what is being argued here. Surfer said "I could fight my way through solar plasma" and that's it. Nowhere did I argue that surfer would be hurt or struggle to "fight" through plasma. You know like how rookie lanterns "fight" through solar plasma

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v58/Desaad/Hal%20Jordan/TalesofGLCorpsAnnual01-13.jpg

Oops........

Seriously using suns and shit to prove surfer is immune to HV is lolworthy. Surfer was knocked out by smashing into a speeding ship once and in the next issue he was fighting inside a black hole. He is inconsistent like that like every other character.

So your own scan shows your inability to comprehend then you downplay the sun. LOL.

Re: Re: Silver Surfer vs Superman Power Competition

Originally posted by abhilegend
1.Strength: Superman and surfer is not even close in this department.
2.Speed: Superman, vastly superior in combat speed and a clear edge in flight speed.
3.Intellegence: Superman, what has surfer actually done to denote he is anywhere near superman in intelligence?
4.Durability: Edge to superman overall, edge to surfer in piercing durability.
5.Stamina: Superman.
6.Reflexes: Superman
7.Agility: Superman
8.Energy Blasts: Split
9.Versatility: Surfer

Who takes it?: Superman beats the shit out of surfer.

You truly are a moron who doesn't read comics and clearly not surfer comics. Superman has zero flight speed that even comes close to Surfer's best. In fact, what is superman best flight speed? Stamina Superman.. WTF... When has surfer ever gotten tired.. elaborate please. Energy blasts split LULZ... What the F are you basing this load of turd on.

Originally posted by abhilegend
I assumed they took 1 minute to reach there, which given how quickly they went is a very large amount of time.
He also uses space-warps and black holes to get there if the distance is large enough. Like this

http://img516.imageshack.us/img516/7020/ssenslavers06vb5.jpg

Anyway that million lightyears trip is the best feat he has and that is how we can calculate his flight speed, not some hypothetical scenario where he crosses universe and shit to find planets for galactus and thus is faster than anybody.

It took a minute.. Please post the narration that says a minute and I'm still waiting on the narration that talks about the exact distance again.

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
You truly are a moron who doesn't read comics and clearly not surfer comics. Superman has zero flight speed that even comes close to Surfer's best. In fact, what is superman best flight speed? Stamina Superman.. WTF... When has surfer ever gotten tired.. elaborate please. Energy blasts split LULZ... What the F are you basing this load of turd on.
Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
It took a minute.. Please post the narration that says a minute and I'm still waiting on the narration that talks about the exact distance again.

😂
Originally posted by Newjak
The angle you're trying to play with this is lolwourthy.

You're obviously trying to make a strenuous connection with the scan you're posting and to a rookie GL.

But once again it's a useless comparison cause you don't know how much energy Surfer would have had to exert to actually overcome the effect.

All the scan says and I repeat Surfer could have over come it but instead chose not to.

You really can't form the argument you are trying to make with that scan.

The only things you can confer from that scan is that Solar Palsma doesn't hurt Surfer and that he can over come it should he choose to. That's it.

Oh and he can breath in space and survive in it.


Absolutely "lolwourthy", lolwourthy I say.

He has to fight through solar plasma, so he's obviously not immune to heat as was the intention of the poster. That's all. I don't care if surfer farts and that makes him fight through solar plasma. That would still be below rookie GLs effortlessly going through suns.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Why wouldn't I? If it happened, it happened, me not liking it won't change anything. Was this in New Avenger's or something? I really can't recall the instance you're talking about.

Yeah, will shit happens. Under Bendis, Sentry couldn't endure the center of the Sun for long. Under some writers, even Cosmic's are around more or less planet busting. Not everyone has heralds surviving Stars, just the nature of the beast.

I would find the scans. No it was the main avengers title.

Yeah, writers are stupid sometimes.

Can you perhaps give me an issue number or something? Or an arc name? I remember Osborn getting the ability to absorb powers and shit, but IIRC, it was more of a Luke Cage and gang scuffle. Don't even recall Thor appearing. Have no idea why he'd be at the Sun of all places.

😗

http://i49.tinypic.com/2i9roe1.jpg

that's how he showers each morning

I find it kind of funny that back in the day Stan Lee had Thor strap a Nuclear device to his chest (Was testing it for the army and was fine) yet ran away from bullets.

Ego unleashed a blast at Galactus that destroyed a Solar System IIRC and Thor recovered in better shape from that then a mortar round or some shit.

His vulnerability to artillery specifically didn't make a lick of sense. I know why Lee did it, he just went about it in a bad way imo.

Off topic, but something that I thought off randomly.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Can you perhaps give me an issue number or something? Or an arc name? I remember Osborn getting the ability to absorb powers and shit, but IIRC, it was more of a Luke Cage and gang scuffle. Don't even recall Thor appearing. Have no idea why he'd be at the Sun of all places.

Like I said, its going to take awhile. Its no big deal obviously, so I chalked it up to bendis and his stupidity and forgot about the issue.
Originally posted by vince_slice
😗

http://i49.tinypic.com/2i9roe1.jpg


Yeah, characters are in-consistent. Who'd have thought of that? Also surfer gets his powers fueled by star light.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
I find it kind of funny that back in the day Stan Lee had Thor strap a Nuclear device to his chest (Was testing it for the army and was fine) yet ran away from bullets.

Ego unleashed a blast at Galactus that destroyed a Solar System IIRC and Thor recovered in better shape from that then a mortar round or some shit.

His vulnerability to artillery specifically didn't make a lick of sense. I know why Lee did it, he just went about it in a bad way imo.

Off topic, but something that I thought off randomly.


Ego destroyed planetoids rage................

I don't know, it's been a while. Do you have the scans?

I remember the plot and scenes but some of the details are murky. I recall them following a trail of dead planets to Galactus' location and Ego unleashing a blast at the World Eater that was destroying what looked like planetary bodies similar to his person.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Like I said, its going to take awhile. Its no big deal obviously, so I chalked it up to bendis and his stupidity and forgot about the issue.

I can understand your position, but you can't just make a claim like that and leave it be. Otherwise, what's to stop us from thinking you just made it all up?

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
I don't know, it's been a while. Do you have the scans?

I remember the plot and scenes but some of the details are murky. I recall them following a trail of dead planets to Galactus' location and Ego unleashing a blast at the World Eater that was destroying what looked like planetary bodies similar to his person.

I can understand your position, but you can't just make a claim like that and leave it be. Otherwise, what's to stop us from thinking you just made it all up?


Its from Thor 161 IIRC. It was specifically mentioned as a planetoid.

Meh, think whatever you want.

Thor is bitching about heat of savage land

Sun is way above his paygrade it seems.

whistling

Originally posted by abhilegend
Yeah, characters are in-consistent. Who'd have thought of that? Also surfer gets his powers fueled by star light.
A quote that never was shown or proven overrides things where he flew through the sun like a peacock flies through the nightsky.