Battlezone challenge to Zelda fans

?

The other arguments were pretty valid, but the PI (nor spelling that again) undid the last spell he did. Those "images" are souls. No getting around that.

Ok, but that doesn't mean anything. The fact that they are souls doesn't mean his wand ripped their souls out. It's merely bring them back, albeit temporarily, in what is presumably the only way it can.

It undoes the last spell. If PI brings souls back, then AvK takes souls away. Deductive reasoning and all that.

No. That's not what it does. It reveals the last spell not undoes it. Anyway, the AK certainly does not take away souls after all Voldemort's soul was not taken away.

What do you mean his soul wasn't taken away, that's kinda what happens when you die.

I mean His soul was still wandering the Earth.

Yeah, because he just made the horcruxes for kicks and giggles. Wasn't that kinda the point

Sure, it was to make immortal. Regardless you claimed AK takes away souls. I showed you that's not what it does.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
What do you mean his soul wasn't taken away, that's kinda what happens when you die.

shrug

Originally posted by ares834
Sure, it was to make immortal. Regardless you claimed AK takes away souls. I showed you that's not what it does.

Perhaps. But you still haven't proven that AK takes souls.

I feel like I gave enough evidence for it to be a strong possibility. You haven't necessarily proved that it doesn't.

Zelda fans don't think they have to prove anything. They just say magical resistance and thinks that cuts it for Dorf.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
I feel like I gave enough evidence for it to be a strong possibility. You haven't necessarily proved that it doesn't.

One does not need to prove a negative.

Nor have I claimed it does not attack the soul.

No, ganondorf has enough resistance to probably tank one or two if he braced himself. I'm saying since the effect is usually instant, that a lucky shot he wasn't prepared for could take him down.

You could at least give another option. From what I've seen, the only explanation is that it attacks the soul.

It's magic. It could quit simply just kill. Or,if you want an explanation, it could destroy some ones life force or stop all brain activity.

But the brain was completely healthy. And if it stopped working, your heart would beating and your lungs would keep breathing.

Stopping all breain activy with agic wouldn't require any damage to the brain. After all, MAGIC!

And the lungs would stop if there was absolutely no brain activity not merely the higher functions.