Originally posted by quanchi112
He comes back after being killed proving until all the Horcruxes are destroyed he is immortal. Prove the movies are wrong when Horcruxes are tied to immortality. The burden is on you since the movie was clear. This is why you're a troll.It's already been hashed out and I don't have any interest in this matchup.
He comes back after dying. He ages. Old age kills. He'll only come back a set number of times. Not immortal
It has and you lost.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Voldemort says only I Can live forever right before he attacks Snape.
He also says killing Snape will make him the owner of the Elder Wand. He was wrong
If I recall it, it's implied by the books that Voldemort cannot be inmortal and that all he tries is in vain and acts of desperation because of how scared he's of death. But at the same time, it can also be interpreted as Dumbledor believing Voldemort is doomed to fail more than any actual limitation of his magical powers. The Deathly Hollows imply that its not possible to cheat Death forever in the Potterverse, but if this is by coincidence or by design can be a matter of opinion.
Originally posted by juggermanHe existed without a body and your response is age kills.
He comes back after dying. He ages. Old age kills. He'll only come back a set number of times. Not immortalIt has and you lost.
He also says killing Snape will make him the owner of the Elder Wand. He was wrong
😆
Do I need to link what a Horcrux does to embarrass you.
He was wrong since he didn't realize Draco disarmed Albus. Haha. You agree disarming wins a duel here. Magnificent. He isn't all knowing but was knowledgeable about Horcruxes and their purpose.
😂
Originally posted by quanchi112
He existed without a body and your response is age kills.😆
Do I need to link what a Horcrux does to embarrass you.
He was wrong since he didn't realize Draco disarmed Albus. Haha. You agree disarming wins a duel here. Magnificent. He isn't all knowing but was knowledgeable about Horcruxes and their purpose.
😂
He did yet only cuz his Horcruxes tied him to this world. He used one to "exist without a body". He would run out
When did i agree to that? He was wrong about magical stuff before and he was wrong about this. Do i need to tell you more things he was wrong about?
Originally posted by juggermanImplying he can live forever with the Horcruxes in existence. You claimed he can die of old age despite immortality clearly being mentioned in the films. Prove it.
He did yet only cuz his Horcruxes tied him to this world. He used one to "exist without a body". He would run outWhen did i agree to that? He was wrong about magical stuff before and he was wrong about this. Do i need to tell you more things he was wrong about?
He wasn't all knowing but he wasn't there so how would he know what specifically happened. Do you hear yourself ?
Originally posted by quanchi112
Implying he can live forever with the Horcruxes in existence. You claimed he can die of old age despite immortality clearly being mentioned in the films. Prove it.He wasn't all knowing but he wasn't there so how would he know what specifically happened. Do you hear yourself ?
He ages. Now you prove his aging had a limit. Waiting...
He was wrong. He was wrong about how many Horcruxes he had too. Wrong wrong wrong
Originally posted by juggermanVoldemort clearly states I can live forever but on top of that.
He ages. Now you prove his aging had a limit. Waiting...He was wrong. He was wrong about how many Horcruxes he had too. Wrong wrong wrong
J.K. Rowling's exact definition of a Horcrux is "a receptacle prepared by dark magic in which a Dark wizard has intentionally hidden a fragment of his soul for the purpose of attaining immortality."[13]
Key word being immortality not extremely long life. You jut don't grasp the obvious and can't back your claims.
Voldemort wasn't all knowing but the purpose of creating Horcruxes is attaining immortality which he had done.
🙂
Originally posted by quanchi112
Voldemort clearly states I can live forever but on top of that.J.K. Rowling's exact definition of a Horcrux is "a receptacle prepared by dark magic in which a Dark wizard has intentionally hidden a fragment of his soul for the purpose of attaining immortality."[13]
Key word being immortality not extremely long life. You jut don't grasp the obvious and can't back your claims.
Voldemort wasn't all knowing but the purpose of creating Horcruxes is attaining immortality which he had done.
🙂
Hmmmmm.... Wanna know what i notice? Notwhere in that explaination does it state that immortality is in fact given to the wizard that makes the horcrux. Just that the wizard makes one "for the purpose of attaining immortality". I could jump off a building "for the purpose of" defying gravity in some way. Does that mean i will attain my goal?
Originally posted by Silent Master
I didn't know that J.K. Rowling appeared in a HP movie and talked about Horcruxes...can someone post the clip?
Notice how if anyone else mentions what J.K. said quanny will come out and reem them since "this is about the movies not the books" but he'll turn around and do it when it suits his shitty points.
Originally posted by Silent Master
Why should we take Tom's word for it?
Cuz he's never been wrong about anything ever. Think for once! 😛