Top 10 Heralds ( Marvel and DC ) included

Started by JakeTheBank4 pages

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
This works.

Although I'd probably switch out Wonder Woman for any flavor of the month Herald that someone likes (Genis, Sentry, Captain Atom, Shaman X-man etc.).

Fair enough, but really, Diana's consistency (pre-Flashpoint) is what won me over.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
馃槀

uhuh

Originally posted by abhilegend
Superman
Silver Surfer
Thor
Orion
Shaman X-man
BRB
Captain Marvel
Hal Jordan
Hulk
Wonder Woman
I admit not having read a lot of stuff with Orion in it. Although, the first comic I ever owned was that giant "Flash and the New Gods", I think it was called.
Honestly and unbiased, how would you say he does against the rest of the list you posted?

Originally posted by Horrificus
I admit not having read a lot of stuff with Orion in it. Although, the first comic I ever owned was that giant "Flash and the New Gods", I think it was called.
Honestly and unbiased, how would you say he does against the rest of the list you posted?

Orion is about to have a knock down, drag out fight with Superman (who can bench the earth for 5 days straight).

Originally posted by Horrificus
I admit not having read a lot of stuff with Orion in it. Although, the first comic I ever owned was that giant "Flash and the New Gods", I think it was called.
Honestly and unbiased, how would you say he does against the rest of the list you posted?

He would beat anyone below him and probably split to thor while losing to superman and surfer.

Though, I think it will be another disappointing fight. 馃檨

Originally posted by abhilegend
He would beat anyone below him and probably split to thor while losing to superman and surfer.

Will you think differently, if Orion stalemates Superman?

Originally posted by Golgo13
can bench the earth for 5 days straight

Originally posted by Golgo13
Will you think differently, if Orion stalemates Superman?

We'll see.

Originally posted by abhilegend
He would beat anyone below him and probably split to thor while losing to superman and surfer.

Orion's pretty tough, I don't think he'd lose to Superman personally. He'd probably split with Thor and I could see him losing to Surfer though, yea.

Thor
Silver Surfer
Superman
Green Lantern Kyle/Hal
Flash Wally/Barry
Dr Strange
Dr Fate
Captain Marvel (dc)
Orion
Sentry

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Orion's pretty tough, I don't think he'd lose to Superman personally. He'd probably split with Thor and I could see him losing to Surfer though, yea.

Looking at their fights where Orion is all out and Superman is holding back or his poor performances against common enemies, I think he would lose to superman.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Looking at their fights where Orion is all out and Superman is holding back or his poor performances against common enemies, I think he would lose to superman.

Orion has had to hold back with the AF, too.

Originally posted by Golgo13
Orion has had to hold back with the AF, too.

With Byrne superman. He's suckershotted superman with the intent of killing him and he shrugged it off twice.

Do they always write him this tough?
Was always curious about Orion. Might read up on him.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Fair enough, but really, Diana's consistency (pre-Flashpoint) is what won me over.

She's more consistent then X-Man?

She was hurt by bullets in the Four Horsemen miniseries.

Originally posted by curryman
She's more consistent then X-Man?

She was hurt by bullets in the Four Horsemen miniseries.

Diana's always had a weird aversion to bullets. Doesn't make sense considering she can take punches from Superman, but it is what it is. Her showings and feats against other heralds coupled with her physical attributes and potentially broken weapons capable of subduing skyfathers netted her the position on my list.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Diana's always had a weird aversion to bullets. Doesn't make sense considering she can take punches from Superman, but it is what it is.

Yeah and I wish they would work on getting some damn consistency into those comics. If someone can tank a punch from say Superman or Diana or Orion then bullets shouldn't hurt them. If a bullet can pierce their skin then a punch from Thor would would have their skin break in an instant.

It's not that I don't think she can take them, it's that we all know that she has very inconsistent showings 馃槢

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Her showings and feats against other heralds coupled with her physical attributes and potentially broken weapons capable of subduing skyfathers netted her the position on my list.

Yeah but her physical attributes are still below most of the Kryptonians and she has none of their versatility either.

I'm not saying she should be placed lower on the tier list or anything like that, she's earned her spot. I just don't see how she's earned a spot above Zod, Captain Comet, Loki, Maxima, X-Man and many others. There are so many with more consistent showings who are her rough physical equal AND sport a far greater versatility.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Thor
Silver Surfer
Hulk
Doctor Strange
Beta Ray Bill
Superman
Green Lantern (Hal/Kyle)
Orion
Captain Marvel/Black Adam
Wonder Woman
馃憜

I see abhilegend is the only one with enough balls to put them in order.