Originally posted by abhilegend
Haven't you said that Thor's damage soak is better than superman previously? Time to prove it jake.
Pretty sure at this point, every notable Thor and Superman feat have been brought up time and time again in various threads under various scenarios with various degrees of scrutiny on both sides. Why or how this thread is any different than the countless other threads which have been made is beyond me.
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Pretty sure at this point, every notable Thor and Superman feat have been brought up time and time again in various threads under various scenarios with various degrees of scrutiny on both sides. Why or how this thread is any different than the countless other threads which have been made is beyond me.
Previously no one has utilized all the resources like they should have if Thor is even close to Superman. The Hulk or the Juggernaut would be more fairly comparable. Superman's longevity and healing factor is charged by the sun similarly to Thor's by Mjlnor, and Juggernaut's by the Cyttorak, and Hulk's gamma charged DnA, etc...I'd place Superman durability on par with Juggernaut's actually...slightly above Hulk. Feat wise. He's certainly capable of it in both of their strongest depictions. Thor doesn't really come close. Jugg's durablity>=Supes'.
Though, I've never seen Juggs or Hulk survive supernovae or even terranova, if we explode mid and low ends it's Superman>Hyperion>WWH>Juggs>>>Thor.
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Pretty sure at this point, every notable Thor and Superman feat have been brought up time and time again in various threads under various scenarios with various degrees of scrutiny on both sides. Why or how this thread is any different than the countless other threads which have been made is beyond me.
Originally posted by Dolos
Previously no one has utilized all the resources like they should have if Thor is even close to Superman. The Hulk or the Juggernaut would be more fairly comparable. Superman's longevity and healing factor is charged by the sun similarly to Thor's by Mjlnor, and Juggernaut's by the Cyttorak, and Hulk's gamma charged DnA, etc...I'd place Superman durability on par with Juggernaut's actually...slightly above Hulk. Feat wise. He's certainly capable of it in both of their strongest depictions. Thor doesn't really come close. Jugg's durablity>=Supes'.Though, I've never seen Juggs or Hulk survive supernovae or even terranova, if we explode mid and low ends it's Superman>Hyperion>WWH>Juggs>>>Thor.
Yes, they have. Thor/Superman debates have been going strong ever since I first joined the forum and I've seen plenty of scan blitz wars.
And no, Superman's durability isn't close to Juggernaut's.
Well, I did a quick search and look what I found out.
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
-Strength: Generally a wash, but if someone holds the edge, it's Superman. It's by no means overwhelming, though.-Striking Power( with Mjolnir ): Thor
-Striking Power(without Mjolnir): Superman
-Blasting Power: Thor
-Raw Speed: Superman
-Combat Speed: Superman
-Durability: Superman
-Damage Soak: Thor
-Combat Smarts: Superman
-Greats Hyperbolic Statement: Superman
Who wins??: Generally a split depending on how they fight.
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Durability: Superman.
Damage Soak: Thor.Your mileage may vary.
Originally posted by abhilegend
No, it hasn't. Answer the question jake. I don't know why you're hesitating. Thor has over 50 years of scans to chose from after all.
I've already said my piece in this argument years ago. I'll contribute to offer insight and opinion and correct misconstrued facts/lowballing, but as far as doing a scan war, not really my thing due to:
A.) Already have done it
B.) Too lazy to scan my comics
I don't know why people act like this debate is something new or that anyone is going to add anything to the table that hasn't already been discussed.
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Yes, they have. Thor/Superman debates have been going strong ever since I first joined the forum and I've seen plenty of scan blitz wars.And no, Superman's durability isn't close to Juggernaut's.
Well, except - everything I've got has been from the respect thread - Thor's just doesn't have the feats necessary.
Juggs' respect thread isn't rival in high ends either.
I mean, if you believe I'm in error than you just go ahead and pull scans from the Thor respect thread, and the Juggs if you want to go the extra mile.
You'll find they just don't compare, and it's not hard to go a thread over. Quit trying to make us out to be cheap skates, bringing it back to be sneaky or whatever, when you can just bring back what you need just as easily.
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
I've already said my piece in this argument years ago. I'll contribute to offer insight and opinion and correct misconstrued facts/lowballing, but as far as doing a scan war, not really my thing due to:A.) Already have done it
B.) Too lazy to scan my comicsI don't know why people act like this debate is something new or that anyone is going to add anything to the table that hasn't already been discussed.
Originally posted by JakeTheBank
And? You've successfully used the search function. Want a cookie?
A lot of that could be contributed to the Mjlnor.
Don't forget Superman has absorbed half of existence busting via Mageddon Warhead.
You very well could just be claiming this argument was resolved out of your arse. I wasn't here 'a few years ago', so why are you pretending likes dems common knowledge?
lol.
Originally posted by abhilegend
Link me to where you did a scan war on this.
Your snake-eyes imitation is terrible jake.
Why don't you just start spamming Thor feats and see if any of them come close to just one I've put up here. Just one.
Don't use one where he tanks a blast, because I doubt any of those matches the Mageddon WH.
Originally posted by Dolos
A lot of that could be contributed to the Mjlnor.Don't forget Superman has absorbed half of existence busting via Mageddon Warhead.
You very well could just be claiming this argument was resolved out of your arse. I wasn't here 'a few years ago', so why are you pretending likes dems common knowledge?
lol.