How would Superman fit in the Marvel U if they bought the rights to him?

Started by -Pr-6 pages
Originally posted by carver9
Hulk would be treated just like Grundy, The General, and Konvikt is treated (but on a better scale), he would tackle and probably run through the Justice League, especially since DC has acknowledged Hulk power of physically getting stronger and faster with rage.

No, that wouldn't happen at all, because Hulk is nothing like those characters.

lol,
You're probably the only person who can make Carver look reasonable.

Originally posted by janus77
lol,
You're probably the only person who can make Carver look reasonable.

If that was possible, I might agree with you.

But no.

IF you agreed, you might have undermined my point 🙂

shrug

Seriously though, Hulk fans wouldn't be happy if DC bought the rights, because at best he'd be treated like Grundy in terms of actual combat feats.

It doesn't help that he doesn't really fit in to DC earth either.

There's no point talking with you on Hulk. Your dislike of Carver clouds all things Hulk and your absolutist stance that Hulk is "nothing like" The General, Grundy etc ...

Originally posted by janus77
There's no point talking with you on Hulk. Your dislike of Carver clouds all things Hulk and your absolutist stance that Hulk is "nothing like" The General, Grundy etc ...

Feel free to keep believing that, as untrue as it is.

Considering how much money they would have to fork out for him I doubt Marvel wouldn't do everything could to push Superman at the forefront.

The problem is what their "forefront" actually consists of.

With Disney as it's (Marvel's) parent company, I could see that happening on some level in the future. And not just with Superman, but ALL of DC's stuff. Who is DC's financial muscle? Warner Bros?

He would make a good Guardian of the Galaxy but a member mainly based on earth so he could save people there with the Avengers and then go out and help the other members of the GotG when needed.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Quesada's not the boss anymore?

Joe Q is now Chief Creative Officer of Marvel Entertainment. He's got a bigger role in all of Marvel's endeavors now and you'd better believe that he still has his hand in firm control of Axel Alonso's puppet strings.

Originally posted by abhilegend
He would be better than Thor and Surfer at least.

nah. The marvel universe consists of a lot of mutant and other types, I think the Superman types don't fit in well. The most popular heros in marvel are not even close to hearld class characters. Spiderman, captain America, wolverine. Supes needs to stay in D.C. comics.

As far as who would be better in the marvel universe superman or thor, id have to say thor for sure.

Originally posted by golem370
He would make a good Guardian of the Galaxy but a member mainly based on earth so he could save people there with the Avengers and then go out and help the other members of the GotG when needed.

Hell no. None of those characters are overly powerful. That's by design.

If Superman's rights are owned by Marvel would they be able to keep his history and interactions with the other DC characters? If so I think just having Superman stay as he is without re-imagining him or changing his character history one bit would work, and having his story in Marvel be that he somehow got sent to the MU in some kind of dimensional rift event and can't ever return to his native universe under any circumstances (the event being impossible to replicate) would work fine enough. I wouldn't have him join the Avengers though. I think he should work directly for the U.N. and have tensions with the other heroes as he becomes the new global golden boy. Maybe even envy by other heroes (save someone like Captain America). I think eventually they should have an arc where the difference in frequency of sunlight between the MU and DCU cause his power levels to fluctuate and come more in line with Marvel's. It could be done right but I feel it would have to treat Supes history with absolute respect. The brand has earned that level of consideration.

Originally posted by MF DELPH
If Superman's rights are owned by Marvel would they be able to keep his history and interactions with the other DC characters? If so I think just having Superman stay as he is without re-imagining him or changing his character history one bit would work, and having his story in Marvel be that he somehow got sent to the MU in some kind of dimensional rift event and can't ever return to his native universe under any circumstances (the event being impossible to replicate) would work fine enough. I wouldn't have him join the Avengers though. I think he should work directly for the U.N. and have tensions with the other heroes as he becomes the new global golden boy. Maybe even envy by other heroes (save someone like Captain America). I think eventually they should have an arc where the difference in frequency of sunlight between the MU and DCU cause his power levels to fluctuate and come more in line with Marvel's. It could be done right but I feel it would have to treat Supes history with absolute respect. The brand has earned that level of consideration.

It would probably be the crown jewel of a larger acquisition of DC's properties. Disney would buy the rights from whomever is the financial muscle of DC, and then after promising (lying) to keep the two separate, they would inevitably merge the properties into Marvel entertainment.

Think UFC buying Pride or the WWE buying out the WCW.

Originally posted by dmills
With Disney as it's (Marvel's) parent company, I could see that happening on some level in the future. And not just with Superman, but ALL of DC's stuff. Who is DC's financial muscle? Warner Bros?

Yeah, WB is the owner.

If Disney bought DC, it would be a sad, sad day for comics, imo.

Originally posted by dmills
Joe Q is now Chief Creative Officer of Marvel Entertainment. He's got a bigger role in all of Marvel's endeavors now and you'd better believe that he still has his hand in firm control of Axel Alonso's puppet strings.

Ouch.

The only chance I could give Superman at Marvel would be if Quesada had absolutely no input in to it.

Originally posted by dmills
Hell no. None of those characters are overly powerful. That's by design.

Whats your point.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Yeah, WB is the owner.

If Disney bought DC, it would be a sad, sad day for comics, imo.

Ouch.

The only chance I could give Superman at Marvel would be if Quesada had absolutely no input in to it.

Which would sadly mean there's no chance at all. Marvel comics is a SMALL portion of their revenue, but at the same time the overall brand comes from the comic material. Everything would go through Joe Q as a result because it's all a part of the overall direction of the toys, films, animations etc. Abnett and Lanning's run on "Nova" and "Guardians Of the Galaxy" were the first casualties of that new business model per Joe Q himself.

Originally posted by golem370
Whats your point.
Originally posted by dmills
None of those characters are overly powerful. That's by design.