Originally posted by Silent Master Again, you brought up him having an invisible aura..that means the burden is on you.
If you like I can quote the post where you made the original claim.
You're contesting the feat based on the idea it could be hers. Prove it was then.
SM
Silent MasterSenior Member
Originally posted by juggerman You're contesting the feat based on the idea it could be hers. Prove it was then.
Contesting the feat doesn't shift the burden.
JUG
juggermanSenior Member
Originally posted by Silent Master Contesting the feat doesn't shift the burden.
You claimed it was hers. Prove it
SM
Silent MasterSenior Member
Originally posted by juggerman You claimed it was hers. Prove it
Again, you made the original claim, so the burden is still on you.
If it'll help, I can quote the post where you made the original claim.
JUG
juggermanSenior Member
Originally posted by Silent Master Again, you made the original claim, so the burden is still on you.
If it'll help, I can quote the post where you made the original claim.
So now it wasn't hers?
SM
Silent MasterSenior Member
Originally posted by juggerman So now it wasn't hers?
You made the original claim, that means the burden is on you.
JUG
juggermanSenior Member
Originally posted by Silent Master You made the original claim, that means the burden is on you.
Glad you agree it wasn't hers
SM
Silent MasterSenior Member
Originally posted by juggerman Glad you agree it wasn't hers
You still haven't backed up your claim.
JUG
juggermanSenior Member
Originally posted by Silent Master You still haven't backed up your claim.
I did. She was protected when she should have been injured. And of course his aura is a known power in the Superman mythos.
SM
Silent MasterSenior Member
Originally posted by juggerman I did. She was protected when she should have been injured. And of course his aura is a known power in the Superman mythos.
Comic Superman's mythos isn't proof, as it's not canon to the movie verse.
Now, please back up your claim.
KIN
KingD19Shai-Gen's Enigmatic Wong
Was there a visual cue? Was there any spoken or documented confirmation that he has his electron invincibility aura?
If there wasn't and you can't produce any proof, then he doesn't have one.
JUG
juggermanSenior Member
Originally posted by Silent Master Comic Superman's mythos isn't proof, as it's not canon to the movie verse.
Now, please back up your claim.
Lois not being harmed is proof
JUG
juggermanSenior Member
Originally posted by KingD19 Was there a visual cue? Was there any spoken or documented confirmation that he has his electron invincibility aura?
If there wasn't and you can't produce any proof, then he doesn't have one.
The scene itself is proof. She should have been injured and wasn't
SM
Silent MasterSenior Member
Originally posted by juggerman Lois not being harmed is proof
No, it's you making up powers that don't exist in order to explain a scene of PIS.
JUG
juggermanSenior Member
Originally posted by Silent Master No, it's you making up powers that don't exist in order to explain a scene of PIS.
I made up the idea of Superman having it? I get you don't like it but that's what it looking like
SM
Silent MasterSenior Member
Originally posted by juggerman I made up the idea of Superman having it? I get you don't like it but that's what it looking like
Yes, you made up the idea of MOS Superman having it.
KIN
KingD19Shai-Gen's Enigmatic Wong
In the movies there's no proof that he has it. So saying he has it is pretty much making it up when there's no actual proof.
JUG
juggermanSenior Member
Originally posted by Silent Master Yes, you made up the idea of MOS Superman having it.
Not Superman in general and it fits
JUG
juggermanSenior Member
Originally posted by KingD19 In the movies there's no proof that he has it. So saying he has it is pretty much making it up when there's no actual proof.
There is
SM
Silent MasterSenior Member
Originally posted by juggerman Not Superman in general and it fits