The Official "Argue with Quan about Zelda" Thread

Originally posted by quanchi112
When she Didnt care about Link or Hyrule.

She's a ruler trying to save her people. There were Twili relying on her and she was selflessly helping them. You're evil for not helping someone while helping another? That's not even selfish, that's loyalty to the subjects she knew.

In any case, she did start caring about Hyrule. Was she still selfish then?

Originally posted by The Scenario
She's a ruler trying to save her people. There were Twili relying on her and she was selflessly helping them. You're evil for not helping someone while helping another? That's not even selfish, that's loyalty to the subjects she knew.

In any case, she did start caring about Hyrule. Was she still selfish then?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Link was always selfless she wasn't. She has both elements in her unlike Link or Dorf.

Midna selflessly helped people long before Zelda saved her. But fine, do you agree that Midna stopped being selfish after her life was saved?

Originally posted by The Scenario
Midna selflessly helped people long before Zelda saved her. But fine, do you agree that Midna stopped being selfish after her life was saved?

Originally posted by quanchi112
She never became total goodness or total evil like Link or Dorf.

You didn't answer the question. Midna should selfless behavior before and after Zelda's sacrifice, when did she show selfishness after?

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
You heard it here first, setting out to stop an evil dictator from ****ing with your people and helping to save another world as well, which you initially had no stake in, is ebil if you're a little rude to someone you've never met before. Ebil as fuk.

Originally posted by The Scenario
You didn't answer the question. Midna should selfless behavior before and after Zelda's sacrifice, when did she show selfishness after?

Originally posted by ScreamPaste

Originally posted by quanchi112
That is misrepresenting it.

Midna is more evil than good T/F?

Originally posted by quanchi112
I am saying she is neither evil or pure goodness she is a normal character with both qualities.

And I'm asking when Midna performed any evil action, and what that action was. Well, when and what?

9. People have flaws, but can still be good overall. (T/F)

We need Oreos and milk? T/F?

True. Always true in all situations forever.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
No, that appears to be your stance. The only 'evil' we ever see from Midna is a little conceit and some bad manners. What other 'evil' is there?

Midna is more evil than good T/F?

Originally posted by The Scenario
And I'm asking when Midna performed any evil action, and what that action was. Well, when and what?

9. People have flaws, but can still be good overall. (T/F)

You did not answer my question, you just parroted your own stance.

Is Midna, as of Zelda saving her life, more good than evil?

Is she a 6 good 4 evil mix? Of is she 9 evil, 1 good? Or is she a perfect split?

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
You did not answer my question, you just parroted your own stance.

Is Midna, as of Zelda saving her life, more good than evil?

Is she a 6 good 4 evil mix? Of is she 9 evil, 1 good? Or is she a perfect split?

So you concede. You're too scared to answer anyone's questions, and are simply parroting your unproven view. You lose.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
So you concede. You're too scared to answer anyone's questions, and are simply parroting your unproven view. You lose.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
You did not answer my question, you just parroted your own stance.

Is Midna, as of Zelda saving her life, more good than evil?

Is she a 6 good 4 evil mix? Of is she 9 evil, 1 good? Or is she a perfect split?

Is she more good, or more evil? Which does she have more of?

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Is she more good, or more evil? Which does she have [b]more of? [/B]