The Official "Argue with Quan about Zelda" Thread

Started by NotAllThatEvil87 pages

So its completely irrelevant? She ends the game helping the good guys. She may all jealous and selfish and cruel, but at the end of the game she's wearing a hero's Jersey. Why is that not good enough?

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Why is midna's alignment important again?
Scenario is breaking and posting gifs everywhere because he knows it is the only thing that can save scenario.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Scenario is breaking and posting gifs everywhere because he knows it is the only thing that can save scenario.

But why is it important?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Scenario is breaking and posting gifs everywhere because he knows it is the only thing that can save scenario.

Sentences that make sense, this is not one.

Also, I post evidence when you can't grasp a point. If evidence scares you off you have bigger problems than just being wrong. 🙂

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Sentences that make sense, this is not one.

Also, I post evidence when you can't grasp a point. If evidence scares you off you have bigger problems than just being wrong. 🙂

autocorrected your name into scenario's.

You speculate and don't know what true evidence is. Your bias isn't evidence.

What evidence to you have for midna's personal demons?

When the game shows me something clear as day, that's evidence. For example this:

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
This is getting sad Quan. We both know Midna is good. When she's dying her main concern isn't for herself, it's for Zelda and her people.

YouTube video


^
Proves she's good.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Shr has both inside her. Killing isn't good either. Using fused shadows which is evil isn't good either.

This is so easy.


And your rebuttal, that she kills, contradicts your claim that Link is pure good. 😄 Congrats.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
What evidence to you have for midna's personal demons?
Her using evil items to accomplish her quest. Two wrongs don't make a right. She failed too. She's pretty stupid tbh.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
When the game shows me something clear as day, that's evidence. For example this:

^
Proves she's good.

And your rebuttal, that she kills, contradicts your claim that Link is pure good. 😄 Congrats.

Link has no choice but to kill. He also doesn't use evil items like fused shadows.

Ms is a good relic whereas Fused Shadows is evil.

🙂

The triforce is holy and devine relic. Does ganondorf using it make him an ok dude?

haermm So if Hitler creates a gun, it's evil to use that gun against him?

Link kills to achieve his goal, saving Hyrule, Midna does the exact same thing. One cannot be pure good and the other evil. If I kill you with a holy bullet I'm still an *******.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
The triforce is holy and devine relic. Does ganondorf using it make him an ok dude?

^This.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
The triforce is holy and devine relic. Does ganondorf using it make him an ok dude?
Master sword is anti evil not the top. Fused shadows is evil. It's so easy to destroy your biased points.

Except ganondorf uses the triforce, so my point is very much not destroyed.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
haermm So if Hitler creates a gun, it's evil to use that gun against him?

Link kills to achieve his goal, saving Hyrule, Midna does the exact same thing. One cannot be pure good and the other evil. If I kill you with a holy bullet I'm still an *******.

^This.

Fused shadows are evil. Do you contest this ? Is the ms good ?

You are now claiming Link is corrupt. Hilarious.

Link is selfless whereas Midna originally was not.

One is evil magic and one isn't.

😄

Link is also arrogant and a cheater.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Fused shadows are evil. Do you contest this ? Is the ms good ?

You are now claiming Link is corrupt. Hilarious.

Link is selfless whereas Midna originally was not.

One is evil magic and one isn't.

😄


And she used them for good. The MS cannot be used for evil, but if it could, and you did, you'd be committing an evil act, doing the opposite is therefore a good act. This is simple.

Alignment of your tool < Alignment of the job you use it to do.

Midna, by the time Zant mortally wounded her, was no longer selfish and was primarily good. This is fact.

Why is the alignment of any character in question again? This is not an issue in any debate I've read. If midna was tje main antagonist but never made her move, what would change?

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Link is also arrogant and a cheater.
He does cheat with the boots but this raises an interesting point. Does the Ms only sense true evil ?

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Why is the alignment of any character in question again? This is not an issue in any debate I've read. If midna was tje main antagonist but never made her move, what would change?

Quan has a long history of being willfully wrong about anything in Zelda just to antagonize people who enjoy the games. Click me. Examples.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
And she used them for good. The MS [b]cannot be used for evil, but if it could, and you did, you'd be committing an evil act, doing the opposite is therefore a good act. This is simple.

Alignment of your tool < Alignment of the job you use it to do.

Midna, by the time Zant mortally wounded her, was no longer selfish and was primarily good. This is fact. [/B]

No, she uses an evil relic not an a to evil relic. People lose control when they wield the Fused Shadow.

One relic is magically evil so it is different than a hammer you use.

She still used an evil relic.

Fact.

😆