Superman vs A Planet

Originally posted by abhilegend
Its more like Geoff Johns forgot that the fight was already taking place in superman books and had both superman fight again from start. That's only possible explanation of so many discrepancies in two fights. The logic that these two fights are same and since one doesn't have world breaking apart every time they hit means the one fight where the world broke apart six times doesn't count or that the world breaking isn't world breaking but something else is just laughably stupid btw. The second fight also didn't have them living each other's life either, it had no elements of the first fight to prove anything from the first fight wrong.

I understand what you're saying but I'm trying to understand something here. Both times Lois was laid out in both fights. So what I'm trying to get here is: did Lois pass out twice in both fights with the Supermen and if so, why would the two Supermen fight twice? Also, which fight happened first? Then, if everything was settled in the first fight, and they both came to an agreement, them being Superman, why would they go into a rage fight again when everything was settled the first time.? I thought their goal was to stop Luthor, not kill each other. Answer these questions for me please.

Originally posted by carver9
I understand what you're saying but I'm trying to understand something here. Both times Lois was laid out in both fights. So what I'm trying to get here is: did Lois pass out twice in both fights with the Supermen and if so, why would the two Supermen fight twice? Also, which fight happened first? Then, if everything was settlped in the first fight, and they both came to an agreement, them being Superman, why would they go into a rage fight again when everything was settled the first time.? I thought their goal was to stop Luthor, not kill each other. Answer these questions for me please.

@Cele

But he should have an answer for both fights though. I want to see what ABHI see.

Originally posted by carver9
@Cele

But he should have an answer for both fights though. I want to see what ABHI see.

Honestly, the best explanation is two different narration on a fight. You can't say one doesn't apply because it doesn't for your argument.

Originally posted by xJLxKing
Honestly, the best explanation is two different narration on a fight. You can't say one doesn't apply because it doesn't for your argument.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
I'll give u an example...
Taskmaster was seen in Avengers: The Initiative#32 getting a few shots in on Thor when he was down. We also saw up close look of the main group that brought Thor down. In Seige#1, we don't even see Taskmaster at all. We just saw on overview of the fight and not in detail. During AvngrsIntve#32, we also see Ironclad of the U-Foes getting a shot in as opposed to him just standing in the background in Seige#1. Like I said, tie-ins are almost all the time used to supplement big company wide story arcs...

If you're hand has to be held through everything, it's a wonder how you even post information on anything involving comics...

I guess I have to finally say it. Ure obviously trolling at this point because u've run out of ammunition..

Hahahaha.

You are the guy who's applying two different and at random comics and using it as a proof and trying to accuse me of trolling? Irony abounds.

Originally posted by carver9
I understand what you're saying but I'm trying to understand something here. Both times Lois was laid out in both fights. So what I'm trying to get here is: did Lois pass out twice in both fights with the Supermen and if so, why would the two Supermen fight twice? Also, which fight happened first? Then, if everything was settled in the first fight, and they both came to an agreement, them being Superman, why would they go into a rage fight again when everything was settled the first time.? I thought their goal was to stop Luthor, not kill each other. Answer these questions for me please.

Also the first fight was likely ignored by Johns.

Superman and Kal-L fought for first time under Joe Kelly. This was ignored by Johns in IC 5 where they fought for the first time. Since under Johns they never fought before that fight, they never come to agreement either.

Originally posted by abhilegend
I haven't seen those fights but those don't contradict each other like a random character seen alive in one fight and dead before the fight even starts in another. Going by what you are saying here, you are conceding that the supermen destroyed and rebuild earth-two in AC 836, AOS 649 and Superman 226 but they just didn't show it in IC 5. y'know. Right?

Hahahaha.

You are the guy who's applying two different and at random comics and using it as a proof and trying to accuse me of trolling? Irony abounds.

What I'm doing is taking everything into account and not dismissing things just so it suits my argument..

Now let's get back to ure notion of 2 separate fights. Where's your explanation on that? This I gotta see.

Originally posted by abhilegend
No. Lois was in FOS when the first fight took place. She died before the second fight started.

Also the first fight was likely ignored by Johns.

Superman and Kal-L fought for first time under Joe Kelly. This was ignored by Johns in IC 5 where they fought for the first time. Since under Johns they never fought before that fight, they never come to agreement either.

I've read the arc several times, and never at any point did I feel like it was two separate fights. I'll have to look it up again.

Still have no idea how it's at all relevant, though.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I've read the arc several times, and never at any point did I feel like it was two separate fights. I'll have to look it up again.

Superman has feats that are above busting a planet, which subsequently prove that he can.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I've read the arc several times, and never at any point did I feel like it was two separate fights. I'll have to look it up again.

Still have no idea how it's at all relevant, though.

For some strange reason, when I see Pr in a thread clearing stuff up like this, its a mind relief (no homo).

You want the mod d

Originally posted by Philosophía
Superman has feats that are above busting a planet, which subsequently prove that he can.

Pretty much.

Originally posted by carver9
For some strange reason, when I see Pr in a thread clearing stuff up like this, its a mind relief (no homo).

Eww.

Do any planets have Superman busting feats?

Lolz

Originally posted by janus77
Do any planets have Superman busting feats?

Pretty much an sentient planet would shove dicks in Superman's butt

edit.