Superman vs A Planet

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
😂

Fair enough.

Based on his general strength feats and how he stacks up against those who have busted planets, if Superman was actually intending to destroy a planet - which is even less likely than Thor doing so - it seems more than plausible he could do it.

I'm gonna take a hard line stance here. There is no way Superman can destroy a planet. I may be wrong, but I've never seen it on panel in his 50+ years of comics so that can only mean he can't.

Zop and Jlxking were right. There is no way he can bust a planet without any amps.

PC Supes not allowed btw.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
I'm gonna take a hard line stance here. There is no way Superman can destroy a planet. I may be wrong, but I've never seen it on panel in his 50+ years of comics so that can only mean he can't.

Zop and Jlxking were right. There is no way he can bust a planet without any amps.

PC Supes not allowed btw.

lol

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
lol

Neither are blowing up Earth sized planet but perhaps an Earth moon size sure.

Oneshots it like he has done already.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
I'm gonna take a hard line stance here. There is no way Superman can destroy a planet. I may be wrong, but I've never seen it on panel in his 50+ years of comics so that can only mean he can't.

Zop and Jlxking were right. There is no way he can bust a planet without any amps.

PC Supes not allowed btw.

Originally posted by snowdragon
Neither are blowing up Earth sized planet but perhaps an Earth moon size sure.

Got the scans?

Originally posted by ares834
Got the scans?

You know what's funny? The people who are now going gaga over the narration saying the planet shatterd were the one who said that this feat isn't world shattering even though both the narration and characters stated so.

If that wasn't hyperbole or just him talking, then the feat can't be admissible like the shockwave feat between HOTM Hulk and Red Shulk. Because it took two Supermen to pull that off. It was the force of their blows colliding that did it.

However I do remember Supes kamikazi'ing that dark matter moon and ko'ing himself while destroying it in the process. A flying head start should give him enough to destroy the Earth if he's going all out. If he doesn't do it the first time, he can definitely pull it off with the other 4 shots. If Blue Marvel holding back can nearly shatter the moon in half, then Supes going all out can destroy the Earth.

Originally posted by KingD19
If that wasn't hyperbole or just him talking, then the feat can't be admissible like the shockwave feat between HOTM Hulk and Red Shulk. Because it took two Supermen to pull that off. It was the force of their blows colliding that did it.

But it was also only one punch from both of them. Not several.

He could maybe... but I have not seen it yet

Originally posted by ares834
But it was also only one punch from both of them. Not several.

I know. I'm pointing out that you can't say, "Yeah, Superman shattered the Earth" or however you want to classify it. When it was Super-men that did it. It was two opposing forces whose combined damage output from matching up managed to destroy the world. It wasn't Superman by himself.

Just like it was Hulk's energy backlash and Red She-Hulk's energy backlash combining that destroyed that planet, not Hulk alone.

Keep in mind I believe he can do it given the stips(especially with the flying start), but I don't think it can be argued he can do it like in those scans, since he isn't going head up against another Superman.

Originally posted by KingD19
If that wasn't hyperbole or just him talking, then the feat can't be admissible like the shockwave feat between HOTM Hulk and Red Shulk. Because it took two Supermen to pull that off. It was the force of their blows colliding that did it.

However I do remember Supes kamikazi'ing that dark matter moon and ko'ing himself while destroying it in the process. A flying head start should give him enough to destroy the Earth if he's going all out. If he doesn't do it the first time, he can definitely pull it off with the other 4 shots. If Blue Marvel holding back can nearly shatter the moon in half, then Supes going all out can destroy the Earth.

Here he does it by himself in one punch.

"Who can strike with such force they shatter-". It happened again and again. It happened 6 times in 3 comics, how many of them are hyperboles?

Honestly, if any other character destroys a planet 6 times in 3 comics with another slightly stronger version of himself in combat by just shockwaves anytime soon, his fans would nuke every comic book vs forum on internet.

He obviously can, and iirc has already done so.

Originally posted by abhilegend
If he can produce shockwaves that destroys the world alongside another superman, he can destroy a planet by one punch. It isn't a hyperbole, it happened everytime they strike ech other and it was explicitly stated to be their punches that destroyed the world.

http://s1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/?action=view&current=18-1.jpg

"Who can strike with such force they shatter-". It happened again and again. It happened 6 times in 3 comics, how many of them are hyperboles?

[

Honestly, if any other character destrooys a planet 6 times in 3 comics with another slightly stronger version of himself in combat by just shockwaves anytime soon, his fans would nuke every comic book vs forum on internet.

First off, I said if it wasn't hyperbole or just the person talking up the fight. I wasn't sure as I've seen it debated several times before.

Also, if you look at my post. I believe he can do it. That's what I've said from the beginning. With the stips, I believe he can do it with the amount of tries given. I'm not sure if he can do it in one punch. But I believe he can pull it off definitely. I was just pointing out that you can't say he can do it like it was presented in the scan. Since it was the combined destructive forces that broke or shattered worlds or whatever. You can't say, "Yeah, it took 2 Supermen fighting and their combined blows destroyed the world. But just 1 can do the exact same thing just as easily."

The way it was presented means exactly the opposite. While it might be in his power, the planets were destroyed because 2 of them were clashing. Not just one smashing into the planet.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
I'm gonna take a hard line stance here. There is no way Superman can destroy a planet. I may be wrong, but I've never seen it on panel in his 50+ years of comics so that can only mean he can't.

Zop and Jlxking were right. There is no way he can bust a planet without any amps.

PC Supes not allowed btw.

Originally posted by KingD19
First off, I said if it wasn't hyperbole or just the person talking up the fight. I wasn't sure as I've seen it debated several times before.

Also, if you look at my post. I believe he can do it. That's what I've said from the beginning. With the stips, I believe he can do it with the amount of tries given. I'm not sure if he can do it in one punch. But I believe he can pull it off definitely. I was just pointing out that you can't say he can do it like it was presented in the scan. Since it was the combined destructive forces that broke or shattered worlds or whatever. You can't say, "Yeah, it took 2 Supermen fighting and their combined blows destroyed the world. But just 1 can do the exact same thing just as easily."

The way it was presented means exactly the opposite. While it might be in his power, the planets were destroyed because 2 of them were clashing. Not just one smashing into the planet.

That's not what it looks like to me. But I could be wrong because I don't know the context. To me it looks like he got hit so hard he went to another dimension or something. Because he's in the middle of a fight, and through the "shatter" we see him having a calm dinner and saying that isn't his life, but he can hack it if Lois is there.

Regardless though, the fact is you're arguing a moot point.

The whole point I made was that using the feat of the two Supermen causing a planet to be destroyed by clashing can't be used to say a single Superman can pull it off.

Just like saying Hulk clashing with Red Shulk and destroying a planet can't be used as evidence to say Hulk or Red Shulk could do it alone. I never said Superman couldn't do it on his own. I simply pointed out that feat can't be used to say he can, when it's clearly from him and another Superman fighting.

Originally posted by KingD19
That's not what it looks like to me. But I could be wrong because I don't know the context. To me it looks like he got hit so hard he went to another dimension or something. Because he's in the middle of a fight, and through the "shatter" we see him having a calm dinner and saying that isn't his life, but he can hack it if Lois is there.

Regardless though, the fact is you're arguing a moot point.

The whole point I made was that using the feat of the two Supermen causing a planet to be destroyed by clashing can't be used to say a single Superman can pull it off.

Just like saying Hulk clashing with Red Shulk and destroying a planet can't be used as evidence to say Hulk or Red Shulk could do it alone. I never said Superman couldn't do it on his own. I simply pointed out that feat can't be used to say he can, when it's clearly from him and another Superman fighting.

Even though superman alone destroyed the earth by his punch here?

http://s1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/?action=view&current=18-1.jpg