Superman vs A Planet

I don't get how you don't get what I'm saying. Doing it in another scan is fine. That's proof positive I didn't need. I was saying the scan presented, of 2 Supermen destroying a world can't be used to say 1 Superman can destroy the world. It's a shared feat so a single person can't claim it.

Posting a scan of 1 Superman destroying a world is fine. Since it's just him, because of that scan you can say "Yeah, Superman can do it in one punch."

But you can't say "Yeah, Superman can do it in one punch." And then post a scan of 2 Supermen going at it.

That's the only point I've been making.

Originally posted by KingD19
I don't get how you don't get what I'm saying. Doing it in another scan is fine. That's proof positive I didn't need. I was saying the scan presented, of 2 Supermen destroying a world can't be used to say 1 Superman can destroy the world. It's a shared feat so a single person can't claim it.

Posting a scan of 1 Superman destroying a world is fine. Since it's just him, because of that scan you can say "Yeah, Superman can do it in one punch."

But you can't say "Yeah, Superman can do it in one punch." And then post a scan of 2 Supermen going at it.

That's the only point I've been making.

Lol. I never said he couldn't.

Originally posted by abhilegend
http://s1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/?action=view&current=AOS649SURVIVESTIMEREALITYSHATERINGFORCES5.jpg
http://s1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/?action=view&current=02-03.jpg

You know what's funny? The people who are now going gaga over the narration saying the planet shatterd were the one who said that this feat isn't world shattering even though both the narration and characters stated so.

Originally posted by abhilegend
I edited the post. Superman did destroy the planet by his own here.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
this was debunked a week or so ago, remember?

The writer even said the Supermen didn't destroy the planet. ABHI just doesn't give up...he will forever post those debunk scans. Lord.

Yes, Superman can.

Originally posted by TheGodKiller
He obviously can, and iirc has already done so.

I say Supes can do it.
But the scans abhi is trying to push are not evidence of that. And debunked as some have mentioned.

I knew they'd been debated. Not debunked.

But yeah, I still believe given the stipulations Superman can destroy the planet. But it's good to know how those feats go one way or the other. Wouldn't make sense for Earth to be destroyed...then Superman is on it.

Originally posted by KingD19
I knew they'd been debated. Not debunked.

But yeah, I still believe given the stipulations Superman can destroy the planet. But it's good to know how those feats go one way or the other. Wouldn't make sense for Earth to be destroyed...then Superman is on it.

Ahhhhh.

Originally posted by KingD19
Ahhhhh.

It's just not ure standard planet busting feat. It's just not.

He does it in one.

Both Superman and Thor have feats requiring way more energy than is required here.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Can't believe ure still peddling this thing...
😘

Originally posted by psycho gundam
this was debunked a week or so ago, remember?

Originally posted by JBL
It has been debunked far longer than that. Superman has NEVER destroyed a planet. Out of 50 plus years of feats and not having a single planet destroying feat proves this. What writers HAVE put him up against are small moons, shadow moons and smaller things, and even then he is shown to have to ram them at high speed or needing to build up mass to help him thus making even those small bodies 70% flight feats.

Originally posted by carver9
The writer even said the Supermen didn't destroy the planet. ABHI just doesn't give up...he will forever post those debunk scans. Lord.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
It's more on the debunked side.
Pretty sure the writer said that they were sharing memories instead of actually indirectly punching worlds out.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
It's still quite a feat for what it was don't get me wrong. I just don't believe it's the feat that Ahbi was making it out to be. There were all kinds of things going on due to the whole planet being in flux.

It's just not ure standard planet busting feat. It's just not.

Originally posted by KingD19

But you can't say "Yeah, Superman can do it in one punch." And then post a scan of 2 Supermen going at it.

😂

As for the op. Based on a 5 hit minimum stip? No. But I do think he can bust a planet under certain circumstances.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
With a single flying head start, I believe he could definitely do so.

Without it, I still think he could do it, reboot or no.

This guy knows what's up.

Seriously, does anybody has the link to this supposed Joe Kelly interview which Rage and Celey cling to their life? Considering it contradicts his own words in the comics when he wrote Kal-L and Superman fight and Supergirl and Power Girl fight he himself wrote, why is it even being used as a mean to discredit a feat?

What interview?

Originally posted by abhilegend
Seriously, does anybody has the link to this supposed Joe Kelly interview which Rage and Celey cling to their life? Considering it contradicts his own words in the comics when he wrote Kal-L and Superman fight and Supergirl and Power Girl fight he himself wrote, why is it even being used as a mean to discredit a feat?

That's on them to post it if they want it seriously considered. I wouldn't worry too much about it for now tbh.