Here is a review on Reddit. He thinks of himself as a tough critic. Gave BVS a pretty good score.
Spoiler:
Reddit review. he gives it 6.5/10The Good
Despite serious concerns going in, I'd say that the most impressive success of the movie was the believability in the action between Batman and Superman. I fully expected to roll my eyes, saying "Oh come on...how can he stand up against a GOD?!" but they nailed it.
As we know from the trailer, they actually addressed the ridiculous amount of carnage that inevitably resulted from the first movie.
Ben Affleck definitely quashed any concerns we may have had for ability to play the Dark Knight...see below for the film's shortcomings in Bruce Wayne, however...
Wonder Woman was a bad ass and got me excited to see her in action down the road (not so great out of superhero mode, though)
They took a huge risk in the final act that many other superhero movies would be too afraid to attempt and it definitely was effective (without giving too much away)
Get hyped for Justice League and future DC properties
We got to see some awesome Bat gadgets (GRAPPLING HOOK!!)
The fight sequences were definitely in the better half of all comic book movies as of late
Alfred was awesome. I love Jeremy Irons' completely different portrayal from previous versions of the character
The Bad
They completely ignored the Bruce Wayne half of Batman's character. You cast Ben Affleck, who screams billionaire playboy persona, and don't let him do his thing?!
Despite a relatively straightforward plot, it seemed a bit all over the place at times. I think it was in need of editing...
They didn't waste our time with Batman's backstory outside of a quick montage, thankfully. However, it was a bit heavy-handed with the "he's tormented by his past" references. This specifically was annoying in the final battle.
Amy Adams' boobs just out of frame in several shots
Verdict
As a follow-up to a (in my opinion) lackluster Man of Steel, it was definitely an improvement. As a comparison to similar Batman properties (Burton/Nolan), it falls short. It's not going to go down as one of the best superhero movies ever, but it's definitely worth a watch. It seems to fall victim to the world-building "get ready for the next one" trait that befalls other superhero franchises towards the end, but only slightly. It's a lot of fun and packed with references that will make comic book fans beam. To draw a comparison that many others inevitably will, if you liked Man of Steel, you will love Batman v Superman; if you didn't, you will at least enjoy yourself.
Here is his other scores for comparison.
Winter Soldier: 7/10
Guardians: 8/10
DOFP: 8/10
Deadpool: 6/10
Age of Ultron: 5/10