Maxima vs Martian Manhunter

Started by cdtm3 pages
Originally posted by Arabus

What, giving Brainiac a lobotomy isn't enough?

So your main argument, is that because Maxima "defeated" Brainiac in Panic in the Sky, that Brainiac could "never" defeat Maxima?

By this logic, Firelord can never defeat Spider-Man.

Considering some of Brainiac's high end feats, you'll need more then you've given to make a case for Maxima matching Brainiac, let alone being so far above him he could "never" defeat her, as you claim.

Originally posted by cdtm
By this logic, Firelord can never defeat Spider-Man.

Why do people keep bringing up the Firelord/Spiderman example? In the very same issue, Firelord admitted he could annihilate Spiderman with a single aoe burst but he'd take out most of NY city as well. So he decided to play with Spiderman and that's what cost him the fight.

Originally posted by zopzop
Why do people keep bringing up the Firelord/Spiderman example? In the very same issue, Firelord admitted he could annihilate Spiderman with a single aoe burst but he'd take out most of NY city as well. So he decided to play with Spiderman and that's what cost him the fight.

There's that.

But it's just the fact Spidey khtfo. I can just about buy Spidey staggering a guy who trades shots with Thor, because he's awesome like that, but he shouldn't be knocking him out, even if he just stands there and takes it.

Originally posted by cdtm
There's that.

But it's just the fact Spidey khtfo. I can just about buy Spidey staggering a guy who trades shots with Thor, because he's awesome like that, but he shouldn't be knocking him out, even if he just stands there and takes it.


Spiderman almost KOed Masterson Thor till Thor let loose with an AoE attack.

Originally posted by zopzop
Spiderman almost KOed Masterson Thor till Thor let loose with an AoE attack.

Yeah, Masterson sucks. 😈

Panther KOing Mephisto beats all of Spidey's PIS moments, imo. And the armbar on Surfer was pretty neat.

Originally posted by cdtm
So your main argument, is that because Maxima "defeated" Brainiac in Panic in the Sky, that Brainiac could "never" defeat Maxima?

By this logic, Firelord can never defeat Spider-Man.

Considering some of Brainiac's high end feats, you'll need more then you've given to make a case for Maxima matching Brainiac, let alone being so far above him he could "never" defeat her, as you claim.

🙄

FFS, we're talking about Panic In The Sky. This whole thing started because you claimed that Brainiac was surprised, and that's why he lost the duel. In that story, no, Brainiac is not a match for Maxima without Warworld keeping her in check. I gave you examples within that arc of why that position is supported. If you have evidence that this whole story is SMvsFL, then the burden of proof is on you to provide it. Otherwise, you're just making baseless claims.

Originally posted by Arabus
🙄

FFS, we're talking about Panic In The Sky. This whole thing started because you claimed that Brainiac was surprised, and that's why he lost the duel. In that story, no, Brainiac is not a match for Maxima without Warworld keeping her in check. I gave you examples within that arc of why that is. If you have evidence that this whole story is SMvsFL, then the burden of proof is on you to provide it. Otherwise, you're just making baseless claims.

Originally posted by Arabus
Ummm no. Brainiac is not a match for Maxima without Warworld. Period.

Totally not a baseless claim. 😉

Read a comic.

Originally posted by cdtm
Totally not a baseless claim. 😉

Read a comic.

Maybe you should take your own advice before you claim that Brainiac was distracted, and that Maxima was steamrolled prior to that. 😉

Originally posted by cdtm
When he was distracted after Flash ripped him from Warworld, leaving him open to her assault. [/B]
Originally posted by Galan007
Maxima wins, but I don't think it has anything to do with blood manipulation.

TK?

Her TK is insane, I'll admit.

But could it affect MM while phase shifted?