Fist Fight: Captain America/Black Panther vs Lady Shiva/Batman

Started by carver93 pages
carver9 Senior Member

Fist Fight: Captain America/Black Panther vs Lady Shiva/Batman

Pre reboot versions.

They have blue jeans and a tee on.

Who wins?

pym-ftw Mizukage

Team Superhuman

deathslash Pyromaniacal Humanitarian

team one takes this for a solid 7/10 majority.

Daredevil1 Senior Member

Cap and BP 10/10 not easy though.

Mshinu Star for a Brain

Team Bats is outmatched.

wolverinos Restricted

you got to be kidding me... Superhumans vs humans in a fist fight.

pym-ftw Mizukage
Originally posted by deathslash
team one takes this for a solid 7/10 majority.
Originally posted by Daredevil1
Cap and BP 10/10 not easy though.

How is it not a stomp?

comicfan11 Ocean's Heaviest Hitter
Originally posted by pym-ftw
Team Superhuman
Silent Master Senior Member

Team Cap wins

Blue Area Vet Restricted
Originally posted by Silent Master
Team Cap wins

sigh.....Carver, are you feeling well?

deathslash Pyromaniacal Humanitarian

Originally posted by pym-ftw
How is it not a stomp?
Cap is faster and stronger than Batman, but bruce is argueably better in h2h, so it would take a long time for cap to beat him. Panther vastly outranks shiva in terms of intelligence, strength and speed, but isn't as strong in h2h as she is, so it would take a while, but he'd take her out faster than cap would take out bruce. After reconsidering this fight, I'll change my answer to team one taking this 10/10 after a hard fought battle.

namorsubby Senior Member

Either could win. Team 1 is physically superior more or less, team two is more skilled imo.

maxivitopowe Herr Universem

T1

pym-ftw Mizukage

Originally posted by namorsubby
Either could win. Team 1 is physically superior more or less, team two is more skilled imo.

I'm assuming your using the prebbot versions, and really everyone here is skilled enough that its a non factor.

Silent Master Senior Member

IMO the physical gap is larger than the skill gap, plus IMO team Cap has better teamwork.

wolverinos Restricted

what makes people think Batman and lady Shiva are more skilled than captain America and Black Panther?
just because they use more acrobatics and fancy moves does not mean better fighting skills.
both Cap and Panther are extremely skilled and easily a top notch fighters skill wise.

namorsubby Senior Member

Originally posted by pym-ftw
I'm assuming your using the prebbot versions, and really everyone here is skilled enough that its a non factor.
The physical aspect of this match isn't that much of a factor either if you go by feats and not labels.

Supermex NIGHT NIGHT MITCH'S!!

Anybody see BP take on that Hulking cat from Thanos Black Order?
Nuff said..

BP said that the big guy would beaten him if the fight wasn't stopped..
But BP went toe 2 toe with him

Blue Area Vet Restricted
Originally posted by Silent Master
IMO the physical gap is larger than the skill gap, plus IMO team Cap has better teamwork.

The skill gap belongs to team one as well.

Blue Area Vet Restricted

Originally posted by Supermex
Anybody see BP take on that Hulking cat from Thanos Black Order?
Nuff said..

BP said that the big guy would beaten him if the fight wasn't stopped..
But BP went toe 2 toe with him

BP would solo Batman and Shiva. For whatever reason, people continue to be in denial about his power/skill level. The thing is, unlike many other characters, his power level his been largely consistent throughout his history.