What if Qui Gon Never Died?

I think Anikan would of been successfully trained if Qui Gon wouldnt of died. 😉

This is a very complex question... there are many many variables. Would Anakin have been ok? Would the Emperor have been defeated before becoming the Emperor? Would Dooku have been a bad guy? How much of Qui-Gon's attitude would the Jedi have believed? What would have Obi-Wan's career have been like? Would the whole concept of returning after death ever become apparent?

Nightmare.

I say that had he lived he would have successfully trained Anakin as a Jedi. Anakin would then be less vulnearable to Palpatine and would not have allowed his feelings for the beautiful Padme to overcome him. And Obi Wan would not be remembered as the one who trained a future Dark Lord. Had Qui-Gon lived, Dooku might not have joined Sidious. It is hard to really know for sure but the entire Star Wars plotline would have been rewritten. 😉

True.So many Q's and answers to one complex Question"waht if Qui never died?"

First of all. Anikan would probably still have his mother. Qui gon would of wanted him to be with his mother. Im surprised no other jedi thought this would make Anikan just a little bit sad. Which everyone knows what that leads to.

All the other Jedi DID see that- it was one of the first things the Council said to Anakin and one of the reasons for their initial rejection of him.

then why didnt they get his mother?

she could of been a maid.

As pointed out somewhere once, the Jedi are not in the business of dealing with slaves and slavemasters. They could not interfere with Watto's possession of Anakin's mom.

but they interfered with Anikan.

That was Qui Gon's doing. He did not have the approval of the Concil when he did that.

he did they just werent so sure about it.

I mean when Qui Gon first took the boy from his home. That was before the council had met him or knew of him apparently.

yeah i see what you mean.

If Qui never died then Anakin might not have went to the darkside.
But Qui might have joined Dooku.

QGJ would never have joined DOoku...

Never happen in a million of years.

Just as obi 1 said.

Obi-Wan's so smart...

Debateable considering his not being aware of his student's growing frustration with the jedi way. Btw, your new avatar reminds me of the Dr Who opening graphics, Rex! 😄

he does know anakin is arrogant though