What if Qui Gon Never Died?

Apparently not all of you did! I have the added advantage of having read the book just the other day-and remembering key bits from the film itself.

yes they do say that in the film, the book doesnt count

As you so rightly say finti it was in the film. I hope this clears this particular question up Cookies. Feel free to ask any more questions you might have my young apprentice.

I was actually refering to
"There is no anger, there is ..."
that code, not the other one

Oh, the creed. Never liked the sound of that myself.

Oh the Creed! Parts of it did seem harsh especially for Anakin Skywalker in Episode II. The love and anger thing I mean.

I find it very hard to believe that none of the council has ever felt passion. About anything.

passion as in not thinking clear they mean

So will they understand his love for Padme do you think?

yes, it's normal to fall in love
but they don't like it

My friend and I were discussing this same subject earlier and we reached pretty much the same conclusion-at least as much as we can without seeing that final chapter.

I wonder if Yoda ever fell in love. I think most of the others have but Yoda has always seemed kind of lonely to me.

It is only attachment and posession that is forbidden. As Anakin specifies, Jedi are encouraged to love.

Rewind your DVD. He says Jedi are encouraged to feel compassion which is a form of love. Not the same thing. "A certain point of view"

Obviously you need to re-wind it first. He did not say they were encouraged to feel compassion, he said compassion, which he defined as UNCONDITIONAL LOVE, was central to a Jedi.

He then said you might say they were encouraged to love.

In any case, the point that ONLY attachment and possession is forbidden is the important bit. Jedi are allowed all the emotions anyone has, just they must not let them rule them and must not become attached to things.

I need to know how you rewind a DVD

😉
j/k in case you panicked

Yes a dvd cannot be rewinded in the literal sense as a videotape can. Probably just a freudian slip yerss. I wouldn't worry too much about it.

Mine can be rewinded.

Anyway, I've always thought Yoda was lonely. He seems sad deep down.

Originally posted by GordonSkywalker
Yes a dvd cannot be rewinded in the literal sense as a videotape can. Probably just a freudian slip yerss. I wouldn't worry too much about it.

DVDs can be rewinded but not literally.Just to get it all clear.