Originally posted by TheGodKiller
Only h1a8 is capable of trolling himself.Since you did the impossible, there are only two options left to consider: a)you don't exist, or b)you're h1's sock-on-proxy.
You decide.
I hate these tough decisions; but I think i'd rather not exist given the two options. is this the part where my account is terminated?
Originally posted by Nibedicus
Here is the scan again:See the flying rocks? The flying debris? The flying people/mounts?
Do you see any motion lines anywhere? Motion lines weren't used in this artwork. Bad logic is bad.
shrug
Those sure look like motion lines trailing Superman's cape and feet in panel 1 to me...
After reading the various responses I'm going change my stance, I'm in full agreement that it is indeed a KO.
Guys, either get back to the topic or get out of the thread. I want to see evidence of which attack is more powerful. Not this nitpicking which has derailed the thread. Last chance before the warnings/bans start. And FYI, I will be going through the thread and deleting posts. 😉
Actually, the warnings start now. Raisen, you get 2 seperate warnings and TheGodKiller you get 1 warning.
Originally posted by Nibedicus
Your entire foundation for PASSING the buck on burden of proof while maintaining that is a single mod comment in reply to carver which I'm not really fully convinced was an actual mod ruling rather than a mod's comment on what occurred in a scanYou do know, sans the "mod ruling" you keep clinging to, that's exactly what you're doing, right? Passing the burden of proof and requiring irrelevant "proof" unconnected to the actual scan being interpreted?
The fact that you still don't understand what "nitpick" means even after I've posted the meaning to you (with sources) doesn't really help your case either....
Wait... what?
Are you high? When did I ever cite random examples of characters being gone for a while and specifically said they were not KOed??? Please post in quotes where I said this...
You're freaking literally making crap up now....
Stop lying.
Never happened.
Stop lying.
Because they are irrelevant. People can post random examples all day. It has ZERO to do with the specific scan being discussed. With literally tens of thousand out there, I'm sure one can find random examples of just about anything happening to a character. It boils down to one this: they're all irrelevant as we're discussing one specific scan and what the correct interpretation of it is. They all have nothing to do with what is being discussed.
How are you not getting this?
When discussing one specific scan, what is important is pointing out actual indicators found within the specific scan itself that proves your interpretation is correct.
You say that further proof is required by one side of the argument while considering "your side" of the argument to have presented sufficient proof when both sides presented almost identical "kinds" and almost equal levels of proof (interpretation of said scan via physical position/condition of WW's body parts).
That is the double standards debating which one form of hypocrisy.
You see, I would have been ok with you telling me that I've not convinced you with the proof I've provided (I even admitted that the scan itself is a bit vague in one of my posts), but stating that I need to provide proof while accepting the level of proof provided by the "WW is KO'd" side is right about equal in terms of type (and is less properly explained to boot) screaaaams double standards and bias, and I simply had to point it out to you.
Then I'm sure you can offer a rebuttal to the point I made (you can find it at the bottom of page 6) and point out what the logical flaws is there instead of going on a senseless diatribe rife with made up crap, irrelevant crap and stupid crap which stemmed from your crappy understanding of what I posted and crappy understanding of logical reasoning in general so we can end this off topic back and forth?
No, I pointed out that getting struck and not appearing for a few pages/panels happens to characters all the time.
"Not coming back for a few pages/panels" is NOT proof of them being KO'd. It is an assumption.
Thus you cannot use them as direct proof in debates to prove that the character was KOd.
You seem to have a crappy understanding on how logic works...
They were not provided to "support my interpretation", they were provided to stress that you providing them is irrelevant to the point I'm making.
I'm literally spoon feeding you the meaning of everything I said, you seem to constantly get it wrong....
facepalm
I don't really need to provide an example that has no relevance on the point I'm trying to make, soooo nah.
You mean your -goal- of trying to get a rise out of me?
A goal isn't really a point. Thus, I stated that I can't see your point on doing so as you made none.
As you don't seem to know the correct meaning of the word "nitpicking", one wouldn't really put any weight on any "point" you might try to make.
People make typing mistakes all the time (I happen to have spotted and corrected mine within minutes). You trying to somehow use it as a means to reduce my credibility is both laughable and kind of immature and completely fallacious from a logical standpoint.
If anything, it just kills your credibility altogether as it makes you look like you can't seem to formulate a proper argument so you resort to childish antics to try and get people (only Superman fans really) to think you're clever. Bad form, really.
I already pointed out actual examples of you misinterpreting the things I posted as well as the sheer hypocrisy within your entire debating position, none of which you've addressed btw.
So, yes, you ARE a hypocrite that misinterprets things.
ROFLOL.
That's not a strawman. You might want to look up what a strawman fallacy is.
OMG, if you don't know what the big words mean, please don't try to use them and make yourself sound completely foolish....
😆
Edit. In closing, you don't seem to know what "nitpicking" is, you don't seem to know what a "strawman" is, you don't seem to understand how logic works and you don't seem to properly understand the points I'm making even when I'm literally spoonfeeding it to you...
smh.
I'm not going to reply to everything due to what Bada stated, but 1: I'll still provide the scans if you have actual evidence that Wonder Woman wasn't KOed if you give me the issue reference and page numbers, and 2: I can PM you where you were a hypocrite if you'd like. Or better, you PM me and then I'll show you where.
Now I'll be posting examples to stay on topic.
