..... The Hulk Vs Thor .......

Started by janus774 pages

That... Could have been a page out of the bible!

Thor's always been on the brink of breaking out into "Whyyyy Emmmm Ceee aaaAyyyy...", imo.

Marvel has finally decided to push Hulk to the head of the pack. And it only makes sense. His entire mythos is about how dangerous it is if he loses control. That never really made sense if other heroes could beat him straight up.

Originally posted by maxivitopowe
That may be the best point I've ever seen anyone make on the VS forums.

Maybe I've misjudged you.

Originally posted by The Sorrow
You can't change Thor's character and you can't change their history. Hulk wins again.
Last time they fought a weakened Thor KOED an amped up wwh. So ya Thor for a majority

Hulk murders Thor.
This doesn't last long, nor is it pretty for Thor.

Simply put, Thor is not going to survive a single punch from Hulk if Hulk is serious about this.

Regular Savage Hulk would be around Thor + Mjolnir's level.

Originally posted by janus77
Hulk murders Thor.
This doesn't last long, nor is it pretty for Thor.

Simply put, Thor is not going to survive a single punch from Hulk if Hulk is serious about this.

Regular Savage Hulk would be around Thor + Mjolnir's level.

Currently Thor knocks him out by accident again.

Originally posted by janus77
Hulk murders Thor.
This doesn't last long, nor is it pretty for Thor.

Simply put, Thor is not going to survive a single punch from Hulk if Hulk is serious about this.

Regular Savage Hulk would be around Thor + Mjolnir's level.

So does anyone else believe this to be true?
Has Hulk surpassed Thor now?

Meaning they were equals in the past, but now Hulk is the true better of the 2?

Originally posted by Supermex
So does anyone else believe this to be true?
Has Hulk surpassed Thor now?

Meaning they were equals in the past, but now Hulk is the true better of the 2?


It's what Marvel seems to be trying to tell people, some accept some are still in denial.

It's only logical too. Savage Hulk has always been depicted as Thor's superior. Mjolnir was the leveller. It's been said over and over again.

It's undeniable that Hulk from sometime around House of M, began to get stronger as his Banner and Hulk aspects began to come to an understanding. And, as of Planet Hulk and the emergence of Green Scar, it has been a cannon fact that Hulk is the strongest he's ever been. And his feats, well, they seem to heavily indicated that too.

Stan lee once said that "Thor" was going to be marvels superman.........

never happened.

Thor to marvel is what captain marvel is to D.C.

SHIT

Hulk wins, he shouldn't but he will prolly everytime.

Originally posted by zeel
Stan lee once said that "Thor" was going to be marvels superman.........

never happened.

Thor to marvel is what captain marvel is to D.C.

SHIT

Hulk wins, he shouldn't but he will prolly everytime.


Marvel shouldn't have a "superman", that creation is an abomination. Dull and puke-inducing.

One of the reasons I read very little DC is because of his presence. he's too much of an archetype and not enough genuine character.

Thor is better off as he is being treated by Marvel. Could be far worse off, could be ignored and marginalised like Surfer.

Hulk is Marvel's "big gun", but he is part-hero, part-monster, which keeps him interesting and makes his interactions with the rest of the MU less puke-inducing.

Maybe DC are going to turn Superman into the "Thor of DC"? They seem to be toning him down, maybe they'll give him appetites, character, anger and pain and disillusionment and wrath ... Round him out a little?

No, this is how Hulk and Thor have been depicted throughout the ages:

Thor is held as someone who can give the Hulk a fight with fists alone, but will inevitable lose. Mjolnir does indeed level the playing field in the physical aspect, but not only that, it allows Thor to tap into powers beyond what the Hulk can.

It was most recently displayed when Thor supercharged himself so much, even touching him was to much for the Hulk to deal with.

Physically, the Hulk has always been at the very least >= Thor. Thor could give a good fight, but not win. But at the end of the day, only one of them has the power to make Galactus fall back in pain, and it's never been the Hulk. The Hulk will always be < Thor because he's limited. It's the reason we see Thor leading the charge against Glory, the entirety of a pantheon, and have Hulk gang raping the abomination instead.

It's been and likely will continue to be as Hulk being stronger and Thor being more powerful, and in an environment not hampered by plot, power will trump strength.

Gotta admit.
I am entertained.

Originally posted by DarkOdin
Last time they fought a weakened Thor KOED an amped up wwh. So ya Thor for a majority

He wasn't ko'd iirc he was bfr'd, Thor himself passed out afterwards so I'm not sure what this sentence is supposed to mean. It isn't really indicative of how a fight between them would play out.

Originally posted by DarkOdin
Last time they fought a weakened Thor KOED an amped up wwh. So ya Thor for a majority

When?

Originally posted by The Sorrow
He wasn't ko'd iirc he was bfr'd, Thor himself passed out afterwards so I'm not sure what this sentence is supposed to mean. It isn't really indicative of how a fight between them would play out.
It has debated defore it was clear he was koed and was coming to as hi was in orbit and falling back to earth, Yes thats right it would play out the same Thor would pass out after a fight with Hulk, when just prior to the fight he fought a small army and a skyfather then gets teleported directly into a fight with amped Hulk and amped Thing.

Carver as for you you already know when it was when Hulk was 1 of the worthy

However you claim it was not WWH but your own creation family man Hulk

Yeah Hulk wins in comics. We have never seen either one going all out on eachother truly with planet busting attacks. Thor has just put down to many people Hulk wouldnt last very long against. They both are pretty much at the top of the list and have the means to put the other down.but imo versatility and mobility should eventually win the day. Brutebstrength only wins every time in comics.

Hmm, Thor could probably take any Hulk short of Paks Hulk. WBH/ Upper level greenscar would take Thor to the cleaners.

Wbh hulk would take everyone thats not Odin or above to the cleaners.And dry em out. But I get bored with fights like WBH and RKT. To powerful to take seriously.

Originally posted by DarkOdin
It has debated defore it was clear he was koed and was coming to as hi was in orbit and falling back to earth, Yes thats right it would play out the same Thor would pass out after a fight with Hulk, when just prior to the fight he fought a small army and a skyfather then gets teleported directly into a fight with amped Hulk and amped Thing.

Carver as for you you already know when it was when Hulk was 1 of the worthy

However you claim it was not WWH but your own creation family man Hulk


Amongst who? Thor fans? I seem to remember he was still holding onto his hammer after the blast which indicates he wasn't out. Looking at it from your pov lets say he was briefly ko'd, in the context of that fight it wouldn't have made a difference because Nul was awake and no worse for wear when he landed. He could have returned to the fight, and would have found a near-dead Thor on the ground. This was also a completely bloodlusted Thor, and written by Fraction who essentially wrote him on steroids most of the time.

Hulk is the stronger and tougher of the two, but Odinson has Mjolnir which is an equalizer in most situations. If Thor doesn't approach this fight with a bloodlusted mentality from the outset and fight smart, he's going to find it very hard to keep Hulk down.

Wasn't the Thor that fought Prof. Hulk in the Arctic, going all out? Prof. Hulk had little problem handling him.