Originally posted by janus77
Putting aside the PIS nature of Thanos' feat (Surfer is pure energy - he doesn't have to have a body), I'd say that Hulk doesn't require a heart or lungs to fight and operate normally, so why would he require a physical brain?It doesn't seem at all possible that brain damage would affect Hulk, should it even be possible for Thanos to inflict any such a think by overcoming 1) his insane durability and 2) his "functionally immortal" making healing factor.
We've seen Hulk riddled with high-power adamantium bullets, barrage upon barrage and no lasting damage.
Getting back to Surfer, he really was jobbed out to Thanos (as he always is). Someone who can reform - instantly - from being atomised and can take smacks and smashes from Galactus on a fairly regular basis, has no business being that affected by Thanos' attacks.
Yes Thanos should be more powerful than Surfer, but nowhere close to that much more... Pure PIS, imo.
I agree that the surfer death makes no sense. it's apparent that thanos was meant to be surfer's kryptonite.
regarding the HF. it seems to me that the brain does matter. it's always been represented that way
Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Is this like group therapy? We should do trust exercises next. Where all of you trust me with your bank accounts and girl friends.
1. I'm actually trying to see if people around here actually look at different viewpoints.
2. I also want to extend the life of this thread so we can troll eachother
3. I'll trust anybody with my girl. if she chooses to screw somebody, it's that b1tches problem. my issue would be with her. she's an adult and can make adult decisions.
4. I trust nobody with my money tho
Originally posted by Raisen
I agree that the surfer death makes no sense. it's apparent that thanos was meant to be surfer's kryptonite.regarding the HF. it seems to me that the brain does matter. it's always been represented that way
At "WWH" levels, he was reforming from far more damage, instantly, so to me there is no concern about such a tactic of attack.
His HF isn't something his brain initiates or regulates or something that a lack of a physical brain would impede, nothing I can recall to suggest Hulk would have trouble just regrowing a brain - instantly - whilst getting a little more pissed off and a hell of a lot more durable.
Originally posted by ShadowFyre
I like trying to find scenarios in which both can win. Its kinda easy especiallynwith powerhouses like this. And I like your thinking on the girls and money thing.
you can't go around stressing what your girl's doing. if it happens, kick her out. there's always other fish in the sea. they won't all be gold diggers or hoes
make sure everything is in your name too.
Originally posted by Odekahn
Yes, and then that if he jolted Logan's head around it would slow his HF. He punches him repeatedly in the head and then Logan is KO'd and Hulk said, "Just as I thought"
I dont see that as a healing factor. A healing factor in no way hinders or helps someone getting knockes out. That is an instantaneous by product of your brain bouncing off your skull. If anything. Wolverine should get knocked out even easier by anyone spider man strength or above and almost never by anyone below.
Originally posted by Malkaedus
Forgive me for my ignorance, but when did this happen? Surfer was alive during Infinity.
It was just one of the many indignities Marvel inflict upon their greatest creation(s).
Galactus and Surfer are the best things Marvel ever made, and they **** them up every chance they get.
Originally posted by ShadowFyre
I dont see that as a healing factor. A healing factor in no way hinders or helps someone getting knockes out. That is an instantaneous by product of your brain bouncing off your skull. If anything. Wolverine should get knocked out even easier by anyone spider man strength or above and almost never by anyone below.
You might not, but the writer does. It's what Hulk is talking about as he's beating on Logan.
Originally posted by janus77
I think it's a question of character. Hulk has ripped out a chunk of his own brain before, and survived it.At "WWH" levels, he was reforming from far more damage, instantly, so to me there is no concern about such a tactic of attack.
His HF isn't something his brain initiates or regulates or something that a lack of a physical brain would impede, nothing I can recall to suggest Hulk would have trouble just regrowing a brain - instantly - whilst getting a little more pissed off and a hell of a lot more durable.
I don't remember him ripping out part of his brain. did it affect his logic, speech, movement in any way? if so, that would lend credence that he would be ko'ed that way.
are you saying hulk is un koable? I seem to remember him being ko'ed by far less than thanos....multiple times. and the ko occurs from getting hit too hard in the head..........
Originally posted by janus77
This was long before Infinity, before Annihilation even.It was just one of the many indignities Marvel inflict upon their greatest creation(s).
Galactus and Surfer are the best things Marvel ever made, and they **** them up every chance they get.
Just found a synopsis of the story on the Marvel Universe site. Apparently Surfer's death was more due to Death wanting him as her new consort and less what Thanos was actually doing to him.
Originally posted by Raisen
I can understand that.think about how you would support WWH in this fight
Ok. I'm down. 👆
Let's see.....
The best chance I think Hulk would have would be to try to outsmart Thanos and lure him into some sort of weakened position. I think BFR is probably Banner's best option.
I just don't see WWH besting the Thanos we saw in Infinity without something up his sleeve.
Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Arenhulks brains and organs super dense as well?And raisen, Im the gold digger bro. Goin cougar huntin at the casino in a few hours lol
hulks brains and organs are super tough. antman was one of the guys to comment on this. I doubt they're tougher than surfer's tho
I do like the cougars. but the one's you find at a casino are seventy year old martini drinkers.
you're better than that.
Originally posted by Raisen
I don't remember him ripping out part of his brain. did it affect his logic, speech, movement in any way? if so, that would lend credence that he would be ko'ed that way.are you saying hulk is un koable? I seem to remember him being ko'ed by far less than thanos....multiple times. and the ko occurs from getting hit too hard in the head..........
Savage Hulk has had some ridiculous lows and his average is around Thor level, maybe a little higher.
This though is Green Scar and he was several tiers higher up on average, than Savage Hulk.
Prof. Hulk is the one who ripped out a chunk of his own brain. He was in pain and raging, but conscious.
Green Scar is "Hulk at his strongest". "WWH" is KMC mod-created Hulk that works within the parameters of the WWH story, but without the bit about Hulk only operating at those levels because he consciously chose to hold back (what Cho and Hulk state throughout and during HoTM).
Originally posted by Odekahn
What did Hulk say about Wolverine's healing factor, carver?
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/62/70877240kh7.jpg/
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/62/92196991hl0.jpg/
http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/62/84399283zt4.jpg/
LOL...during the time Hulk pounded on Wolverine face, Wolverine was slashing Hulk across the eyes, arms, etc... if you truly believe Thanos can grab, overpower Hulk, and pound on his face WHILE tanking one of the strongest Hulk punches across the face, then you are truly high.
What if Hulk grabs Thanos like he did Wolverine and punch him repeatably across the head, what would Thanos do?
