Thor vs Dr. Manhatten

Originally posted by eaebiakuya
Surfer can do everything you listed here. And he can do even more and in a bigger scale.

Still, he dont have a free win over Thor.

Arguing anything about Dr. Manhattan is stupid for both parties trying to argue him both ways. Get over it. His powers and capabilities were never anything important to the character beyond the fact that he was beyond everything else in the Watchmen universe. Hell he could have been Bendis powered Luke Cage level and still at least marginally fulfilled his role in the watchmen series as the lone truly superhuman asset the world knew, looking in at the plights of mere mortals....

edit: I meant to say non-Bendis

Originally posted by Silent Master
Heralds have fought inside blackholes before without suffering any damage, so please stop lying.

Originally posted by h1a8
The writer didn't want him to try. Probably because the writer forgot his powers. This has happened thousands of times in comics.

Originally posted by Mindset
DM can't even cure cancer.

Originally posted by Mindset
Cool that DM can really cure cancer easily.

Originally posted by h1a8
Thor wasn't one of those heralds. And I'm not referring to the event horizon of a black hole (which can be huge) but the actual singularity that is in the center of the black hole (basically planck size).

I never said that Thor was one of them, but blackholes aren't herald killers and I'd be more than happy to compare Thor's durability feats to the characters in question.

Originally posted by Silent Master
I never said that Thor was one of them, but blackholes aren't herald killers and I'd be more than happy to compare Thor's durability feats to the characters in question.

Originally posted by h1a8
A black hole is the most powerful thing in the universe. There is no durability feat greater than surviving a black hole. Any feat by Thor would greatly pale in comparison to a surviving a black hole. So what's to compare? It still wouldn't prove that Thor is capable of surviving a black hole. You have to compare Thor's feats with that of the black hole feat. Nothing else.

No, I can compare Thor's feats to other people that have survived a black hole...so do you want to compare feats?

Originally posted by Silent Master
No, I can compare Thor's feats to other people that have survived a black hole...so do you want to compare feats?

And surviving inside the event horizon is not the same as surviving touching the singularity.

Originally posted by h1a8
and what would that achieve?

And surviving inside the event horizon is not the same as surviving touching the singularity.

It would prove that Thor has better feats than people that have survived blackholes.

Now, do you want to compare feats?

Originally posted by Silent Master
It would prove that Thor has better feats than people that have survived blackholes.

Now, do you want to compare feats?

Thor has damaged beings like Galactus whos durability piss on black holes. He has also physically damaged Surfer, someone who glides through Black Holes without trouble. He has worked Terrax and Terrax was in a black hole for months 'while weakened'.

Originally posted by h1a8
How would it when the black hole feat is greater than any feat by Thor?
but if that's the only purpose then it is moot since it doesn't show that Thor can survive one.

Do you have any examples of a black-hole killing someone with Thor's durability?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Do you have any examples of a black-hole killing someone with Thor's durability?

note: the closer you are to a singularity the astronomically the more the force. Touching the singularity produces infinite tearing force on an object. No being in the universe can survive touching a singularity.

Originally posted by h1a8
the guy surfer killed with a black hole blast.
do you have examples of Thor having feats that compare to surviving a black hole?

Ok, let's compare their durability feats.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Ok, let's compare their durability feats.

Do you have examples of Thor having feats that compare to surviving touching a singularity?

Originally posted by h1a8
I answered your question. don't ignore my question.

Do you have examples of Thor having feats that compare to surviving touching a singularity?

No you didn't, you named a random guy, you need to post his durability feats in order to prove that he's on Thor's durability level.

Originally posted by Silent Master
No you didn't, you named a random guy, you need to post his durability feats in order to prove that he's on Thor's durability level.

Originally posted by h1a8
what does that have to do with anything I said. I could be right or wrong but I answered your question. You never answered mine.

I asked for examples of a bkack-hole killing someone with Thor's durability, You have yet to provide any proof that the person you named had Thor level durability.

Has anyone in comics died as a result of falling into a blackhole?
Legit question, just wondering.

Originally posted by Silent Master
I asked for examples of a bkack-hole killing someone with Thor's durability, You have yet to provide any proof that the person you named had Thor level durability.