Supergirl vs Wonder Woman

Originally posted by light889
Are you talking about that issue where WW got shot in jl rebirth? What is that jl issue supposed to prove? It was writen by priest. Who onece said about WW. I don't relate to white women in tiaras talking big talk. The bias is real. And Isn't WW a character that has a susceptibility to piercing weapons? What does her susceptibility to piercing weapons have to do with anthing here? Here she is going to be takig physical hits. Something her character has always been capable of doing. Hits from Powergirl, Supergirl, Superman, Grail, Darkseid, etc.

Bullets aren't sharp,btw. They just have a lot of energy behind them.

Like a Kryptonian fist .

And what's batman got to do with anything? Last time i checked, he shouldn't be able to do anything against powerhouses in random fights. Without PIS/WIS helping him.

Why is Batman fighting WW PIS and Supergirl fighting WW not PIS?

I can show Supergirl faster and stronger than WW since rebirth, just like I can show WW faster and stronger than Batman. Yet, strangely, only the one you dislike is PIS, but the other isn't. Funny that.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85

It happened. Doesn't matter who wrote it. Priest, Simone, Morrison, whatever. Fact remains, in a canon comic, WW is unable to react to a ricocheted bullet, and when she is unable to react, nearly died.

Bullets aren't sharp,btw. They just have a lot of energy behind them.

Like a Kryptonian fist .

Why is Batman fighting WW PIS and Supergirl fighting WW not PIS?

I can show Supergirl faster and stronger than WW since rebirth, just like I can show WW faster and stronger than Batman. Yet, strangely, only the one you dislike is PIS, but the other isn't. Funny that. [/B]

In canon comics WW has dealt with speeding bullets countless times. In canon, Rebirth WW took a bullet to the brain and kept fighting.

Like a kryptonian fist? Like the countless kryptonian fists WW has been able to take in 78 years of comics?

Why is PIS. Maybe because batman shouln't be able to physically fight anybody in WW class. While WW actually has the stats to be a credible challenge for sg.

Originally posted by light889
In canon comics WW has deal with speeding bullets countless times. In canon, Rebirth WW took a bullet to the brain and kept fighting.

Like a kryptonian fist? Like the countless kryptonian fists WW has been able to take in 78 years of comics? Try again.

Why is PIS.

Maybe because batman shouln't be able to physically fight anybody in WW class. So try to lowball better next time.

No, she has not been shown to be bulletproof in canon comics. If you can, please post them.

78 years =/=Rebirth. Try to keep up.

Just like WW isn't able to fight someone in Supergirl's class with all powers on

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
No, she has not been shown to be bulletproof in canon comics. If you can, please post them.

78 years =/=Rebirth. Try to keep up.

Just like WW isn't able to fight someone in Supergirl's class with all powers on

This thread was made during N52. So that is the version of sg and WW we should be discussing.

But since you insist. WW in Rebirth took a bullet to the brain. Didn't die and kept on fighting with said bullet still inside her brain. It was in Metal. So that's that.

WW has been fighting characters in sg class for decades. She has faced sg more than once and won every time. Oh yeah, so unable to fight sg indeed. LOL.

Originally posted by light889
This thread was made during N52. So that is the version of sg and WW we should be discussing.

But since you insist. WW in Rebirth took a bullet to the brain. Didn't die and kept on fighting with said bullet still inside her brain. It was in Metal. So that's that.

WW has been fighting characters in sg class for decades. She has faced sg more than once and won every time. So unable to fight sg indeed. LOL.

The thread was bumped during Rebirth. So that's the version we should be using.

But since you insist, that showing DEFINITELY shows WW as not being bulletproof.

Why do you keep talking about 'decades', even after talking about n52, let alone Rebirth?

Lol.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
The thread was bumped during Rebirth. So that's the version we should be using.

But since you insist, that showing DEFINITELY shows WW as not being bulletproof.

Why do you keep talking about 'decades', even after talking about n52, let alone Rebirth?

Lol.

I would imagine that if it was done during N52. That would be the version we'd discuss. Or is a rule that says we should discuss current versions if an old thread that was using a previous version is bumped?

Right. Not bulletproof. But it showed her healing factor and regenaration ability. As she didn't die from getting shot in the brain, didn't need medical attention. And kept fighting with the bullet still inside her brain.

You want to talk about Rebirth only? Rebirth WW was not unable to fight sg. Who was even amped and trying to kill her. So where is this myth of "Rebirth WW can't take hits from sg", coming from?

Originally posted by light889
I would imagine that if it was done during N52. That would be the version we'd discuss.

Right. Not bulletproof. But showec her healing factor and regenaration ability. As she didn't die from getting shot in the brain, didn't need medical attention. And kept fighting with the bullet still inside her brain.

You want to talk about Rebirth only? Rebirth WW was not unable to fight sg. Who was even amped and trying to kill her. So where is this myth of "Rebirth WW can't take hits from sg", coming from?

But it was bumped during Rebirth. So no.

So we have one showing of her needing medical attention, and one not.

Moreover, it shows her poor durability.

This 'myth' is due to my point that ithe WW/Supergirl fight is PIS, based on a bullet being able to go through WW. Kara's fist packs more energy than a bullet.

Just like Batman/WW is PIS, so too is WW/Supergirl. As Supergirl's fist packs far far more energy than a mere bullet.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
But it was bumped during Rebirth. So no.

So we have one showing of her needing medical attention, and one not.

Moreover, it shows her poor durability.

This 'myth' is due to my point that ithe WW/Supergirl fight is PIS, based on a bullet being able to go through WW. Kara's fist packs more energy than a bullet.

Just like Batman/WW is PIS, so too is WW/Supergirl. As Supergirl's fist packs far far more energy than a mere bullet.

No, we also have the one of her getting shot in the chest and abdomen. She didn't need medical attention there either. Plus you missed the context in the priest one. You should go back and read what happen after the shot. The whole part of her fighting a God. And what that God of death tells WW.

Your point has no weight. Because WW not being bulletproof has always been the weakness in her overall durability. Her achilles heel. It has never stopped her from being capable of taking hits from heavy hitters. Something she has alway done and is still doing in Rebirth. So.

Originally posted by light889
No, we also have the one of her getting shot in the chest and abdomen. She didn't need medical attention there either. Plus you missed the context in the priest one. You should go back and read what happen after the shot. The whole part of her fighting a God. And what that God of death tells WW.

Your point has no weight. Because WW not being bulletproof has always been the weakness in her overall durability. Her achilles heel. It has never stopped her from being capable of taking hits from heavy hitters. Something she has alway done and is still doing in Rebirth. So.

So.....it's PIS that she can take the hits.

Thanks.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
So.....it's PIS that she can take the hits.

Thanks.

It's not. Wonder Woman has an specific susceptibility to bullets. Achilles was invulnerable except for a very specific part of his body. Wonder Woman is a character inspired in mythology. So that is her own achilles heel. It takes nothing away from her durability as a whole. Rebirth Wonder Woman has been seen taking hits from many heavy hitters. Jason, Grail, sg, Superman, Damage, Darkseid, Doomsday, etc. So trying to label as PIS an entire catalogue of feats is ridiculous.

Originally posted by light889
It's not. Wonder Woman has an specific susceptibility to bullets. Achilles was invulnerable except for a very specific part of his body. Wonder Woman is a character inspired in mythology. So that is her own achilles heel. It takes nothing away from her durability as a whole. Rebirth Wonder Woman has been seen taking hits from many heavy hitters. Jason, Grail, sg, Superman, Damage, Darkseid, Doomsday, etc. So trying to label as PIS an entire catalogue of feats is ridiculous.

So if she was shot by bullets shaped like tiny fists, she'd be ok?

What if someone punched her whilst wearing bullet shaped boxing gloves?

If Superman threw (as opposed to shot) a bullet at her, would it go through her?

What happens when Hal Jordan makes a bullet construct?

Would Batman hurt her if he had bullets between his fingers, like a stubby Wolverine?

Is there a size limit, so big bullets hurt more than small bullets?

This bullet weakness is fascinating.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
So if she was shot by bullets shaped like tiny fists, she'd be ok?

What if someone punched her whilst wearing bullet shaped boxing gloves?

If Superman threw (as opposed to shot) a bullet at her, would it go through her?

What happens when Hal Jordan makes a bullet construct?

Would Batman hurt her if he had bullets between his fingers, like a stubby Wolverine?

Is there a size limit, so big bullets hurt more than small bullets?

This bullet weakness is fascinating.

We already saw her more than once, getting bullets in vital organs and surviving based on her healing/regeneration ability.

But how is that relevant to the attacks she will be facing here? It's no different from the countless times she has been shown taking hits from heavy hitters. Or haven't you seen WW taking hits from heavy hitters before?

Originally posted by light889
We already saw her more than once, getting bullets in vital organs and surviving based on her healing/regeneration ability.

But how is that relevant to the physical attacks she will be facing here? It's no different from the countless times she has been shown taking hits from heavy hitters. Or haven't you seen WW taking hits from heavy hitters before?

So what happens if Supergirl wore bullet shaped boxing gloves?

It's no different than Batman taking hits from heavy hitters. Or haven't you seen Batman taking hits from heavy hitters before?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
So what happens if Supergirl wore bullet shaped boxing gloves?

It's no different than Batman taking hits from heavy hitters. Or haven't you seen Batman taking hits from heavy hitters before?

Is Batman a clay figure brought to life by magic. Or a DemiGod. Is there anything making him capable of taking hits from heavy hitters like in WW's case? And do the majority of his durability feats involve him taking hits from heavy hitters like in WW's case? But Since you want to claim that WW taking attacks from heavy hitters in Rebirth, and in her whole 78 years of comic book history basically is pis. I guess we can do the opposite and say batman has powerhouse level of durability.

What's going on in this thread is laughable. It's like saying Wonderman or even Rhino could punch through Wonder Woman. Funny!!!

2019 carver9 is a beast we haven't known before.

I'm biting my lip each time I see him post.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
2019 carver9 is a beast we haven't known before.

I'm biting my lip each time I see him post.

He gives me a concussion every time he posts 👆

Bullets have nothing to do with this thread. WW can be pierced by bullets yet take Superman's most powerful punches without being killed or penetrated by them. We just chalk it up to comic logic or it is her magical weakness (when the cross sectional area of an object is below a certain point then she can be pierced by it).

Anyway. I believe that SG is stronger (not by a lot). Not sure about durability though. SG may be a little more durable against punches but WW has larger damage soak (not by a lot).

SG should win this. But it will be close.
But make no mistake, if skill and weaponry were allowed against SG (full powers) then I would argue that WW wins.

Originally posted by h1a8
Bullets have nothing to do with this thread. WW can be pierced by bullets yet take Superman's most powerful punches without being killed or penetrated by them. We just chalk it up to comic logic or it is her magical weakness (when the cross sectional area of an object is below a certain point then she can be pierced by it).

Anyway. I believe that SG is stronger (not by a lot). Not sure about durability though. SG may be a little more durable against punches but WW has larger damage soak (not by a lot).

SG should win this. But it will be close.
But make no mistake, if skill and weaponry were allowed against SG (full powers) then I would argue that WW wins.

I don't really see sg as stronger or more durable. They are always shown to be peers. WW is mentioned in comics as being stronger than her, and the strongest female hero on earth.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
He gives me a concussion every time he posts 👆

My brain's had enough, too.

He's not gonna show us mercy, though.