12 rounds with Wildcat · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

JayDaDon World Champion

Originally posted by abhilegend
Cap wins against Ted like Batman but to think its going to be easy is ridiculous. Ted knocked out Hawkman with a headbutt and Carter shits on Cap in stats.

Not saying it would be easy and Cap also occasionally bats way outside his and Ted's league as well, but I agree and would probably also give the slight nod to Batman winning also.

Q99 Senior Member

Originally posted by namorsubby
Jay garrick, Stargirl, etc. I'm too lazy to post it. The respect thread links in the second page.

Couldn't find the Stargirl one, but they aren't martial artists in any case, so they aren't the best judges.

You've read the Birds of Prey storyline where he and Canary go up against the 12 Brothers in Silk, right? It's a cool story that shows Ted fight alongside and against some good foes, and I think it respects him well, but it doesn't paint him as the most skilled in the room.

namorsubby Senior Member

Originally posted by Q99
Couldn't find the Stargirl one, but they aren't martial artists in any case, so they aren't the best judges.
You've read the Birds of Prey storyline where he and Canary go up against the 12 Brothers in Silk, right? It's a cool story that shows Ted fight alongside and against some good foes, and I think it respects him well, but it doesn't paint him as the most skilled in the room.

I believe that's the one where he punched that guy for making fun of his hat and he "catches" ninja stars by simply letting them become embedded in his hand. Cool read. And yes id admit that's he isn't the most skilled fighter overall. But in the dc universe its been made clear that he is without question the "finest boxer who had ever lived". Cap holds no such distinction in his comic universe

Originally posted by JayDaDon
So your saying Captain America holds NO physical advantages over Wildcat? lol

umm no. You said MASSIVE physical advantages. Not so according to feats.