Poll
22%
78%
Originally posted by Firefly218
It is clearly stated in LotR that only the lava of Mt. Doom can destroy the ring. This means that absolutely NOTHING else can destroy the ring.
No limits fallacy applies as always. If you think magical poison can't destroy that ring and only lava can, your smoking to much peace pipe.
Originally posted by Supra
No limits fallacy applies as always. If you think magical poison can't destroy that ring and only lava can, your smoking to much peace pipe.
I dont think you understood. ABSOLUTELY NOTHING can destroy the ring, including normal fire and lava, except for the lava in Mt. Doom.
Why the phuck do you think Frodo spent 3 movies traveling to Mt. Doom?
Originally posted by Firefly218
Are you being serious or trolling? I'm actually very curious.
No I'm being serious, have you actually watched the movies, everyone tells Gandalf "NO, Your Crazy, Leave Me Alone, Stop, I don't want to."
The guardian council told him "Don't Go!!!!"
Does Gandalf listen? No.
Now look, Smaug is about to destroy Lake Village because he would not listen.
Originally posted by Supra
No I'm being serious, have you actually watched the movies, everyone tells Gandalf "NO, Your Crazy, Leave Me Alone, Stop, I don't want to."The guardian council told him "Don't Go!!!!"
Does Gandalf listen? No.
Are you kidding me? The council was in total agreement with Gandalf.
They even assembled a fellowship of middle earth's greatest warriors to accompany Frodo.
The council, along with Gandalf, realized that destroying the ring was important and it could only be done in Mt. Doom
Originally posted by Firefly218
Are you kidding me? The council was in total agreement with Gandalf.
They even assembled a fellowship of middle earth's greatest warriors to accompany Frodo.The council, along with Gandalf, realized that destroying the ring was important and it could only be done in Mt. Doom
Im talking about in the Hobbit Part 2, the council said do no go..he did not listen.
The ring was fine with Froto and Bilbo as clearly Hobbits are the only ones how cannot handle it, Gandalf didn't even touch the ring and suddenly he's been hexed by Sauron into his bidding.
Originally posted by Firefly218
It is clearly stated in LotR that only the lava of Mt. Doom can destroy the ring. This means that absolutely NOTHING else can destroy the ring.
At best, that just means that nothing else in the LotRverse can destroy the ring, it doesn't mean that other universes don't have objects/people that could destroy it.
That said, I'm not convinced that a Basilisk fang woud do it.
Originally posted by Silent Master
At best, that just means that nothing else in the LotRverse can destroy the ring, it doesn't mean that other universes don't have objects/people that could destroy it.
Originally posted by Silent MasterThat said, I'm not convinced that a Basilisk fang woud do it.
And this too, seeing as the Basilisk Fand lacks the power neccesary