Can the Master Sword cut through Sauron's ring ? · Foreign Cinema

Yamcha Desert Bandit

Originally posted by Nephthys
How sharp is it?

I came in here, saw this, and automatically thought a cheese discussion was going on..

I was sadly mistaken :c.

The Scenario Greater Sci-Fi combatant

Originally posted by quanchi112
You are lying to yourself. You're repressing memories. We'd need to put you under hypnosis to admit the truth.

I'm always ready to submit to you, Master, but don't you remember? My orders are clear; I can't lie without permission, or I punish myself. It hurts, Master.

jmoul Senior Member

I came onto this thread looking for an intelligent debate, but it turns out this is a terrible discussion. The Ring was made to be completely indestructible by any means other than being thrown into Mount Doom. Even Elvish swords could not break it. The Master Sword is incredibly strong with magic, but Sauron's magic is too strong for even the Master Sword.

The Ring survives the impact from the Master Sword.

StealthRanger S Class Demon

Were it book versions that might very well be the case

Though it's movie versions so, yeah

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by The Scenario
I'm always ready to submit to you, Master, but don't you remember? My orders are clear; I can't lie without permission, or I punish myself. It hurts, Master.

Listen just admit that the sword fails here and I will take the gag off.

NemeBro Senior Member

Originally posted by StealthRanger
Were it book versions that might very well be the case
Though it's movie versions so, yeah

That wouldn't be the case though.

The Master Sword has better feats bro.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by NemeBro
That wouldn't be the case though.
The Master Sword has better feats bro.

TP version, bro.

NemeBro Senior Member

This is also the movie and not book version, I was just clarifying Stealth's post.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by NemeBro
This is also the movie and not book version, I was just clarifying Stealth's post.

So you concede and agree the master sword fails here.

The Scenario Greater Sci-Fi combatant

Originally posted by quanchi112
Listen just admit that the sword fails here and I will take the gag off.

I like the gag, Master.

Master Sword is demonstrably more powerful than Elvish swords and the Ring itself. It dispels the Ring's magic and breaks it.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by The Scenario
I like the gag, Master.
Master Sword is demonstrably more powerful than Elvish swords and the Ring itself. It dispels the Ring's magic and breaks it.

It can't dispel the magic unless it can cut through it. It didn't dispel Dorf until it pierced his weak soft girl like flesh.

It breaks against the ring.

Sauron and Quan are seen laughing and high fiving.

NemeBro Senior Member

What feats do the One Ring have?

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by NemeBro
What feats do the One Ring have?

Resisting an axe.

NemeBro Senior Member

What feats does the axe have?

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by NemeBro
What feats does the axe have?

Being wielded by a badass dwarf.

Now what feats does the Master Sword have ?

NemeBro Senior Member

Cutting Ganondorf. Ganondorf has better feats than the One Ring.

MS wins.

The Scenario Greater Sci-Fi combatant

Originally posted by quanchi112
It can't dispel the magic unless it can cut through it. It didn't dispel Dorf until it pierced his weak soft girl like flesh.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TShJJKsN6TU

Oh, Master, I'm sorry but I can't allow you to lie, either. The Master Sword can dispel magic from a distance, without even touching the target. That's why it can hurt Ganondorf at all, remember?

It breaks against the ring.
Sauron and Quan are seen laughing and high fiving.

I'm sorry Sauron had to die.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by NemeBro
Cutting Ganondorf. Ganondorf has better feats than the One Ring.
MS wins.

Physical weapons always cut him. What physical weapons has Dorf resisted ?

NemeBro Senior Member

A castle blowing up.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by The Scenario
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TShJJKsN6TU
Oh, Master, I'm sorry but I can't allow you to lie, either. The Master Sword can dispel magic from a distance, without even touching the target. That's why it can hurt Ganondorf at all, remember?
I'm sorry Sauron had to die.

That magic can also work again on Link. His sword didn't dispel Dorfs magic until it was lodged into him.

Executioner sword hurt him which he never recovered from to the day a 17 year old crushed him in combat.

Ms breaks.

Sauron lives until he meets Voldemort that is.