Planet Hulk vs Ultimate Hulk(Ultimates)

The fight takes place in an arena

Ultimate Hulk wrecked the Avengers, picked up mjonir and was destroying ships with his fists that nothing short of a nuclear explosion could damage.

Planet Hulk wins.

Planet Hulk takes care of business

PH

Planet Hulk was a good Hulk but Ultimate Hulk was a rage monster which may give him the edge.

Planet Hulk could barely beat Beta Ray. Actually, he was unable to beat him until he got a cheap shot in.

Ultimate Hulk was taking on the entire Avengers team. Ultimate Hulk definitely wins.

Of course if we included Hulk from the Hulk vs. Thor dvd, then that Hulk wrecks all.

Ultimate Hulk wins.

Weren't those ships Ult Hulk destroyed weak to gamma radiation, I seem to recall that being hit with gamma rad made them brittle.

Maybe. But he still wrecked the Avengers and picked up Mjolnir. Planet Hulk wasn't all that impressive imo.

Ultimate Hulk wins, but not easily. His blind, unending rage is the key for a win.

Originally posted by FrothByte
Planet Hulk could barely beat Beta Ray. Actually, he was unable to beat him until he got a cheap shot in.

Ultimate Hulk was taking on the entire Avengers team. Ultimate Hulk definitely wins.

Of course if we included Hulk from the Hulk vs. Thor dvd, then that Hulk wrecks all.

Hulk was weakened when he fought Bill. Weakened by the portal and the disks. During the end, nothing could stop him. He tanked EVERYTHING.

But wasn't horse Thor weakened too? He went through the portal and had the same disks on him too.

Originally posted by Psychotron
But wasn't horse Thor weakened too? He went through the portal and had the same disks on him too.

He didn't go through the same portal. Also, his powers is different than Hulk...Hulk power is to grow more powerful while getting mad...without that, he was just another strong man with a minor healing factor. Bets Ray Bill still bad high end durability, blasts, etc...he wasnt as handicapped as Hulk (and didn't go through the portal Hulk went through along with the consistent battles).

Leaning towards planet hulk.

Planet Hulk is the superior film.

But PH feats don't compare to UH's feats, iirc. UH was close to Mindless Hulk in portrayal. He swiped the floor with all the Avengers and almost outright killed a few of them.

Originally posted by Robtard
Planet Hulk is the superior film.

But PH feats don't compare to UH's feats, iirc. UH was close to Mindless Hulk in portrayal. He swiped the floor with all the Avengers and almost outright killed a few of them.

He also picked up Thors Hammer and one shotted Thor with it.

YouTube video

I put that under the "wiped the floor with all the Avengers" category.

Thinking about it, Iron Man, Thor, Captain America or Pym could have possibly taken down everything or almost everything PH faced in his film. The spores would be the one problem, though IM would be safe.

Him picking up Thors hammer might put him in a different category and make him stronger then PH.

Originally posted by carver9
He didn't go through the same portal. Also, his powers is different than Hulk...Hulk power is to grow more powerful while getting mad...without that, he was just another strong man with a minor healing factor. Bets Ray Bill still bad high end durability, blasts, etc...he wasnt as handicapped as Hulk (and didn't go through the portal Hulk went through along with the consistent battles).

There's really nothing in the movie to indicate that going through the portal made him weaker.

The disc however did control his rage somewhat, which I guess translates to limiting his strength, but that still doesn't change the fact that Beta Ray BIll was beating him to the punch nearly every time.

And IIRC, that disc also allowed him to be more of a "thinking" Hulk and kept him in Hulk form even after he's been knocked out. So it's both an advantage and a disadvantage.