DOE Bane vs. Revan (Novel)

Started by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ4 pages

DOE Bane vs. Revan (Novel)

This has probably been done before, but i felt like making this thread anyways. Who wins? Takes place on a flat and open terrain on Naboo.

Revan gets stomped.

Revan stomps.

Revan gets slaughtered

Reasons please.

Revan just can't compete in swordsmanship.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Revan just can't compete in swordsmanship.

You gave Revan the win against Mace not long ago, but I think we both agree that he can't compete with Mace in a duel either.

Because Revan had better Force powers. And I think he could hold off Mace for a bit in a duel. Bane would crush Revan in a lightsaber fight and has superior Force abilities imo.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Because Revan had better Force powers. And I think he could hold off Mace for a bit in a duel. Bane would crush Revan in a lightsaber fight and has superior Force abilities imo.

Revan's Force feats vastly outstrip Bane's. As does Mace's, for that matter, but that's neither here nor there.

Oh yeah, I forgot who I was talking to for a moment there.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Oh yeah, I forgot who I was talking to for a moment there.

Bane's dick up your ass for so long must really hurt, which is probably why you're grumpy.

But for real, the Encyclopedia does credit Revan's absorption and deflection of Nyriss' lightning as a demonstration of his raw Force strength. Bane has never displayed such power.

Nah, after the first 30 seconds the pain stops as the anus softens. And then its all aboard the Bane train!

Which encyclopedia? Also disagree, Bane has fantastic feats in more than just one area. Revan's tutaminis is great, but thats about it. Bane would take him in a TK battle. At the least, Revan's not going to be doing shit to Bane with the Force, making it a pure lightsaber fight.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Nah, after the first 30 seconds the pain stops as the anus softens. And then its all aboard the Bane train!

Which encyclopedia? Also disagree, Bane has fantastic feats in more than just one area. Revan's tutaminis is great, but thats about it. Bane would take him in a TK battle. At the least, Revan's not going to be doing shit to Bane with the Force, making it a pure lightsaber fight.


The official TOR Encyclopedia: ''Revan's raw power in the Force bends Nyris's Sith lightning back at her, utterly destroying the Sith.''

Force strength is pretty much what determines one's telekinetic power. When Bane displays such Force strength, we can talk.

Ah yes.

No it isn't. Your telekinetic power determines your telekinetic power. Try again.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Ah yes.

No it isn't. Your telekinetic power determines your telekinetic power. Try again.


😬

It does. The more Force strength, the more powerful you're gonna be telekinetically, and the stronger a Force aura you can raise.

Bane has the best tutaminis feat in history by far.

Your mastery of telekinesis is what determines how great you are. Just like every other Force power, your ability with the technique in question is the the deciding factor of how good you are with it. Are we to assume that everyone is just as good at all aspects of the Force as they demonstrate with a single one?

Originally posted by Nephthys
Your mastery of telekinesis is what determines how great you are. Just like every other Force power, your ability with the technique in question is the the deciding factor of how good you are with it. Are we to assume that everyone is just as good at all aspects of the Force as they demonstrate with a single one?

There's a difference between ''power'' and ''mastery''. Force ''power'' determines the power that one can unleash through telekinesis; Force ''mastery'' determines how well one can unleash said power.

I'm not sure why you're mentioning other aspects of the Force when we're talking about the telekinetic aspect only.

You both [Intrepid & Nephthys] have a point.

Generally, I think it's a safe assumption that a powerful adept will be naturally gifted in the core applications of the Force: superhuman strength, speed, reflexes, telekinesis, telepathy, etc.

But, to Nephthys's point, there is a difference between power and skill. And if raw Force strength always determined telekinetic prowess, then Anakin's TK should eclipse Yoda's.

Originally posted by Intrepid37
There's a difference between ''power'' and ''mastery''. Force ''power'' determines the power that one can unleash through telekinesis; Force ''mastery'' determines how well one can unleash said power.

I'm not sure why you're mentioning other aspects of the Force when we're talking about the telekinetic aspect only.

No, mastery refers to how well you can wield it in general. Including how much you can actually unleash.

What the ****? You're the one who brought up Revan using Tutaminis as proof that he's better at TK than Bane. 🙄

This point is ridiculous anyway since Revan is not more powerful than Bane.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
But, to Nephthys's point, there is a difference between power and skill. And if raw Force strength always determined telekinetic prowess, then Anakin's TK should eclipse Yoda's.

Exactly.