Wolverine vs Captain America

Started by Robtard24 pages
Originally posted by Firefly218
True, but as long as Cap has his shield Wolverine can't lay a claw on him. Cap is much faster and more agile, and therefore should be able to easily block Wolverine's slow attacks

The shield is only so large, so it's silly to assume Cap is 100% safe with his shield.

Watching Cap fight and Wolverine fight, they're about the same in terms of speed.

With the shield I only saw cap be able to defend against a single knife hand

He also defended himself from multiple gunfire... which all moves faster than Wolverine's claws. Wolverine had trouble with a single katana wielding Samurai. Cap is enhanced human. Faster, stronger and more agile. Wolverine ain't winning this.

yeah its kinda easy for you to block bullet fire when they are aiming directly at your shield

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
He got knocked out by a non adamentium bullet to the head in X-3 man. Funny how you leave that fact out in your examination of all the movies.
😕
KingD19 did mention it:
Originally posted by KingD19
X2
A 0mm bullet to the skull knocked him out.

To me it's pretty clear; X-Men version of Logan was a chump who was easy to KO despite his physiological capabilities. Origins and The Wolverine however gave him beastly new feats.

Imo, X-version would lose while the Origins/TheWolverine-version would win.

Originally posted by Robtard
The shield is only so large, so it's silly to assume Cap is 100% safe with his shield.

Watching Cap fight and Wolverine fight, they're about the same in terms of speed.

Wolverine's no where near as fast.

Originally posted by Epicurus
😕
KingD19 did mention it:

To me it's pretty clear; X-Men version of Logan was a chump who was easy to KO despite his physiological capabilities. Origins and The Wolverine however gave him beastly new feats.

Imo, X-version would lose while the Origins/TheWolverine-version would win.

Yeah but since they're all part of the same continuity, the logical thing to think is a bullet can knock out Wolverine. But might not. Also maybe his berserker rage helped him not being KO'd by the adamantium bullets. He was quite calm when the normal bullet KO'd him.

Wolverine has the one hitter quitter.
Cap will need to land several blows without getting hit if he is to survive.

Originally posted by God Cloth Seiya

Cap will need to land several blows without getting hit if he is to survive.

Which he easily can with his SHIELD, superior speed and combat prowess.

Also CAP could take getting stabbed a couple of times. Just not in a fatal area.

Claws > Guns

If he stabs him even once he could bleed to death

Originally posted by God Cloth Seiya
Claws > Guns

If he stabs him even once he could bleed to death

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Which he easily can with his SHIELD, superior speed and combat prowess.

Also CAP could take getting stabbed a couple of times. Just not in a fatal area.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Wolverine's no where near as fast.

Yeah but since they're all part of the same continuity, the logical thing to think is a bullet can knock out Wolverine. But might not. Also maybe his berserker rage helped him not being KO'd by the adamantium bullets. He was quite calm when the normal bullet KO'd him.


He survived a nuke in The Wolverine. And that was before the adamantium upgrade.

Since Origins is more recent than the X-Men films, I am presuming his feats from that should be counted. Which means that a non-adamantium bullet to the head would do little more than piss him off in a forum fight.

So that's that.

To the death, Wolvie. To the win/KO, Cap.

Originally posted by The Spleen
To the death, Wolvie. To the win/KO, Cap.

Once Cap KOs Wolverine, he'll find a way to Kill him

Originally posted by Firefly218
Once Cap KOs Wolverine, he'll find a way to Kill him
No.

Originally posted by The Spleen
No.

Good argument.

Originally posted by Firefly218
Good argument.
It's a simple no. Details? OK. What gear does Cap have that will kill Wolvie?

Originally posted by The Spleen
It's a simple no. Details? OK. What gear does Cap have that will kill Wolvie?

Cap could possibly sever Wolverine's head with his shield. With his super strength, if Cap repeatedly slams his shield on Wolverine's neck.

Originally posted by Epicurus
He survived a nuke in The Wolverine. And that was before the adamantium upgrade.

Since Origins is more recent than the X-Men films, I am presuming his feats from that should be counted. Which means that a non-adamantium bullet to the head would do little more than piss him off in a forum fight.

So that's that.

No that's not that. You've just made up your own rules there. I could argue Singer's films are the more canon one, as those are the ones people generally like (including First Class as Singer was involved in that one too), and are most familiar with.

And then that's that for me. Fact is X1 and X2 are completely 100% canon to this UNiverse, and you can't just write them off.

Also in "The Wolverine" he was KO'd when injected with drugs/poison whatever. So he can be KO'd, it's not just a matter of "he survived a Nuke so can't be KO'd by anything else, even though he has been several times now.

Originally posted by Firefly218
Cap could possibly sever Wolverine's head with his shield. With his super strength, if Cap repeatedly slams his shield on Wolverine's neck.

Yeah, that's true. Cap could potentially decapitate Wolverine, or cut off any part of him.

Cap doesn't have the strength or the superheated edge necessary to cut through Adamantium. Nor is his shield fully Adamantium so there's still no guarantee it would work going by X-Movieverse rules.

And taking into account all movies involving Wolverine. He has more showings of tanking/shrugging off damage than not.

I'm going with Logan on this one. His claws offer a far more effective and versatile mode of attack than Steve's shield. Once Cap loses the shield (and he eventually will), it's all over.