Wolverine vs Captain America

Started by Time Immemorial24 pages

Originally posted by God Cloth Seiya
Ah you keep copy catting me cause you want to be just like me.

I feel for you 👆

Takes one to know one, don't be all but hurt because wolverine beat deadpool once and therefore you think now deadpool can take Thor.

Who's the deadpool and wolverine fanboy afterall?

Wrong thread, I don't mind if bring up other characters into the thread as long as they have something to do with the debate.

Originally posted by God Cloth Seiya
Wrong thread, I don't mind if bring up other characters into the thread as long as they have something to do with the debate.

So its the right thread for you when you want to bring up a character for your debate, but its the wrong thread if I wan't to do it. Your a Hypocrite and you lost both debates.

Uh no here is what I mean since your maturity won't let you understand

In the other thread I'm ok with this cause its a feat that actually has something to do with this.

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
He was not hurt by Ironman, Captain had to stop the fight before Thor was going to do him in.

I do mind this though

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
Terminator said in T2 he feels pain, does that mean he is hurt? No

Understand?

Originally posted by God Cloth Seiya
Uh no here is what I mean since your maturity won't let you understand

In the other thread I'm ok with this cause its a feat that actually has something to do with this.

I do mind this though

Understand?

Quit making insults and passing them off as knowledge. Your wrong.

Saids the guy whose been calling me names like a 3 year old.

Cap eventually scores the K'O

Originally posted by Time Immemorial
So they have the same durability, except, wolverine needs an adamentium skeleton and uber regen healing factor to match cap's built in durability.

so you're saying that Cap could do the Hiroshima feat?

He could, he'd just not heal right away and he'd be on the floor crying, if he managed to remain conscious through it.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
No that's not that. You've just made up your own rules there. I could argue Singer's films are the more canon one, as those are the ones people generally like (including First Class as Singer was involved in that one too), and are most familiar with.

And then that's that for me. Fact is X1 and X2 are completely 100% canon to this UNiverse, and you can't just write them off.

Also in "The Wolverine" he was KO'd when injected with drugs/poison whatever. So he can be KO'd, it's not just a matter of "he survived a Nuke so can't be KO'd by anything else, even though he has been several times now.

Yeah, that's true. Cap could potentially decapitate Wolverine, or cut off any part of him.


I haven't made up any rules here. It's not about what one likes, it's about what's more recent, and Logan's feats in Origins and The Wolverine are more recent, which would give them precedence over previous films. Especially when they contradict previous low showings such as him being KO'd by a bullet to the head.

Of course they are canon, but Origins is more recent than them, and TW is even more recent than Origins.

IIRC, his healing factor was compromised in that. And when exactly did Cap get knockout drugs/toxins as part of his standard equipment anyways? Or are you mentioning a scene from a special edition version of a Captain America film which only you saw?

Wolverine's skeleton is indestructible, so lol no.

Originally posted by Epicurus
I haven't made up any rules here. It's not about what one likes, it's about what's more recent, and Logan's feats in Origins and The Wolverine are more recent, which would give them precedence over previous films. Especially when they contradict previous low showings such as him being KO'd by a bullet to the head.

Of course they are canon, but Origins is more recent than them, and TW is even more recent than Origins.

Who said "recent" = "more canon"?

In fact I wouldn't at all be surprised if Origins: Wolverine gets written out of canon. It's already got contradictions to the rest of the series like the "Emma Frost" thing. And Sabretooth being Wolverine's brother LOL.

But if we are to put them all in the same continuity, then we'd have to assume that modern day Wolverine gets KO'd more easily than Past Wolverine.

Either way you can't just write off events from the 2 films which started off the series. And the only 2 made by the guy who created the series.

Originally posted by Epicurus
IIRC, his healing factor was compromised in that.

No, it was after he cured himself.

Originally posted by Epicurus
And when exactly did Cap get knockout drugs/toxins as part of his standard equipment anyways? Or are you mentioning a scene from a special edition version of a Captain America film which only you saw?

He's an agent of shield. He can carry those kind of weapons if he knows who he's up against.

But that wasn't my point anyway. Point is Poisons are different to Nuke's melting your flesh, different to blunt trauma to the head. So you can't just say "He survived a nuke therefore nothing can knock him out now!" Because clearly in canon he can and has been KO'd several times in different ways.

Originally posted by Epicurus
Wolverine's skeleton is indestructible, so lol no.

So is Cap's Shield. He wouldn't even have to break the adamantium, just use enough force to separate them at their joints.

Logan fights like a tard going head on relying on his hf he basically has no h2h skills.
While Cap is ridicolusly skilled in the 2 nd movie.
He will block Logan's attacks and Ko him with the shield.

Well if we use the feat from the origins movie, Deadpool was shwon being able to go hypersonic fighting speed without trying. Wolverine was able to keep up with him in H2H so wouldn't that make wolverine faster than cap?

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Who said "recent" = "more canon"?

It doesn't mean more canon but it definitely means greater precedence. Everyone is relying largely on Cap's feats from Winter Soldier over and above his feats in Avengers and the first Captain America movie.

Anyways, precedence or not, that single bullet KO scene doesn't override multiple showings in Origins where Wolverine tanks greater amount of damage without getting taken out. Especially when there is another scene where he tanks a bullet to the head without any problem whatsoever.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER

In fact I wouldn't at all be surprised if Origins: Wolverine gets written out of canon. It's already got contradictions to the rest of the series like the "Emma Frost" thing. And Sabretooth being Wolverine's brother LOL.

Now you're just plain speculating. Origins is part of established X-canon, and pretending that it no longer applies based on a What If scenario that you cooked up is downright disingenuous.
Originally posted by DARTH POWER

But if we are to put them all in the same continuity, then we'd have to assume that modern day Wolverine gets KO'd more easily than Past Wolverine.

Either way you can't just write off events from the 2 films which started off the series. And the only 2 made by the guy who created the series.


Which is why I separated Origins-level Wolverine from the one portrayed in the X-trilogy. It was you who stated that they should both be treated as part of the same canon, and should therefore be the same character

I absolutely can, if we are to take into consideration the overall picture based on all the known canon. Origins gave him a shitton of beastly feats, and ignoring them in light of a few low showings here and there is you doing what you're preaching against.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER

No, it was after he cured himself.

Okay.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER

He's an agent of shield. He can carry those kind of weapons if he knows who he's up against.

Again, speculation. Cap's standard equipment has primarily consisted of his shield and the uniform throughout much of his onscreen career. You can't arbitrarily give him additional tools based on speculation about what SHIELD agents carry around with the. I could easily claim that Logan, being a former elite mutant merc should have access to stuff which mercs have, but that's not the way to debate.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
But that wasn't my point anyway. Point is Poisons are different to Nuke's melting your flesh, different to blunt trauma to the head. So you can't just say "He survived a nuke therefore nothing can knock him out now!" Because clearly in canon he can and has been KO'd several times in different ways.

Poisons are inferior to nukes. That's the difference between them. I am not claiming that surviving a nuke makes him invincible, I am saying that him tanking the radioactive fallout is a feat well beyond most of Cap's feats except for the disintegration gun. We have also seen him tank greater damage than what has KO'd him in the movies, and in greater number of instances as well. Guess you'll manage to come up with some strange reasoning as to how those feats become invalid in light of the fewer number of his lower end showings.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER

So is Cap's Shield. He wouldn't even have to break the adamantium, just use enough force to separate them at their joints.

Magneto and Phoenix, with their vast electromagnetic and telekinetic power were unable to break apart Logan's skeleton, so what makes you think Cap can?

Originally posted by Epicurus
Magneto and Phoenix, with their vast electromagnetic and telekinetic power were unable to break apart Logan's skeleton, so what makes you think Cap can?

TBF, Phoenix was deliberately holding back, and IDK if Mags ever tried to break Logan's skeleton onscreen. He had no trouble controlling it.

But yeah, Steve goes down here.

Originally posted by Lestov16
TBF, Phoenix was deliberately holding back, and IDK if Mags ever tried to break Logan's skeleton onscreen. He had no trouble controlling it.

But yeah, Steve goes down here.


She didn't seem to hold back when Logan was powering through her attempts to disintegrate him. Yes, he did when he attacked him and Rogue in the train in the first X-Men film. He tried to rip his claws out but failed. Though he was toying with him in that scene.

Even though a lot of people won't agree with me I see the stats like this

Durability= Wolverine > Cap. I say this cause we saw wolverine tanking bullets and still standing while cap was shot by a lot less and went down to the ground.

Fighting speed= Wolverine > Cap. I say this because Cap only showed to have superhuman fighting speed while wolverine was shown fighting a guy who had hypersonic fighting speed.

Strength= Cap > Wolverine. I never really seen any superhuman strength wolverine unless I missed one but I think cap has shown better strength feats.

Special things= Wolverine > Cap. Healing factor and an unbreakable skeleton is pretty much much better than caps shield.

Originally posted by God Cloth Seiya
Durability= Wolverine > Cap

Hiroshima and Phoenix

I said wolverines durability is higher. What are you saying?

Those are the only things you need to prove it