Sedriss defeated Kam Solusar, was good enough to give Luke Skywalker some trouble and even when he died he was able to take Ood Bnar out with him.
Kit Fisto was defeated by Ventress, was easily slain by Palpatine (although to be fair, it is Palpatine so no shame there) and was unwilling to face Grievous directly unless he had back-up. When he was alone against Grievous he mostly relied on hiding and evasions. Only when he'd grabbed one of Grievous's weapons did he dare confront him directly.
I'm going with the guy that has actual victories and overall more impressive feats.
Sedriss wins this one.
Fisto is strong enough to rend durasteel when he split an aquatic war droid in half along with having redirected omnidirectional fire and managing to destroy the legs on a huge separatist super weapon via a version of force push underwater. I have no idea who this other guy is but if he can compete with that and beating Grievous someone who has dueled evenly while disadvantaged with Mace Windu then he has my respect.
Originally posted by Syndicate
I have no idea who this other guy is
This should fill you in:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uDMHKZGJmHA&list=UUSgZNhMGO4hmZa9jjg6fp2w
Originally posted by Syndicate
but if he can compete with that and beating Grievous someone who has dueled evenly while disadvantaged with Mace Windu
He can.
Originally posted by Syndicate
then he has my respect.
He should.
Originally posted by Syndicate
I need feats before I can doll out my respect. :3
Watch the video in the link provided and you'll get plenty of feats.
Originally posted by Galan007
When did Sedriss "give Luke trouble"..? I recall Luke one-shotting him with a TK shove.
The audio drama gives the more complete version of the fight. As I said, watch the video for the explanation.
Originally posted by chilled monkeyThat fan-made video, while moderately informative if you knew nothing of the character beforehand, does not suffice as canonical evidence.
The audio drama gives the more complete version of the fight. As I said, watch the video for the explanation.
The narrator of the vid states Sedriss "stood up to Luke Skywalker", and splices-in a panel from the comic. Here's the entirety of their comic 'battle':
http://imgur.com/u73JZup
http://imgur.com/KfyJFlh
Sedriss attempts to force-choke Luke's cohort. Luke negates said attack. Sedriss then begins charging toward Luke. Luke owns him with a single TK gesture. /fight
The narrator is just using purple prose to try and make Sedriss sound more impressive than he was--but he certainly never 'gave Luke trouble', like you said.
Originally posted by Galan007
That fan-made video, while moderately informative if you knew nothing of the character beforehand, does not suffice as canonical evidence.The narrator of the vid states Sedriss "stood up to Luke Skywalker", and splices-in a panel from the comic. Here's the entirety of their comic 'battle':
http://imgur.com/u73JZup
http://imgur.com/KfyJFlh
Sedriss attempts to force-choke Luke's cohort. Luke negates said attack. Sedriss then begins charging toward Luke. Luke owns him with a single TK gesture. /fightThe narrator is just using purple prose to try and make Sedriss sound more impressive than he was--but he certainly never 'gave Luke trouble', like you said.
Very good and detailed post