Bastila Shan and Revan Vs Anakin Skywalker and Ahsoka Tano

Started by Nephthys6 pages
Originally posted by NewGuy01
Nyriss's charring/incinerating people was also on a Nexus. 😮

Which is irrelevant to Revan's feat of absorbing the attack.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Nah. Ahsoka will got for Bastila. He can't hold them both off while protecting Bastila.

If Dooku can engage Anakin and Obi-Wan then Revan can engage Anakin and Ahsoka.

Hell, I could see Revan taking out Ahsoka quite easily. Shes a little out of her depth imo.


It doesn't matter what feats Vitiate and Nyriss have off nexus because Revan fought them on nexus.

Right, Revan is unaffected by this fact, in fact he benefits immensely. Vitiate and Nyriss on the whole look all the worse for it though.

Now, that all being said, it doesn't really make him better than Anakin or Vader at all, even if Ant wants it to

The slaughter of *that* many force sensitives in a duel has only been outmatched by Tulak Hord.

In addition to such, Revan has superior accolades, intelligence, and the addition of some pretty deadly Sith powers. Even if you put Revan lower then Anakin, you cannot deny the fight itself would be brutal.

With these abilities he has proven his capability in combat in his defeat of Darth Malak, Mandalore the Ultimate, and he cut down dozens of Dark Jedi *totallllll* on the Star Forge.

You forgot his slaughter of the two Terentateks and his solo of the Sith Academy on Korriban.


You forgot his slaughter of the two Terentateks and his solo of the Sith Academy on Korriban.

I don't find the Terentatek thing as impressive as you do for sheer skill, I purposefully left it out.

Forgot the Sith Academy thing though.

Just one of the two terentatek wtfpwned the two best Terentatek killers, which included a Jedi related to Ulic.
In addition, they immune to nearly all attacks of the Force (this is stated, not game mechanics), and if I believe correctly, the worst of the Sith Alchemy.

Terentateks are no joke. 😬

2 of them at once is highly impressive.

I feel people forget Revan didn't just beat Malak...
He beat Malak's ass 7 times over

Just one of the two terentatek wtfpwned the two best Terentatek killers, which included a Jedi related to Ulic.
In addition, they immune to nearly all attacks of the Force

Cay really, really sucks though.

I understand they were immune to Force Attacks (Though funnily enough, IIRC Force Attacks worked just fine on them in the game) and that Revan likely dispatched them with a lightsaber.

However, I personally don't think Revan cutting down wild beasts really speaks for how he would fare against a sophisticated duelist, so I didn't include it. I do not know why you are making such a big deal of this.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
I feel people forget Revan didn't just beat Malak...
He beat Malak's ass 7 times over

I don't. Its why I argue that Revan is at least Dooku level and probably higher.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Now, it is my personal opinion that Anakin probably has a chance of soloing even an amped Revan, and with Ahsoka at his side the battle is pretty well in Team 2's favor.

This is pretty hilarious though.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
However, I personally don't think Revan cutting down wild beasts really speaks for how he would fare against a sophisticated duelist, so I didn't include it. I do not know why you are making such a big deal of this.

Calling them 'wild beasts' is understating the feat quite a lot, dude. They're dark side abominations designed to kill Jedi.

]I feel people forget Revan didn't just beat Malak...
He beat Malak's ass 7 times over

That one is a game mechanic lol.

Nope. Cutscenes.
Also stated in various sources he replenished his health from the Jedi numerous time. Do you want some quotes, or do you trust me enough?

I don't. Its why I argue that Revan is at least Dooku level and probably higher.

I think putting him higher than Dooku is being overwhelmingly generous, people fail to realize Dooku being someone who can compete with Yoda on fair ground is astounding.

Not to say Revan isn't definitely up there as well, though. Ant's more recent finds, as small as they may seem, are truly adding to Revan's credibility largely.

This is pretty hilarious though.

I don't find it funny, really. Revan's feats simply aren't as good as Anakin's in any area other than his immense knowledge and intelligence.

Anakin is frankly the more powerful, and the more skilled, no matter how you look at it.

Calling them 'wild beasts' is understating the feat quite a lot, dude. They're dark side abominations designed to kill Jedi.

As I said, defeating such powerful creatures is a highly impressive feat. I simply don't think it constitutes to Revan's capability in a sophisticated duel, even if they're horrifyingly powerful monsters, they're still wild untamed beasts.


Also stated in various sources he replenished his health from the Jedi numerous time. Do you want some quotes, or do you trust me enough

The quotes say he drew on the captive Jedi's powers to sustain himself, not that he got defeated 7 times and ran around while Revan simply stood there watching as he dripfed himself on Jedi-slurpies.

I will go on a hunt to find quotes them.
I shall return either victorious, or still grasping to the cutscenes. Either way, I win.

Well, that was quick.

"The ceiling is a huge glass dome that offers views out onto the surface of the Star Forge. Sith battle cruisers float up from where they have been constructed. Imprisoned in the walls of the room are eight comatose Jedi. These Jedi are prisoners of war that have been tortured and transformed into receptacles for dark side power. They no longer have any consciousness. Malak uses them to add to his already formidable dark side power. Combat begins. Whenever you reduce Malak['s health]...he turns (or moves) to face the closest Jedi body. He then casts drain life on the body. This immediately destroys the body and increases Malak’s vitality and Force points back to full. The Jedi bodies are the key to your defeat or victory. Normally, Malak’s “regeneration” from the life of the imprisoned Jedi would mean you’d face him in combat until he snapped the last of your powers and then defeated you, but you have options. You can dispatch each of the Jedi bodies by using offensive Force powers on them,... thus depriving Malak of his power...When Malak is finally cut down, he falls to his knees."
-KotORPG

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
I will go on a hunt to find quotes them.
I shall return either victorious, or still grasping to the cutscenes. Either way, I win.

We only see Malak draining stuff in the cutscenes, we don't see that he was "defeated" every time it happened, just that he was sustaining himself on the Jedi's life forces. I've read all the quotes you are referring to, and they will hurt you more than they'll help. You lose, broski.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Well, that was quick.

"The ceiling is a huge glass dome that offers views out onto the surface of the Star Forge. Sith battle cruisers float up from where they have been constructed. Imprisoned in the walls of the room are eight comatose Jedi. These Jedi are prisoners of war that have been tortured and transformed into receptacles for dark side power. They no longer have any consciousness. Malak uses them to add to his already formidable dark side power. Combat begins. Whenever you reduce Malak['s health]...he turns (or moves) to face the closest Jedi body. He then casts drain life on the body. This immediately destroys the body and increases Malak’s vitality and Force points back to full. The Jedi bodies are the key to your defeat or victory. Normally, Malak’s “regeneration” from the life of the imprisoned Jedi would mean you’d face him in combat until he snapped the last of your powers and then defeated you, but you have options. You can dispatch each of the Jedi bodies by using offensive Force powers on them,... thus depriving Malak of his power...When Malak is finally cut down, he falls to his knees."
-KotORPG

That's a description of the gameplay, not a canonical synopsis of the battle dude.

The book is a canonical source, bro.

That book is an RPG guide that speaks to the player directly and talks about reducing Malak's health points until he restores himself to full HP and Force Points on the captive Jedi. 😬

Good luck convincing anyone that this--a walkthrough guide that refers to the battle as something you(the player) have several options in going through--As a canonical description of the event.

The cutscenes are canon, and they show Malak "replenishing his health." "Replenishing" is defined as to "fill something up again", which means Malak's health must be low. My point stands, ever without the RPG guide.