Originally posted by dadudemon
Nah, it did and I quotted it.But don't twist my point to mean what you want it to mean just to be right about something. At best, your argument is one of degrees, at the worst, you're completely and utterly wrong.
you are ONCE AGAIN being a spiteful, evasive, and deceptive troll because of your inability confront even your most trivial errors.
Originally posted by Robtard
Show Shae doesn't appear to be a gold digger, as pointed out: Tyrion offered her a life of ease and wealth in Braavos(?); she turned it down.
With only a moderate stipend.
You interpret that to be sentimentality, I interpret that to be her being greedy and wanting more than a moderate stipend.
Originally posted by Robtard
Her love for Tyrion seems genuine, which will be the troubling part when he chokes her to death.
I don't think that. She did not seem genuine about her love in the show, to me. She seemed like a gold digger who was just a dumber version of Petyr.
Originally posted by focus4chumps
you are ONCE AGAIN being a spiteful, evasive, and deceptive troll because of your inability confront even your most trivial errors. ffs getting tired of your shit
Dude...calm down. You're the one that keeps quotting me and forcing points of argument on me (ones that I am not making).
Sure, Tyrion didn't call her a whore to her face in the books, because SHAE SAID IT HERSELF in the books in the "parallel" scene. But he did try to send her away which, for me, was interpreted as a rejection by Tyrion which is why I think Shae betrayed him in the books. In the show, because people are stupid, it was spelled out more clearly with Tyrion going ape-shit on her when he rejected her.
Saw that edit where you scaled back your misplaced rage. I added it back in by hitting the back button in the browser. Nice try.
Originally posted by Bardock42
Anyways, the Shae character in the show seems to react very differently, and ostensibly is influenced by completely different motives, than the Shae character in the books.
I disagree. Here's a point that illustrates part of why I disagree:
Originally posted by dadudemon
[in reference to sending Shae away with a Stipend]With only a moderate stipend.You interpret that to be sentimentality, I interpret that to be her being greedy and wanting more than a moderate stipend.
I don't think that. She did not seem genuine about her love in the show, to me. She seemed like a gold digger who was just a dumber version of Petyr.
Basically, I think they are both gold diggers and we will see that in this next episode where Shae shows her true colors to Tyrion before he chokes her. Keep in mind, she has to say something that gets Tyrion to choke her to death on Sunday. 🙂
That's not so much a point why you disagree, but a repetition of your feelings of disagreement, but fair enough, I mean I find the arguments brought by the others in the thread here immensely compelling, and yours strenuous at best, but we don't have to agree on everything, we can still get married.
Originally posted by dadudemon
With only a moderate stipend.You interpret that to be sentimentality, I interpret that to be her being greedy and wanting more than a moderate stipend.
I don't think that. She did not seem genuine about her love in the show, to me. She seemed like a gold digger who was just a dumber version of Petyr.
It would have been more than she currently had, which was working for a living and getting the odd gift from Tyrion after she sucked on his cock, no? It also would have meant she was safe from his father's wrath of: "next whore I'll hang". (why imo, she might have been a spy from the start in the show)
If show Shae just wanted more money, she probably could have asked and Tyrion would have provided, since he's in love with her.
Disagree, obviously, show Shae seems like actual affection/love up to the point of her dismissal. Guess we'll have to see how it plays out.