Superman Vs. Thanos Modified Slugfest

Started by abhilegend6 pages

Originally posted by pym-ftw
so according to you if superman flew into the shade he is at risk of rapidly depowering himself?

Yes. Nightshade has drained him that way. Why is that relevant here however?

Originally posted by h1a8
Superman's strength feats (when he isn't holding back) are clearly greater than Thanos strength feats (who almost never holds back).

Superman went from not being able to hurt DD to killing him in a few panels. This is more than a 5x strength difference. DD was wrecking heralds (MM and Guy) with ease.

Superman went from using all his might and all of his powers and not doing much to a probe to one shotting them like tissue paper. This is more than a 5x strength difference.

So Superman at normal holding back levels is one of the strongest heralds in D.C. but when he lets loose then he is on a whole other level.

Thanos greatest strength feats are
7 hitting Surfer with amped power fists
Wrestling with Drax to cause a planet to destroy itself
Any other feats are significantly less.

With that said, there are plenty of feats by Superman that surpass those by a lot.

Where are u pulling these numbers from? Everything u stated was just wrong

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Where are u pulling these numbers from? Everything u stated was just wrong
Then debate my points. Stop being lazy.

1. Superman's strength feats (when he isn't holding back) are clearly greater than Thanos strength feats (who almost never holds back).

2. Superman went from not being able to hurt DD to killing him in a few panels. This is more than a 5x strength difference. DD was wrecking heralds (MM and Guy) with ease.

3. Superman went from using all his might and all of his powers and not doing much to a probe to one shotting them like tissue paper. This is more than a 5x strength difference.

4. So Superman at normal holding back levels is one of the strongest heralds in D.C. but when he lets loose then he is on another level.

5. Thanos greatest strength feats are
7 hitting Surfer with amped power fists
Wrestling with Drax to cause a planet to destroy itself
Any other feats are significantly less.

I challenge you are anyone to debate against one of my points.

Would love to see actual proof of these random ass numbers

I'm confused, what is the general consensus?

Originally posted by h1a8
Then debate my points. Stop being lazy.

1. Superman's strength feats (when he isn't holding back) are clearly greater than Thanos strength feats (who almost never holds back).

2. Superman went from not being able to hurt DD to killing him in a few panels. This is more than a 5x strength difference. DD was wrecking heralds (MM and Guy) with ease.

3. Superman went from using all his might and all of his powers and not doing much to a probe to one shotting them like tissue paper. This is more than a 5x strength difference.

4. So Superman at normal holding back levels is one of the strongest heralds in D.C. but when he lets loose then he is on another level.

5. Thanos greatest strength feats are
7 hitting Surfer with amped power fists
Wrestling with Drax to cause a planet to destroy itself
Any other feats are significantly less.

I challenge you are anyone to debate against one of my points.

I have challenged you before, what happened to your response??

Hmm...

I think this goes down the same way a slugfest between Superman and Mongul would.

Originally posted by JBL
I have challenged you before, what happened to your response??

Response to what? I don't remember. Statement me again and I will respond.

Originally posted by Insane Titan
Would love to see actual proof of these random ass numbers

Random number? Are you slow?
How many times more force does one need in order to go from not hurting you with their blows to killing you in a few panels? More than 1 times, more than 2,...?

As far as the other points, there are no numbers at all. Care to refute them instead of troll?

Originally posted by h1a8
Random number? Are you slow?
How many times more force does one need in order to go from not hurting you with their blows to killing you in a few panels? More than 1 times, more than 2,...?

As far as the other points, there are no numbers at all. Care to refute them instead of troll?

you have no proof as to how comic charaters punching power increase when holding back etc. Show me actual proof to back up your numbers and not your bullshit opinion.

Your other points are pure fail as you simply ingnore everything put before you.

pg Thor hits harder than Superman and Thanos smiled at him, oh and actually back up the "pg Thor is only 1.5x stronger" reply you will post with real proof or you get reported as I've proven you wrong everytime on this point

Originally posted by MF DELPH
Hmm...

I think this goes down the same way a slugfest between Superman and Mongul would.

So are you saying Superman wins?

Originally posted by Insane Titan
you have no proof as to how comic charaters punching power increase when holding back etc. Show me actual proof to back up your numbers and not your bullshit opinion.

Your other points are pure fail as you simply ingnore everything put before you.

pg Thor hits harder than Superman and Thanos smiled at him, oh and actually back up the "pg Thor is only 1.5x stronger" reply you will post with real proof or you get reported as I've proven you wrong everytime on this point

Thor's best striking feat in BLOOD & THUNDER was one-shottig Drax. That was without the Power Gem. Masterson-Thor arguably did better against Thanos than the batshit insane Thor in B&T. If Thor was physically amped by the Power Gem, he certainly didn't look it unless you argue narration.

Originally posted by Delta1938
So are you saying Superman wins?

Thor's best striking feat in BLOOD & THUNDER was one-shottig Drax. That was without the Power Gem. Masterson-Thor arguably did better against Thanos than the batshit insane Thor in B&T. If Thor was physically amped by the Power Gem, he certainly didn't look it unless you argue narration.

Thanos let Maesterson Thor beat on him and was putting on show for Death like he was in danger to try and impress her with his courage. Him and Mephisto even talked about the plan.

PG Thor caused actual harm to Thanos with punches alone, hell Thor using his hammer with the same amount of shots and Things help couldn't achieve what PG Thor did and they fought the weak pre Rez Thanos

Originally posted by Insane Titan
you have no proof as to how comic charaters punching power increase when holding back etc. Show me actual proof to back up your numbers and not your bullshit opinion.

Your other points are pure fail as you simply ingnore everything put before you.

pg Thor hits harder than Superman and Thanos smiled at him, oh and actually back up the "pg Thor is only 1.5x stronger" reply you will post with real proof or you get reported as I've proven you wrong everytime on this point

You didn't read DOS did you? All through the comic Superman was holding back and didn't even hurt DD at all. It wasn't till the end of the comic where Superman stopped holding back and hurt DD for the very first time. He went on to kill DD in a few panels. Now you tell me how much power increase is that (to not feeling pain from getting hit to dying).

Did you read OWAW? Remember Superman's first fight with a probe. Clark was using all of his might and all of his powers and still nothing.
Later on, Clark was one shotting them like fodder.
How many times more power is that?

Prove that PG Thor hits harder than non holding back Superman. PG bloodied Thanos face. Thanos smiled because he was enjoying the situation (fighting a crazy Thor and all). Thanos is a little twisted and is not afraid of pain or death. You don't even know your own character.

No, Thor wasn't shown to be more than 2x as strong as his normal non-holding back self based off all the evidence. If you have evidence that shows PG Thor exceeded 2x the strength of his non-holding back self then please share it.

Originally posted by Insane Titan
Thanos let Maesterson Thor beat on him and was putting on show for Death like he was in danger to try and impress her with his courage. Him and Mephisto even talked about the plan.

PG Thor caused actual harm to Thanos with punches alone, hell Thor using his hammer with the same amount of shots and Things help couldn't achieve what PG Thor did and they fought the weak pre Rez Thanos

Thor rocked the shit out of Thanos pre Rez. What are you talking about. Comics back then didn't have a lot of blood in the face to show damage. Many characters, including Hulk, was knocked the phuck out with any signs of damage or blood.

Putting on a show my arse. Thanos face was that of someone getting highly affected by those blows. It's one thing to allow someone to hit you and another to take it without being affected.

Originally posted by Insane Titan
Thanos let Maesterson Thor beat on him and was putting on show for Death like he was in danger to try and impress her with his courage. Him and Mephisto even talked about the plan.

PG Thor caused actual harm to Thanos with punches alone, hell Thor using his hammer with the same amount of shots and Things help couldn't achieve what PG Thor did and they fought the weak pre Rez Thanos

Or, we could go with what actually happened and he was hurt. We saw his reaction showing Masterson-Thor's punches were effecting him before he was giving a serious beatdown.

I read all the story's you mentioned , stop dodging and post your actual proof to back your half assed figures up for you to be taken seriously

Hahaha Thanos smiling at PG is your excuse now , pathetic troll Thanos smiled at a gas giant exploding in his face the made the area un liveable for a millennia , tell me Sheldon what does that mean?

You have seen the proof countless times based on how PG Thor fared against Thanos compared to Thor with Things aid did against the weakest version of Thanos

Originally posted by Delta1938
Or, we could go with what actually happened and he was hurt. We saw his reaction showing Masterson-Thor's punches were effecting him before he was giving a serious beatdown.
so you just ignore Thanos and Mephistos whole conversation about him acting like he was in danger of losing? And the fact even Iron Man or Spider-Man moved him much?

Thor knocked him over that's it and if you think Thor shouting "Thanos must die" is proof lol you need to go read infinity

Originally posted by h1a8
Thor rocked the shit out of Thanos pre Rez. What are you talking about. Comics back then didn't have a lot of blood in the face to show damage. Many characters, including Hulk, was knocked the phuck out with any signs of damage or blood.

Putting on a show my arse. Thanos face was that of someone getting highly affected by those blows. It's one thing to allow someone to hit you and another to take it without being affected.

ha rocked the shit you say , they knocked Thanos and he was still able to talk then fire energy.

Lmao what a piss poor excuse "comics didn't show blood then "

So you ignore the story again? If they effected him so bad how did he function to defend himself?

Everything I've said is backed up by the showing from Thanos vs PG Thor and again the fight in Infinty

Originally posted by h1a8
Then debate my points. Stop being lazy.

1. Superman's strength feats (when he isn't holding back) are clearly greater than Thanos strength feats (who almost never holds back).

2. Superman went from not being able to hurt DD to killing him in a few panels. This is more than a 5x strength difference. DD was wrecking heralds (MM and Guy) with ease.

3. Superman went from using all his might and all of his powers and not doing much to a probe to one shotting them like tissue paper. This is more than a 5x strength difference.

4. So Superman at normal holding back levels is one of the strongest heralds in D.C. but when he lets loose then he is on another level.

5. Thanos greatest strength feats are
7 hitting Surfer with amped power fists
Wrestling with Drax to cause a planet to destroy itself
Any other feats are significantly less.

I challenge you are anyone to debate against one of my points.

Your not debating though. Your pulling random numbers out your ass and lowballing Thanos.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
Your not debating though. Your pulling random numbers out your ass and lowballing Thanos.
👆