Thanos beating up a team of heralds is one thing. Thanos beating up a being with all that power in one body is a completely different beast.
Rogue had the power of almost every Avenger and X-men. With just Hyperion, Captain Britain, Wonder Man and Hulk, Thanos is in for a tough time. From there you start piling on Blue Marvel, Rulk, Starbrand, Namor etc. then how is she not easily one-shotting everyone in this thread aside from Thanos?
Originally posted by One-Punch
Fodder is still fodder.Stacking fodder with more fodder doesn't change the sad fact that elite heroes by their lonesome like Thor, Hyperion, Hulk, Surfer and etc are more powerful than the vast majority of Earth heroes, who are probably in the high-meta and below.
In fact, if a high herald were to let off a planet destroying attack, I can see the vast majority of Earth heroes being vaporized, because almost no heroes below mid-herald have planet-wrecking durability. Maybe a few. But 95% of them would die.
Originally posted by One-Punch
Fodder is still fodder.Stacking fodder with more fodder doesn't change the sad fact that elite heroes by their lonesome like Thor, Hyperion, Hulk, Surfer and etc are more powerful than the vast majority of Earth heroes, who are probably in the high-meta and below.
In fact, if a high herald were to let off a planet destroying attack, I can see the vast majority of Earth heroes being vaporized, because almost no heroes below mid-herald have planet-wrecking durability. Maybe a few. But 95% of them would die.
Stacking Thor, Hulk, and Hyperion alone is trouble for anyone on this team, adding the abilities of powerful metas like, lets say Leech (not an on off button for his powers either), someone who's abilities works on mutants (to my knowledge Thanos is a mutant), and Hope, someone that can steal the powers of whoever is in the vicinity. The list goes on and the crazy thing about it is, Rogue gets the memories on how to use these abilities. She stomps this.
Hell, Marvel combined both Hulk and Thor powers a couple of yr back and those two alone had enough power to take out an army of Red Hulks with ease. Marvel thinks highly of combinations of powers.
Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Thanos beating up a team of heralds is one thing. Thanos beating up a being with all that power in one body is a completely different beast.Rogue had the power of almost every Avenger and X-men. With just Hyperion, Captain Britain, Wonder Man and Hulk, Thanos is in for a tough time. From there you start piling on Blue Marvel, Rulk, Starbrand, Namor etc. then how is she not easily one-shotting everyone in this thread aside from Thanos?
👆
Originally posted by carver9
Stacking Thor, Hulk, and Hyperion alone is trouble for anyone on this team, adding the abilities of powerful metas like, lets say Leech (not an on off button for his powers either), someone who's abilities works on mutants (to my knowledge Thanos is a mutant), and Hope, someone that can steal the powers of whoever is in the vicinity. The list goes on and the crazy thing about it is, Rogue gets the memories on how to use these abilities. She stomps this.Hell, Marvel combined both Hulk and Thor powers a couple of yr back and those two alone had enough power to take out an army of Red Hulks with ease. Marvel thinks highly of combinations of powers.
Not to mention that she only absorbed the powers of the assembled teams of a couple dozen X-Men and Avengers anyways, and all that energy was putting a massive strain on her.
IMO, Thanos vs anti-Exitar Rogue is a repeat of Surfer vs Cable all over again. Rogue's inability to handle the sheer strain of all that power would give prunechin the definitive edge.
I'm going to be the odd ball in this thread and disagree with most of you. I believe we are playing theory fighter a bit too liberally. While I agree that this version of rogue seems pretty hax keep in mind that she is very inexperienced with this measure of power. An argument can be made that she absorbed the power of some geniuses as well giving her a huge advantage in any bout, but this can be countered with the fact that she was being overwhelmed with thoughts and could not contain them complimented with all of that overwhelming power. All of these emotional distractions can be detrimental while fighting.
http://38.media.tumblr.com/75b585b2af903be3ffecfd32ee6d2673/tumblr_n7qkm3Lv7f1se2smco6_500.jpg
Now to some credit we see Rogue's will power in fruition which is very impressive, but how long could she compose herself before she loses control and better yet how long would all of this power last before it slowly deteriorates. Now keeping in mind that this version of rogue is being conflicted with all of these emotions. If she goes into a battle with Thanos he could take advantage of this. Afterall he is a season's vet who also has his fair share of tech/defense and genius. Now I know that this version of rogue outclasses Thanos in strength and abilities but again with the rampant voices racing through her head she would not be able to allocate the tactics and ideals of said geniuses she absorbed. She is basically inexperienced whereas Thanos is VERY experienced. Also knowing that these powers will eventually fade away the question comes to mind. With this inexperience of power can she actually kill or defeat Thanos in a quick fashion? I find that hard to believe. I do not think there is any Thanos wanking in this thread. With the resume and history of Thanos it is safe to question whether or not this rogue "stomps" him which I do not see. Having said that I didn't even mention that the op has given Thanos a team of seasoned heralds, one of them being Surfer. Overall though Rogues inexperience with this power will be her downfall.
