DP
DARTH POWER
Senior Member
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Maul puts up a better fight than Jedi Council did
Originally posted by The_Tempest
Maul? Sure. Savage? No. He lasted only as long as Sidious wanted him to.
That I can buy, given that even Maul can take out Opress in a few seconds, it would be silly to think Sidious can't blitz Opress.
But then Filoni's comments about doing better than the Council were aimed at Opress's performance. So I dunno, the 2 on 1 was probably pretty legit, with Opress being useful as backup, but useless on his own.
S6
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Maul puts up a better fight than Jedi Council did
Originally posted by The_Tempest
Maul? Sure. Savage? No. He lasted only as long as Sidious wanted him to.
👆
ARH
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Maul puts up a better fight than Jedi Council did
Originally posted by DARTH POWER
That I can buy, given that even Maul can take out Opress in a few seconds, it would be silly to think Sidious can't blitz Opress.
Maul executed a technique successfully, which is not a demonstration of superior speed. The fact that he managed to do it within few seconds doesn't make it more impressive either as successful technique can occur at any moment in any given fight. A fight between two world's best boxers can end in first few seconds, doesn't mean one is significantly better than the other.
By your logic I could say: given that Johny punched Andy in the face, it would be silly to think Dilan can't outrun Andy.
DP
DARTH POWER
Senior Member
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Maul puts up a better fight than Jedi Council did
Originally posted by Arhael
Maul executed a technique successfully, which is not a demonstration of superior speed.
Well it was far superior skill (and enough strength to do that to a beast like Savage). In Sidious's case he stronger than Maul at least just as skilled, and faster. So I'm just saying I can see Sidious taking Opress out pretty quickly in a one on one. Dooku also had no trouble taking Opress in seconds in their one on one. It's his lack of skill. He seems to be much more helpful as back up. Back up to Ventress against Dooku. Back up to Maul against Sidious.
His tremendous strength probably causes difficulty to an opponent already in the midst of dealing with another opponent.
Originally posted by Arhael
The fact that he managed to do it within few seconds doesn't make it more impressive either as successful technique can occur at any moment in any given fight. A fight between two world's best boxers can end in first few seconds, doesn't mean one is significantly better than the other.
Well it depends. I wouldn't expect Obi-Wan to take out Savage THAT Fast because Obi-Wan is a defensive fighter, and probably doesn't have the physical strength to take Opress out with one arm twist and one kick.
I personally think if someone can find an opening in my technique and take me out in a few seconds, that would impress me more than someone who spends a minute taking me out.
And with Boxing a knock out punch can come any time, but if 1 opponent wins in the first few seconds of the first round then I don't think anyone would call that close.