Vader and Starkiller vs. Revan and Malgus

Started by The Merchant5 pages

Team 1.

Team 2, IMO.

Revan > Starkiller > Vader > Malgus. Good fight, but Team 1 has intimate dueling and combat experience with one another and should be able to work cooperatively to a far greater extent. Revan's the big kahuna here, but only slightly over Starkiller imo. Malgus is the weak link.

You underestimate Malgus. If he is the weakest, it's really not by much.

Originally posted by Nephthys
You underestimate Malgus.

I don't.

Originally posted by Nephthys
If he is the weakest,

He is.

Originally posted by Nephthys
it's really not by much.

Sure.

Which is why I said it would be a good fight. I give Revan an incremental edge over Starkiller and Vader an incremental edge over Malgus. Team 1's slight advantage comes from the fact that I believe they're closer in power than are Revan and Malgus and their extensive experiences together should enable them to work more effectively as a team than Team 2.

Suggesting Starkiller could take on Marr, Shan, Beniko, Theron, Jakiro, and the Hero, and then be beating them during the duel at some point is lolwory

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Suggesting Starkiller could take on Marr, Shan, Beniko, Theron, Jakiro, and the Hero, and then be beating them during the duel at some point is lolwory

Your inability to spell lolworthy is lolworthy.

I was generous enough to grant Revan's superiority over Starkiller, but Starkiller does indeed have the feats and accolades to hang with him.

Trying to push the issue to satisfy your raging boner for a walking plot device who only titillates you because playing him in a video game made you feel like rlly speshul is silly.

God dammit autocorrect. Conceded, though, I put partial blame on Apple.

To be honest, I'm not giving Starkiller an edge over Hero. Add in Marr, Shan, and friends? A tier different at least.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
God dammit autocorrect. Conceded, though, I put partial blame on Apple.

uhuh

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
To be honest, I'm not giving Starkiller an edge over Hero. Add in Marr, Shan, and friends? A tier different at least.

nah

But we'll see once the actual footage releases. The pitfall of the SWTOR fan is that they often count their chickens before they hatch. Cover your ass brah.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
Revan > Starkiller > Vader > Malgus.

Out of curiosity, what convinces you that Revan edges out Starkiller? Especially given that Clone!Starkiller's force-feats seem to eclipse Revan's by a good margin.

:iwin:

yah. Galen couldn't even beat Shaak Ti without circumstances.
I'm being generous to say Marr wouldn't plow him over.

Originally posted by Stigma
Out of curiosity, what convinces you that Revan edges out Starkiller? Especially given that Clone!Starkiller's force-feats seem to eclipse Revan's by a good margin.

Indeed, but in a hilariously inconsistent franchise, feat wars alone are kind of silly.

Originally posted by DarthAnt666
yah. Galen couldn't even beat Shaak Ti without circumstances.
I'm being generous to say Marr wouldn't plow him over.

Revan had issue with a non-Force sensitive Imperial Guard, Starkiller pwns.

Spoiler:
My son, there's no path you can take here that doesn't end curbside with my boot on the back of your head. Best to just concede and quietly withdraw until you have the means to win the argument.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
:iwin:

yah. Galen couldn't even beat Shaak Ti without circumstances.
I'm being generous to say Marr wouldn't plow him over.

Lol

Originally posted by The_Tempest
Revan had issue with a non-Force sensitive Imperial Guard, Starkiller pwns.

Lol

Revan two-shotted one of the Guards. 😐 Only difficulty he had was when his telekinesis failed due to lack of understanding of Vitiates supreme power.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Revan two-shotted of the Guards. 😐 Only difficulty he had was when his telekinesis failed due to lack of understanding of Vitiates supreme power.

You mean there is relevant context? Sure. That's kinda the point. But we can all lowball here. Either way, though, this isn't an argument you can win. Certainly not until that expansion releases.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
Indeed, but in a hilariously inconsistent franchise, feat wars alone are kind of silly.

Fair enough. Revan compensates with the hype, obviously.

You denying Revan's superiority now only makes your downfall infinitely more embarrassing in December.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
You denying Revan's superiority now only makes your downfall infinitely more embarrassing in December.

lol

Yes, waiting for and expecting conclusive proof of a claim is truly embarrassing.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
lol

Yes, waiting for and expecting conclusive proof of a claim is truly embarrassing.


It is when you already have full dialogue of the fight.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
It is when you already have full dialogue of the fight.

Oh, didn't realize that the transcription provide an exact and complete play-by-play of the fight.