Darth Traya vs Emperor Malgus

Started by Sinious3 pages

Darth Traya vs Emperor Malgus

All Out

Who wins?

Traya shitstomps.

That was fast.

IDK

Malgus takes this one.

Malgus has no response to her drain, though I doubt she could ragdoll him due to him being comparably powerful

Malgus without the drain.

Why is it everyone assumes that drain is her only good technique? she's one of the best stealth characters in the mythos.

Stealth would really have no use in a fight between two powerful Sith like this imo

She has drain. Thats the main point of this thread. Can she use it against very capable and powerful combatants? If so, can she take down top tier sith with it? (Not saying, Malgus is top tier. If she takes this in this thread, I'll make another thread of her against a more powerful opponent)

I'm trying to figure it out atm.

She can.

Nothing is stopping her unless you have a resistance to it, and or are faster than her by a superior margin (i,e Plagueis/Sidious tier).

Malgus ticks none of those, ergo Malgus dies

Originally posted by carthage
Stealth would really have no use in a fight between two powerful Sith like this imo

Windu walked up to Dooku and could have decapitated him without the Count even knowing about it.

Originally posted by AncientPower
Why is it everyone assumes that drain is her only good technique? she's one of the best stealth characters in the mythos.

We're not. But she loses without it to an opponent like Malgus.

Originally posted by AncientPower
Windu walked up to Dooku and could have decapitated him without the Count even knowing about it.

That wasn't a straight-up fight.

Originally posted by AncientPower
Windu walked up to Dooku and could have decapitated him without the Count even knowing about it.

Was that really due to force stealth or incredibly bad script writing by George Lucas? Cmon man what do you think is more likely? Dooku is more powerful than Windu in the force in terms of feats.

Yeah we typically debate straight fights here, not situations where one guy has the drop on another.

Originally posted by carthage
She can.

Nothing is stopping her unless you have a resistance to it, and or are faster than her by a superior margin (i,e Plagueis/Sidious tier).

Malgus ticks none of those, ergo Malgus dies

I doubt that Traya would get insta-blitzed by even Sidious. I also doubt that Sidious would be vulnerable to such technique.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
That wasn't a straight-up fight.

Even alerted, a stab in the back is far from impossible, three lightsabers should certainly prove an advantage, when you can disappear whilst your opponent is busy.

Bar Drain feats she has displayed a bucket ton of impressive Force feats, combative and otherwise.

Originally posted by carthage
Was that really due to force stealth or incredibly bad script writing by George Lucas? Cmon man what do you think is more likely? Dooku is more powerful than Windu in the force in terms of feats.

I am not referring to the film, but Shatterpoint.

She isn't going to sneak up on him, he could sense her as they're on the same tier in power.