Poll
12%
31%
28%
29%
Originally posted by riv6672
They are of course, peers. The only time they havent been peers was pre Crisis.In terms no one will give a damn about, if the two were measured in human terms, they would both be even on squats and dead lifts, but Superman would have Thor by 100lbs on the bench, 25lbs on the military press.
You really think Thor could replicate the feat that preceded this?
Originally posted by Board Walker
Superman has defeated the Hulk, and Thor in every cross over they have been pitted against him.
Yes, but they were portrayed as equals in strength and the fight could have gone both ways, except PC Superman against Hulk. But PC Superman's strength is beyond anthing sans Validus and PC Darkseid.
Originally posted by Prof. T.C McAbe
They are peers. Supes has the better feats, better than Hulk or Thor, yet in a crossover they would be all equals.
How did you come to this conclusion? What does superman having light years better feats have to do with them maybe being equal in your "crossover". Your logic is utter stupid and the only reason you came to it is because you want to vote for thor.
Basically this is what you said "Ya i cant really prove thor is stronger but im going to say some really dumb sh*t so i can vote for him anyway"
Originally posted by thingy150
How did you come to this conclusion? What does superman having light years better feats have to do with them maybe being equal in your "crossover". Your logic is utter stupid and the only reason you came to it is because you want to vote for thor.Basically this is what you said "Ya i cant really prove thor is stronger but im going to say some really dumb sh*t so i can vote for him anyway"
Relax, just because someone doesn't shares your point of view and has a differen't opinion, there is no need to be upset.
Originally posted by Prof. T.C McAbe
Relax, just because someone doesn't shares your point of view and has a differen't opinion, there is no need to be upset.
No, it is not that you don't share the same view, it is because your logic is ridiculous and you cannot prove thor is stronger.
You gave some weird hypothetical as your answer...
You basically just looked for an excuse to pick the character you like better.
Originally posted by Board Walker
Superman has defeated the Hulk, and Thor in every cross over they have been pitted against him.
We're talking about strength. If you cant differentiate between strength and a fight, you shouldnt be posting in this particular thread.
-shrug-
Originally posted by riv6672
We arent talking about a fight, which involves skill, durability, different powers...We're talking about strength. If you cant differentiate between strength and a fight, you shouldnt be posting in this particular thread.
-shrug-
Which brings us to this.
Do you think Thor could benchpress the Earth the way Superman did?
Originally posted by thingy150
No, it is not that you don't share the same view, it is because your logic is ridiculous and you cannot prove thor is stronger.You gave some weird hypothetical as your answer...
You basically just looked for an excuse to pick the character you like better.
Just because you can't understand my logic doesn't mean that i am not allowed to have a differen't opinion. I can base it on anything i want and you will have to accept it as my opinion. I hope that clears any misunderstandings.
Originally posted by LordofBrooklyn
Which brings us to this.
go to pic to prove Superman is THe AweSOme
Do you think Thor could benchpress the Earth the way Superman did?
You know, my knee jerk reaction is to say...no, BUT, not having read the story myself, and with all the hyperbole i've read on the site regarding the feat, i'll have to say...probably.
Originally posted by Prof. T.C McAbe
Just because you can't understand my logic doesn't mean that i am not allowed to have a differen't opinion. I can base it on anything i want and you will have to accept it as my opinion. I hope that clears any misunderstandings.
You are making a claim, you have provided no evidence to back up that claim.
You literally stated the dumbest reason ever for them being equals:
"They are peers. Supes has the better feats, better than Hulk or Thor, yet in a crossover they would be all equals."
You admit superman has better feats but you vote for thor because "in a crossover they would be all equals." that is the dumbest and most flawed logic i have ever seen.
You have no proof of thor being on that level, so you gave a stupid hypothetical.
When making a claim you need evidence to support that said claim, you did not do this.
Originally posted by thingy150
You are making a claim, you have provided no evidence to back up that claim.You literally stated the dumbest reason ever for them being equals:
"They are peers. Supes has the better feats, better than Hulk or Thor, yet in a crossover they would be all equals."
You admit superman has better feats but you vote for thor because "in a crossover they would be all equals." that is the dumbest and most flawed logic i have ever seen.
You have no proof of thor being on that level, so you gave a stupid hypothetical.
When making a claim you need evidence to support that said claim, you did not do this.
See and this is where you fail. In the crossover they were portrayed as equals, they even did armwrestling iirc. Anyway, the second thing is you can't grasp, it doesn't matter what you think, what feats who have, a writer can do whatever he wants and you got to live with it. So there is no truth in comics, no science, just opinions of fans like you and me that don't matter to anyone.