HoT vs. Maul

Started by Stigma6 pages

HoT vs. Maul

Both at their peak.

Setting: Jabba's palace

Who wins?

HoT

Maul easily.

It could go either way imo, it's a glorious fight either way.

HoT.

Based on Nova's respect thread, I'm going with Maul.

Nah HoT isnt as skilled

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
It could go either way imo, it's a glorious fight either way.

Agreed, but siding with the HoT 6/10.

Newguys true colors as TOR fanboy emerge

😂

Originally posted by carthage
Newguys true colors as TOR fanboy emerge

Saying HoT > Maul makes someone a TOR fanboy in your eyes?

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Agreed, but siding with the HoT 6/10.

Yeah, HoT takes this, if with difficulty.

Originally posted by carthage
Newguys true colors as TOR fanboy emerge

"Our greatest student! Our greatest failure." 😛

Can someone tell me something about Hero of Tython that Nova's thread didn't? I'm not seeing how he wins.

-Mind dominating Tol Bragga (If you choose Dark Side)
-Casually collapsing ceiling portions
-Powering through weakened Vitiate's powers on a nexus
-Fighting through the Imperial Guard on a nexus (The guard has killed Dark Council members)
-Defeating Lord Scourge, who's power was as great as any of the Dark Council, before reaching his peak
-Is stronger than Satele and basically everyone else in the Order

Those are pretty much his best feats, give or take. He should be at least on oar with Maul, from that IMO.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
-Mind dominating Tol Bragga (If you choose Dark Side)
-Casually collapsing ceiling portions
-Powering through weakened Vitiate's powers on a powerful nexus
-Fighting through the Imperial Guard on a nexus (The guard has killed Dark Council members)
-Defeating Lord Scourge, who's power was as great as any of the Dark Council, before reaching his peak
-Is stronger than Satele and everyone else in the Order

Those are pretty much his best feats, give or take. He should be at least on oar with Maul, from that IMO.

Unless he uses TP combatively I don't see that mattering.

So Vitiate was.. more or less unamped? Feats for an unamped Vitiate? Or how impressive would you say it is as a feat, I guess? It's more of a defensive feat anyway, so I guess it doesn't matter given Maul would likely win through saber combat.

Aren't Dark Council Members just unquantifiable hype?

Read above.

Eh, Maul is also stronger than Satele fairly comfortably.

Originally posted by ILS
Feats for an unamped Vitiate?

Easily defeating Revan?

Vitiate wasn't just unamped, he was weakened by the failed attempt on his ritual.

Or how impressive would you say it is as a feat, I guess? It's more of a defensive feat anyway,

A good amount better than Ulic's feat against Ominin, to be sure. Yeah, I was talking about his Force defenses.

Aren't Dark Council Members just unquantifiable hype?

We have a good idea of how strong they tend to be, from the ones we've seen. If it means anything, Nyriss had resigned that the Imperial guard would kill her, and we know how strong she is.

Maul is also stronger than Satele

I know, and the point is that the Hero is too.

A good amount better than Ulic's feat against Ominin, to be sure. Yeah, I was talking about his Force defenses.
Ulic wasn't using his lightsaber though, but just his Force shields. Ulic was on a nexus as well.
We have a good idea of how strong they tend to be, from the ones we've seen. If it means anything, Nyriss had resigned that the Imperial guard would kill her, and we know how strong she is.
Eh. To be honest I can agree with HoT being comparable to Maul in power but I see Maul as more skilled, for definite.

Hero wins solidly. Suggesting a mere Sith Apprentice can defeat one of the Jedi Order's most famous champions is quite pathetic.