This is an interesting fight as Superman is very limited and can use only Hulks powerset, it is a fight of two equally strong chars, one with invulnerability one with HF vs each other. Current Hulk seems weaker than Superman though but he should be able to amp i hope, his HF also is, when we consider the Rulk fight, not the best, so I would go with Superman for a slight majority. 6-7/10.
Originally posted by Prof. T.C McAbe
This is an interesting fight as Superman is very limited and can use only Hulks powerset, it is a fight of two equally strong chars, one with invulnerability one with HF vs each other. Current Hulk seems weaker than Superman though but he should be able to amp i hope, his HF also is, when we consider the Rulk fight, not the best, so I would go with Superman for a slight majority. 6-7/10.
Superman seems to heal too though.
I'm sure that the Hulk can amp, but what have we seen from current Hulk that puts him on Superman's level?
And I'm not talking about whatever Carver, TheHulk, Hulkrulez99 (or whatever retarded names these troglodytes go by) claims to be the greatest feat ever. But have you, as the sensible poster we know, seen any Hulk feats that can compete with DCNU Superman? 😛
Originally posted by krisblaze
Superman seems to heal too though.I'm sure that the Hulk can amp, but what have we seen from current Hulk that puts him on Superman's level?
And I'm not talking about whatever Carver, TheHulk, Hulkrulez99 (or whatever retarded names these troglodytes go by) claims to be the greatest feat ever. But have you, as the sensible poster we know, seen any Hulk feats that can compete with DCNU Superman? 😛
Yes but it's not his thing, he is more of the invulnerability guy and Hulk the HF. ^^
Nothing, I know that DCnU Superman is far above most Hulks, arguably even WBH, by feats, still I think we should also go by portrayals and what they represent. I base my opinion mostly on a "what if they made a crossover" and there I think Hulk would be Supermans equal in terms of strength, even if he has "worse" feats.
From current Hulk I haven't, but Mr. Fixit, even if he had help, WBH, WWH (fights), and some of Savage Hulks feats could come close. Also we shouldn't only go by highest showings. ^^
I don't advocate going by highest showings, but if we're going to go by "what they represent". Then how they would fare against eachother in a crossover would essentially be :
Superman/Cap Wins
Hulk/Batman comes close
Sniktbub/Spidey whoever almost pulls it home.
Thor/Wonder Woman does Okay.
It just seems like such a copout to have your answer be what you think would happen in a crossover. Almost everybody here, aside from a few muckers, are more or less aware of the state of industry and how popularity determines these things 😛
Originally posted by krisblaze
I don't advocate going by highest showings, but if we're going to go by "what they represent". Then how they would fare against eachother in a crossover would essentially be :Superman/Cap Wins
Hulk/Batman comes close
Sniktbub/Spidey whoever almost pulls it home.
Thor/Wonder Woman does Okay.It just seems like such a copout to have your answer be what you think would happen in a crossover. Almost everybody here, aside from a few muckers, are more or less aware of the state of industry and how popularity determines these things 😛
😂 👆 that's true.
What do you mean he fights to his speed? So basically he stands there and watches as hulks slow ass fist comes to his face....
This battle is not superman vs hulk because you took away everything that makes superman, superman. Never liked threads where you have to take away multiple abilities to make it fair.
Other than above, not touching this nonsense.
Originally posted by krisblaze
Superman seems to heal too though.I'm sure that the Hulk can amp, but what have we seen from current Hulk that puts him on Superman's level?
And I'm not talking about whatever Carver, TheHulk, Hulkrulez99 (or whatever retarded names these troglodytes go by) claims to be the greatest feat ever. But have you, as the sensible poster we know, seen any Hulk feats that can compete with DCNU Superman? 😛
This is laughable. Also, ALL of Hulk fts belong to him. Once you all realize that his power is to amp, things would bloom for you. Whatever he's done on panel was done via his powerset. No outside amps intended.
You might want to look at Hulk strength fts before claiming arch things.
The Rulk and Doc Green fight while impressive in some ways, is somewhat diminished for Ross since it was specifically made clear that Doc Green lured him into that setting solely to capture enough data with the gamma spectrometer.
Anyone who thinks otherwise is either trolling or can't comprehend what's written on panel.
Originally posted by celeyhyga17
The Rulk and Doc Green fight while impressive in some ways, is somewhat diminished for Ross since it was specifically made clear that Doc Green lured him into that setting solely to capture enough data with the gamma spectrometer.Anyone who thinks otherwise is either trolling or can't comprehend what's written on panel.
👆
ABHI even admitted this himself. He knows the context.
Originally posted by thingy150 [/i]
What do you mean he fights to his speed? So basically he stands there and watches as hulks slow ass fist comes to his face....This battle is not superman vs hulk because you took away everything that makes superman, superman. Never liked threads where you have to take away multiple abilities to make it fair.
Other than above, not touching this nonsense.
Yes, just like he's done with the hordes of other characters who have hit him in the face throughout his career.
Then you are more than welcome to occupy a different thread 👆
Originally posted by Damborgson
Yes, just like he's done with the hordes of other characters who have hit him in the face throughout his career.Then you are more than welcome to occupy a different thread 👆
Which is, in a Forum fight, PIS. In a comic book I see a slowpoke like Hulk, compared to Kal, hit Superman but in a Forum fight where they use their abilities in a smart way, not so much. That's the reason why I think that this thread, which depowers Kal, makes it at least a fair FORUM fight.
Originally posted by Damborgson
Yes, just like he's done with the hordes of other characters who have hit him in the face throughout his career.Then you are more than welcome to occupy a different thread 👆
Just like prof said, PIS in some cases. Other cases people with super speed and reflexes hit him. Hulk has zero feats of reaction time and speed that are on supermans level.
Your comment is basically a dumb excuse to ignore speed advantages.
The fact that you need to severely handicap Superman for this to even be a fight says it all. Why not seal the deal and give Hulk a pair of purple pants that radiate both kryptonite and red sunlight? This essentially tells us Hulk can defeat a Superman who has been relegated to forgetting 99% of his powers. Which, okay..yay?
Originally posted by carver9
This is laughable. Also, ALL of Hulk fts belong to him.
Wasn't there a version of Hulk who was one of the Four Horsemen of Apocalypse at one point?
[QUOTE33320]Originally posted by thingy150
Just like prof said, PIS in some cases. Other cases people with super speed and reflexes hit him. Hulk has zero feats of reaction time and speed that are on supermans level.
Your comment is basically a dumb excuse to ignore speed advantages. [/QUOTE]
Im not arguing on favor of Hulk having comparable speed to Superman.
The thread was made with that specific purpose. Tonignore the advantages that Superman has, and make it a test of strength. It's hardly unique among other threads that do the same.
If you don't like it, then go to another thread. Is that hard for you to understand? No one is keeping you here, and if it bothers you that the fight becomes so much closer under these stips, then start arguing for one or the other. Otherwise, keep your trolling urges under control.
Originally posted by Surtur
The fact that you need to severely handicap Superman for this to even be a fight says it all. Why not seal the deal and give Hulk a pair of purple pants that radiate both kryptonite and red sunlight? This essentially tells us Hulk can defeat a Superman who has been relegated to forgetting 99% of his powers. Which, okay..yay?Wasn't there a version of Hulk who was one of the Four Horsemen of Apocalypse at one point?
Are you arguing that Hulk will win? Because I don't see that as the case.
And then people wonder why Superman fans are considered to be so annoying.