Jaina Solo vs. Hero of Tython

Started by Stigma3 pages
Stigma Herald of the Judgement

Jaina Solo vs. Hero of Tython

Both at their best.

No amp/prep time.

Setting: Senate rotunda

Who wins?

Nephthys The Gr8est!!!!!!!!

Hero. Just better. Interesting arena tho.

Trocity Undefeated and Undisputed
Originally posted by Nephthys
Jaina. Just better. Interesting arena tho.
Q99 Senior Member

I go with Tythy too, Jaina's good but not yet as good as her. Cool fight.

Sinious Yo Da Best

HoT

ares834 Senior Member

Jaina.

Angelalex242 Senior Member

Jaina. Flashy as videogames are, they cannot compete with competent Skywalkers.

Nephthys The Gr8est!!!!!!!!

The HoT is probably the least flashy MC in swtor actually. And the most powerful.

Sinious Yo Da Best

👆

Dark-Kenshin Blocked
Originally posted by Nephthys
Hero. Just better. Interesting arena tho.
carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES

Not sure

Arhael Devoid of reality
Originally posted by Angelalex242
Jaina. Flashy as videogames are, they cannot compete with competent Skywalkers.
carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES

I can be swayed if you post me kills for Jaina that are better than Scourge lol

NewGuy01 perpetual

Darth Caedus.

Angelalex242 Senior Member

Even a weakened Caedus is still Caedus. He was probably still fighting as a 9 instead of his usual 9.5.

carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES

Hero hasn't beaten anyone impressive at all in terms of dueling, and Mara did better against Caedus (yeah there were circumstances) than Jaina. Its hard to place either of them skillfully.

Not sure still

Angelalex242 Senior Member

One reason of many I cheer for Mara whenever I get the chance. The Batman of Star Wars she is.

Still, Jaina should be able to handle Hero well enough.

ILS Restricted

Originally posted by Angelalex242
Even a weakened Caedus is still Caedus. He was probably still fighting as a 9 instead of his usual 9.5.
You're vastly underrating how poor of a state he was in, thus undermining how great his Force reserves are and overrating Jaina's performance against him.

Arhael Devoid of reality

Originally posted by ILS
You're vastly underrating how poor of a state he was in, thus undermining how great his Force reserves are and overrating Jaina's performance against him.

He is not, missing arm was his only poor state, which he compensated by one-handed lightsaber style(which can be as effective as two-handed), unarmed combat and cunning offensive Force use. As of stomach wound, it only made him stronger.

Nephthys The Gr8est!!!!!!!!

Didn't he also have a shoulder wound? And probably a few others from their last fight and other shit that I can't recall?

Which arm was it that he lost? Was it his saber arm?

Originally posted by Angelalex242
One reason of many I cheer for Mara whenever I get the chance. The Batman of Star Wars she is.

Still, Jaina should be able to handle Hero well enough.

I don't see why. The Hero has just as good feats as her if not better in numerous aspects. Defeating Vitiate in the Dark Temple > beating a wounded Caedus imo. The Hero showed herself able to resist the Force powers of Vitiate and Sel Makor, both near godlike beings, in the heart of their power. Which is better than getting tossed around by Jacen non-stop. She's also blitzed Sith and torn through legions of elite troops in diminished capacity. She's basically the greatest swordsman of her time, with only the Wrath rivaling her, based on her beating Scourge, Praven, Angral and others, becoming Jedi Battlemaster and with numerous accolades of her being their greatest warrior and possessing legendary and unequalled martial skill.

I see no reason why the Hero couldn't have beaten Caedus in the same situation as Jaina.