Karnak Vs Lady Shiva

Started by riv66723 pages

Karnak Vs Lady Shiva

New 52 Shiva.
No prep. No BFR.

Karnak.

**** the haters.

Karnak SHOULD win this.....

So, 4 stars and one vote for Karnak....

Shiva

I honestly wonder.
Dont think Karnak's as skilled, but his weak point strike power's no joke...

Karnak

i give it *****.

I bet you do! 😛

Karnak

Karnak is more skilled.

His ability isn't inborn or something. He got that from meditating.

He can detect the impossible flaw in any plan, any power, anything. This isn't pressure points, this is beyond that.

Shiva can hit you and make you die a week later.

Shiva

Pretty even, response wise. Neat.

Originally posted by Golgo13
Shiva can hit you and make you die a week later.

And she can actually fight, unlike a certain Inhuman.

Seriously, the only way Karnak wins is if nu-Shiva is a total loser.

^ 👆

i haven't seen nu shiva. preboot would def take karnak out. like any really good street guy likely would.

How skillful IS Karnak?
Without his ability to detect/exploit weak points?
How would he rate then? Top 10? 20? 30?

hard to say it in those terms. imo (and they may vary) in terms of pure skill he...isn't great. certainly below guys like daredevil imo. i dunno. h2h i could see him being a good match against someone like punisher maybe? karnak just doesn't have a lot of feats and no real wins against any of the big guys. kind of the opposite actually--he usually gets his a$$ handed to him....

Karnak latest showing had him taking it to a small group of Avengers and busting through a cell built to hold the Hulk. He takes this.

i've not read the very latest avengers, but even if that is true, daredevil has taken it to the avengers and breaking sh!t is what his POWER is. finding a weakness in a structure is....what he SHOULD do. hitting a high level street guy/ma guy? wayyyy different and it's been shown that his skill level doesn't match up.

^^^Yeah the whole "brick not hit back" thing...