Originally posted by Delta1938
But none of that is what you argued of Spidey webbing him up, spinning him around and smashing him into the environment, either through the floor after I pointed-out it's a default featureless environment, or even against normal city stuff(just to prove he uses tactics like that in general).My point was both characters have feats that are well outside what they should be. I would rank what Batman did above Spidey supporting a building, but I wouldn't actually argue Batman really is stronger than Spider-Man.
😕 You didn't admit missing the featureless environment when I brought it up, but you did when I pointed-out you didn't say anything about it(just changed your argument to through the ground), so I didn't say anything after. Not sure why you're bringing this up now. Same with the Batman point.
Goliath/Atlas is supposed to be in the same class, and I think Tigershark as well(I mixed up that scene with She-Hulk's beating in SECRET WARS somewhat, it was actually Wrecking Crew, Mister Hyde, Tigershark and Goliath). And Hercules was compromised even before he got there, and they all beat his unconscious body after he was defeated. It's not an accurate comparison at all.
Are you actually going to continue with this featureless environment situation? i mean is there a point aside from the fact that i missed that no description for the battlefield was actually given in the OP? I mean what is the point in continuing to bring it up for? Actually lets just deep six it, because I did say what happened in my mind. Are you looking for a crucifixion over something this minute? Lets just drop it, because it doesn't really matter.
You were hinting at Batman and other characters taking on things above their weight class from the start (mainly Batman). I just made it clear that i didn't miss the point form the first post that you hinted on it, however I wasn't intent on biting either. This seemed to me like you were indirectly calling any high end feat above Spiderman's weight class PIS, but I could be wrong. However It still keeps happening. On one hand, you seem to be sticking me with the featureless environment clause/ruling, while on the other, there is also a ruling in place that if something keeps happening it's no longer considered PIS.
Now let's talk about class in terms of lifting strength. Neither Tiger Shark, Mr, Hyde,Goliath, and any of the other Masters of Evil of that period were remotely within Hercules' strength class. The same goes for Ares. But you take one showing like others, and highlight it, because one writer had him do extremely well against him. This happened one time only, and you wouldn't consider that PIS? It only happened once. While on the other hand, Spiderman has taken out characters well above his weight class, and not due completely to strength, but power set, character and combat technique.
Originally posted by tkitna
Understood that Peter wouldn't fight like that, but what does Spidey have in his arsenal that's the equivalent of 15 or more haymakers from an enraged Hercules (in which Ares was pretty much unphased)? I've also read some talk that Spiderman would dance around and tire Ares out. Really? Ares is the Greek God of war. I truthfully think Spiderman is going to tire before Ares does. How long does somebody think the fight would go? I could see Ares fighting for days. Spiderman,,,not so much. Ares just needs to get his hands on him and eventually he would.
This is exactly what I just finished saying to Delta, Ares had one good showing, which could be considered PIS, because he has yet to prove that he is even close to Hercules in strength. Not only this, but Hercules, and anyone in his weight class has proven that they were always portrayed above Ares in terms of strength. Heck Namor isn't even as strong as Hercules at his best, and he's stronger than Ares under his most optimal condition (hydrated). My point is that people are really trying to drive one low showing of Hercules against Ares, while calling Spiderman's dozens of feats PIS. If Spiderman can hurt the Absorbing Man amplified with stone for greater durability, and who is actually a true class 100, why wouldn't he be able to hurt Ares? Ares does not, and never has been touted as being invulnerable.
Tough? Sure, but not invulnerable. This isn't going to last for hours, and days, it's going to take minutes or less if we take Spiderman's feats at face value. It didn't take him hours and days to hurt Creel, Namor, Rhino, Rogue (classic), etc. It's not going to take him that long to hurt Ares. Now can Ares win this? Absolutely. But so can Peter, he just has to be at the top of his game, and not get hit.
Originally posted by tkitna
Ares wasn't even close to being KO'd. He busted Herc on the very next panel.
Was Herc fighting to kill? Was Ares? This is really something that needs investigating. There are different levels of pain that a character of Herc's power can deal out if he was going for the kill. Ares on the other hand is always going for the kill.