ROTJ Vader and Sith Ulic vs FE Malgus and SoD Maul

Originally posted by carthage
Kindly prove that he wasn't going "all out". Windu has no problems letting others know their faults in sparring matches like he held back against Quinlan Vos. Tiin is canonically one of the most skilled fighters produced by the Jedi order, and what? he lost to Dooku in his sparring matches and obviously that's reaching to compare him to Yoda. He openly admitted inferiority to Yoda.

Burden of proof is on you. Prove he was going all out.

He couldn't best Maul even with the backup of Aayla Secura (yeah, SOD Maul is slightly more skilled than in TPM), and Vader took multiple disabling blows and killed a replica of TPM Maul. That was before his prime in ROTJ.

In a duel that literally lasted one comic book panel. Lel. Not to mention his Mando's felt it necessary to intervene shortly into the battle.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
Malgus has been in the battlefield for decades. Don't you think that he would have faced these kind of situations?

Sidious's personal assessment is that Malgus's battlefield feats have never been duplicated.

Malgus have defeated foes with feats that can be safely counted as being among the best in the mythos. As an example: a Jedi (powerhouse) simultaneously collapsed two buildings around the position of Malgus in an attempt to crush the Sith Lord beneath the massive rubble. However, such power was not enough to stop Malgus.

Vader's top TK showings are not enough to stop Malgus.

Malgus is not the great deulist/force user you make him out to be just because someone says something doesn't mean that much like what sidious holds little wait and when have you seen sidious in a battlefield engagement all the jedi and sith of the old republic went up against blisters not light sabers but when they were tested they faired well and vader could defeat statele Shan and the hero of typhon and anyone else so malgus loses and what sort of feats does malgus have that rival vader

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
all the jedi and sith of the old republic went up against blisters not light sabers

the jedi and sith of the old republic went up against blisters

went up against blisters

blisters

Originally posted by Trocity
[B]the jedi and sith of the old republic went up against blisters

went up against blisters

blisters [/B]

Blasters* my bad like windu he didn't really go up against lightsaber wielding foes that often neither did yoda or any jedi just BLASTERS